Software
Houzz Logo Print
wwu123

How efficient are gas burners?

14 years ago

I'm just curious how efficient a gas burner (properly adjusted with a nice blue flame) is at converting natural gas to heat? Both what is the combustion efficiency of converting gas to heat, and then how much of the heat transfers to the pan? Does the rest go to heating the air?

For example, we know most new gas furnaces are rated between 80-95% total to convert the gas to heat and then to transfer the heat to the air exchanger, with the remaining heat or uncombusted gases going out the flue.

On some of these pro-style ranges, let's say three 20K burners running on high is 60K BTU's, which is about the same capacity as a furnace for a new insulated 2000 sq ft home. That's a lot of BTU's. Some fraction of the BTU's is going to heat that is cooking the food - is the rest that's not cooking ending up as uncombusted gas and byproducts, or basically heating up the indoor air much the same as a gas furnace? (I'm ignoring heated air going out the hood for starters.)

Comments (16)

  • 14 years ago

    The cool thing about pro-style ranges is that they still have knobs that can be turned down! :) Having 20K BTUs available on a burner is not an obligation to use it.

    How much of the heat goes into the air with gas? A lot.

    But you also have to remember that BTUs is really BTUs per hour, so with a smaller burner you just might have to have it on for longer so the amount of heat transferred to the environment over time is not necessarily less.

    That said, if you want absolute efficiency go with induction. There is no comparison.

    -Stooxie

  • 14 years ago

    Not as efficient as electric ones!

  • 14 years ago

    Based on the data available from the link below, the measured efficiency of gas based ranges, both open and sealed burners, is in the low 30%'s. Induction is above 80%.

    I know I've paraded this link around before but it's a nice piece of real world data that speaks to lots of perfomance questions that people have re: open vs sealed, induction vs gas, brand A vs brand B.

    Here is a link that might be useful: The People's Test

  • 14 years ago

    That is certainly an interesting chart, laranbrian. The colors made my eyes hurt! I'm wondering, though: Did they use the BTU rating of the burner in the calculation? Or the "energy used in theory," which is based on the total BTU rating? Because if I were boiling water on my gas stove I wouldn't normally turn the burner all the way to the max.
    It would be fascinating to see an experiment that actually measured the consumption and put a cost to it as well. Still, your point appears to be well made about induction. DH loves cooking on gas and doesn't want to take a chance on hating induction, or I'd consider that for the new house.

  • 14 years ago

    I've been waiting for Kas to chime in, but regarding Hilltop's comments and Laranbrian's source, the number I usually see from companies touting induction is that gas stoves are 60% efficient. Don't know where that number comes from or how it's calculated either. It seems that there is agreement, however, that it's significantly less efficient than the OP's example of the efficient furnace or induction (the lowest I remember seeing for that is 89%, but again, haven't a clue where the numbers come from. All of them could have been made up by the secretary for all I know. Statistics often are, then get repeated ad nauseum after they're published, even when it's easy to test whether they're correct or not).

  • 14 years ago

    I don't think gas beats electric in efficiency in anything, only thing it comes close in and may even edge out electric is gas furnaces and maybe water heaters.

    But even our water heater a "Marathon" is basically the same as using gas because the rest of the water heater is so efficient.

    As far as cost to run gas is better UNLESS your house is powered by solar panels & wind turbines then electric is virtually free.

  • 14 years ago

    Chime!

    Actually, I don't know the efficiency of gas burners in heating pans, but I've read estimates somewhere. I think it is addressed at The Induction Site.

    Note that efficiency in heat transfer has to be adjusted for cost per BTU expended in order to compare pan heating costs.

    kas

    Here is a link that might be useful: The Induction Site

  • 14 years ago

    Here's a comparison of the different heating element efficiencies from the cooktop test.

    This may be a little easier to adsorb! It shows that induction (and radiant too) blow gas burners away with respect to the efficiency of energy transfer to a pot full of water. Granted there are a bunch of confounding factors and all that, but my interpretation is that...

    1) induction is waaaay more efficient than gas.

    2) induction is capable of delivering more energy to the food than gas is (in the context of the indoor cooking appliances tested).

    3) There is not a statistically significant difference between the effectiveness of open and sealed gas burners.

    While these data were generated by many contributors under a variety of conditions, I still feel that they are representative of the results that one could expect to see in a real world cooking environment. Sure, under tightly controlled conditions one may be able to discern a difference between open and sealed gas burners, but that difference is not enough to stand out from the environments in different cooking scenarios.
    BTW I like cooking with gas even though it is obviously not the most efficient way to do it!

  • 14 years ago

    ..............and the point of all this is ?????

  • 14 years ago

    The OP asked for how efficient a gas burner was at getting heat into a pan, and then presumably the contents of the pan. Along the way induction was mentioned as being more efficient at the whole process. The data from the People's test tells us exactly these things. I linked to the test and then took the data from the test and put it in a graph to make it more interpretable to the casual viewer. Yeah, its overkill but someone else out there may find it interesting.

    Viola, we have numbers to directly compare the efficiency of the different types of heating elements in real kitchen environments.

    The short answer to the OP is 33%-35%. The rest of the info is just for the further edification of the TKO collective.

  • 14 years ago

    Thank you, Laranbrian. I find your posts on this matter to be quite interesting and informative. LIke you, and notwithstanding the apparent "inefficency" of gas, I much prefer cooking with it (currently on a range with sealed burners no less) no matter what! :-)

  • 14 years ago

    Gas is fun though, inductions seems soo boring, and don't even get me started on radiant electric......

  • 14 years ago

    uggghm - fire good - real men cook with combustion

  • 14 years ago

    I just completed the "the peoples test" in 4 minutes 5 seconds raising the temperature of a gallon of water from 70.2 F to 160+ F in a tri-clad 6 quart dutch oven Marcus Ware closeout from Regal Ware on a Cooktec 3.5 kw hob. Colin's time on the same hob was a little longer but his pot was 8.5" in diameter and mine is 10" across so I think the results are comparable.
    We used to have gas and after 3 years of induction cooking would never go back!

  • 14 years ago

    An interesting article.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Improving Range-Top Efficiency with Specialized Vessels

  • 14 years ago

    "Statistics often are [made up], then get repeated ad nauseum after they're published, even when it's easy to test whether they're correct or not."

    Plllog: I believe I read that only 37.6% of statistics are made up. ;)