Software
Houzz Logo Print
andreajoyames

your favorite determinate roma?

18 years ago

i have my list of tomatoes for 2008 but i'm stuck when it comes to ordering a determinate roma. i want a determinate variety because i want to can tomatoes this year and i want to harvest most of my tomatoes at one time.

so what is your opinion on the best determinate roma tomato?

are there any disease resistant varieties worth trying? i do have one garden bed with nematodes and i've seen a few hybrid romas out there that have resistance to nematodes...but i'm not sure if their flavor is any good...

thanks..

a

Comments (19)

  • 18 years ago

    I've not grown any hybrid romas, but my favoite non-hybrid determinate roma is Martino's Roma.

    Lovely deep green rugose foliage and looks like a small Xmas tree when the fruits are ripe. Has no known, to me at least, tolerance against nematodes.

    And nematode tolerant varieties only allow for a bit more life to the tomato plants anyway; it isn't resistance, it's tolerance. ( smile)

    Carolyn

  • 18 years ago

    To me Plum Crimson (F1,2,3, V), Plum Dandy (EB, F1, V) and Peto 882 (F1,2) are quantitatively better than a typical roma and carry some disease resistance (Plum Dandy has some early blight resistance).

    There are also a number of short stature indeterminate plums (often referred to as "saladettes" by the companies) worth checking out. Not only do these carry disease resistance but the short indeterminate habits tend to produce better tasting fruits with higher brix values. These are worth checking out if you intend to use some for fresh eating. Due to hybrid vigor, these are higher yielding than open pollinated lines.

    I think Peto 882 has been replaced with other lines.


    I'm working on short stature indeterminate plums that have the vintage line Olpaka in their background but they still have more work to go.

  • 18 years ago

    note: many saladettes are not short stature indeterminates
    look carefully when deciding

  • 18 years ago

    andreajp,

    This summer I plan to try out two new-to-me hybrid, determinate saladette/roma types ... Plum Crimson, on Mule's recommendation and because it sets all its tomatoes at once, and Capaya because it looked good, big and determinate, and I'm hoping it'll work in the Midwest although it's bred for Cal/Mex.

    I already got the seeds for Plum Crimson (NC EBR-7 x NC Ebr-8), a fresh market plum Roma line bred by Dr. Randy Gardner at the NCSU program and distributed by Harris Moran from Parks Seed whose blurb says "it sets all its tomatoes at once."

    Capaya is bred by Seminis, who produces a gob of tomatoes for the California and Mexican soils and climate conditions. I'll be getting Capaya from Totally Tomatoes whose 2008 print catalog says, Totally Tomatoes says, "Capaya Hybrid VFAStTSWV Tomato, 70 days, Firm saladette perfect for all kinds of tomato dishes. Clusters of smooth red, slightly heart-shaped, 6 - 8 ounce fruits are mild flavored and hold well after harvest. Excellent disease resistance includes Tomato Spotted Wilt Virus, which is becoming a big problem for growers everywhere. Determinate."

    About Capaya, North Carolina State University Cultivar Lists says, "Capaya (PS 151476) - Vendor: Seminis Vegetable Seeds-Petoseed. Parentage: F1 hybrid. Characteristics: vigorous, determinate, long shelf-life, saladette type; large plant; may work on ground or staked; fruit are semi-elongated, very smooth with good girth; very firm fruit with good color. Resistance: Alternaria stem canker, root Knot Nematode, Fusarium wilt, gray leaf spot, Verticillium wilt, tomato spotted wilt. Similar: Toro, Conquistador. Adaptation: NAFTA - Mexico. 2004."

    Good luck with your search for a determinate Roma-type with a big, concentrated set, and good luck with your 2008 garden!

    Bill

  • 18 years ago

    Heidi did quite well for me last year. I was pleased with it. It's one to consider.

  • 18 years ago

    I'm just going to add my Amen to a couple of recommendations
    made earlier in this string. Martino's Roma and Heidi are both excellant.

    I'm also going to suggest 3 indeterminates for consideration; though it's true that these will not yield all at once they have an excellent taste, have good desease tolerance, and have been prolific yielders for me over the years here in zone 6.
    Idaho Hillbilly
    Opalka
    San Marzano Gigantica (A Franchi Sementi Variety)

  • 18 years ago

    I grew Plum Crimson before it became commercially available with seeds Dr. Gardner sent me. You won't be disappointed in it. It will grow about three feet tall max and produce like crazy with most fruit ripening within a few days' time. They look just like the larger plum types that you see in the store, and since they won't be harvested prematurely they will get that extra flavor of ripening completely on the vine. They taste good as well. I found using ordinary tomato cages that I secured to stakes made out of heavy conduit did just fine. I can't say how much production I had, but it was impressive and I never got BER. I didn't grow any this year, but I will probably do at least a couple of them this next year.

  • 18 years ago

    Heidi did quite well for me last year. I was pleased with it. It's one to consider.

    ***

    Douglas, I don't know how I could have forgotten to mention Heidi along with Martino's Roma, b'c Heidi is just outstanding in all ways as far as I'm concerned. And I see Larry likes it as well.

    Carolyn

  • 18 years ago

    I won't argue with Jim's recommendation of Opalka as a great tomato ... it tastes wonderful and produces well ... but it's not the determinate cultivar that Andreajp is asking for in the original post. Likewise Heidi, which produces like crazy, has a Roma fruit shape, but like Opalka, does not ripen its fruit in a concentrated set as sought by Andreajp.

    On the other hand, I am really encouraged by Tomatomike's report that Plum Crimson "will grow about three feet tall max and produce like crazy with most fruit ripening within a few days' time" indicating it is a determinate cultivar with a tightly concentrated set and possibly what Andreajp is looking for, as expressed in the original post.

  • 18 years ago

    I have a couple of pictures of the Plum Crimson I grew and will post them this evening after I get to the house and the computer they are on.

  • 18 years ago

    Two others came to mind. One you can find fairly easily and the other I sent LOTS of seed of to the TomatoMania list on y@h00 groups.

    The first is Mama Mia. I really liked this. The fruit had a wonderful flavor. I know its determinate but it seemed like I picked it once heavy and then a few times after that harvest (that is not that unheard of for some determinates). I would seek this one out.

    The other is an old vintage variety called 71B2 from the early 40's. It produces like crazy and has a very nice deep rich taste. It's not a "sweet" one. It has what I would call "tomatoey" flavor - what you would expect from a paste. This line I came across because it has resistance to early blight. I am not 100% certain, but Im pretty sure that it is an early parent in the development of the parents that went into making Plum Crimson and Plum Dandy. The fruit are much smaller.

  • 18 years ago

    Here is a picture of Plum Crimson just before the ripening stage. Note the similar size of the fruits and the clusters. This is the only pic I could find at the moment. This would be showing about 1/4th of one side of the plant.

  • 18 years ago

    How nice those tomatoes are! I am always fascinated by tomato leaves, I think those are nice healthy looking leaves.

    Is that a Bert and Ernie fabric you made the ties from? I think I see Bert above the two bright green toms, lol!

  • 18 years ago

    No Trudi, those are Teenage Mutant Nija Turtles!! LOL. We recycle what we can...This year it wat all black. I did not see a difference in the growth pattern between the two :) Strips from my DS bed and such over the years.

  • 18 years ago

    Donatello strikes again, lol!

    I used to make strip quilts and used the extras in the garden. Every now and then a piece of green and red reindeer fabric comes up when I'm turning the beds ;-)

  • 18 years ago

    How sweet is the Heidi? Not technically, but generally when compared to a decent (not genetically "washed out") roma?

  • 18 years ago

    Well, here I go, about to step in the xxxx, because taste is
    pretty much an individual matter.

    Heidi is not so much sweet as tasty to me. This would suggest that it offers some acid/sweet balance. I find I can enjoy them eaten fresh off the vine (with a little salt, of course).

    Frankly, Roma tomatoes taste like yuck to me and are only good for canning as they are very dry and make a thicker sauce with a bit less boiling down.

    Evidently my taster is pretty insensitive as my favorite varieties are all pretty strong tasting, like Yellow Brandywine. This came about when my smeller got cooked working in a dry bleach plant a number of years ago: I understand that smelling and tasting are somehow intwined.

    Actually, this has some benefit on occasion, don't you know.

  • 18 years ago

    I can attest to Opalka... I can - a lot and I love it... several years ago I swore off romas - may be I shouldn't have been so hasty??? Taking notes now: Heidi, Martino's Roma, Plum Crimson??? Do they compare to opalka for taste????

    Tom-

  • 17 years ago

    I just wanted to revive this thread and see if anyone could answer Tom's question. I'd like to know the answer to it myself.

    Kim

Sponsored
Custom Home Works
Average rating: 4.6 out of 5 stars10 Reviews
Franklin County's Award-Winning Design, Build and Remodeling Expert