Software
Houzz Logo Print
cdbva

Success With Xtreme Clay

18 years ago

I'm going to try some tomatoes this year, and I wondered what would be the best strategy for extremely clay-ey soil. I met someone at a local nursery who said she ended up removing her clay and putting in totally new soil.

Last spring I tried mixing 2/3 store-bought soil with 1/3 of the original clay, and my herbs and flowers still were not completely happy, even though I fed them. They'd enjoy their food (Miracle Grow) for a few days and then get all depressed again. Someone said maybe I didn't dig down far enough.

I'm going to try 3 or 4 tomatoes this year. Any thoughts would be most welcome.

Christine

Comments (30)

  • Thank you for some amazingly pithy and detailed responses. Just the sort of thing I was hoping for, from planting medium to pH to several options for dealing with the dastardly dirt. Looking into this stuff will keep me happy for a month at least.

    This local clay is perplexing. People have been tearing down their houses to build McMansions, and I've noticed that the original 50s era homes seem all to have had just a thin layer of sod laid down over pure red clay. I left a little pile at the end of my garden space, and nothing grew in it all summer. There only are a few straggly leaves of grass in it now.

    Well, I'm looking forward to some real tomatoes. I've always gotten them from the farmer's market, but this year I began making pasta puttanesca with fresh tomatoes, and now I'm suffering from withdrawal. Cans are the devil's tool! So it's time to learn to put things up in jars.

    Where do you get concrete reinforcing wire?

  • I'm in Falls Church, Bill, which is a suburb of Washington. Surely they make concrete pipes around here somewhere. The Maryland 'burbs are not too far away, either.

    Don, it would never have occurred to me that the clay was irredeemable, so thanks for pointing that out. If the grass doesn't like it...

    Water always migrates to our neighbor's front yard. Last year the neighbor on the other side put in a couple of drainage pipes that funnelled rainwater onto our lot; I was thinking about becoming disgruntled, but it just flows right over to the other neighbor's. On the bright side (sort of), he does have a spectacular tree in that front yard.

    But about digging holes, that's a very good point. Raised beds it is. Or maybe whiskey barrels, or pseudo-whiskey barrels, would make sense at least to start out.

    This also suggests a strategy for the flowers & herbs. My basil and I thank you.

    Christine

  • Bill, thanks for the links. I'll be calling the extension service at some point. I called them a few years ago and they worked hard to help and were quite cheerful and friendly.

    I wanted see if they knew any way to get rid of yellow jackets without putting poison in the ground. They told me to pour boiling water down the hole. That seemed like a great idea, but when it came time, I couldn't do it. We were only worried about the neighbor's grandchildren anyway, so we warned the neighbor and left the bees buzzing around the back door.

    Rick, I remember going by Catharpin when it was very, very small. Oh, to have a tractor! I used to love bush hogging.

    It would be an interesting challenge to try and make something of the clay. As someone suggested, I've heard the original top soil was ruthlessly bulldozed to make a nice (?) flat neighborhood and every man with his maple. Well, I'll definitely try a few things to improve the flower/herb bed.

    As far as tomatoes go, I'm going to start smallish with something above ground. I do want to figure out the cage issue.

    By the way, one thing prospered in the clay last year: morning glories. They were a gift that I didn't want, so they didn't get any store-bought dirt. I just stuck them in the ground. They wanted a bit of feeding, but then twined madly up the front porch in a wonderful way, and turned out to be one of the best ventures of the year. Even the mailman was charmed.

    I'm certainly having fun here, and have learned enough to keep me obsessing and researching for a month. I appreciate all the input tremendously; it's probably saving me a few years' grief.

    Christine

  • Thank you for some amazingly pithy and detailed responses. Just the sort of thing I was hoping for, from planting medium to pH to several options for dealing with the dastardly dirt. Looking into this stuff will keep me happy for a month at least.

    This local clay is perplexing. People have been tearing down their houses to build McMansions, and I've noticed that the original 50s era homes seem all to have had just a thin layer of sod laid down over pure red clay. I left a little pile at the end of my garden space, and nothing grew in it all summer. There only are a few straggly leaves of grass in it now.

    Well, I'm looking forward to some real tomatoes. I've always gotten them from the farmer's market, but this year I began making pasta puttanesca with fresh tomatoes, and now I'm suffering from withdrawal. Cans are the devil's tool! So it's time to learn to put things up in jars.

    Where do you get concrete reinforcing wire?

  • I'm in Falls Church, Bill, which is a suburb of Washington. Surely they make concrete pipes around here somewhere. The Maryland 'burbs are not too far away, either.

    Don, it would never have occurred to me that the clay was irredeemable, so thanks for pointing that out. If the grass doesn't like it...

    Water always migrates to our neighbor's front yard. Last year the neighbor on the other side put in a couple of drainage pipes that funnelled rainwater onto our lot; I was thinking about becoming disgruntled, but it just flows right over to the other neighbor's. On the bright side (sort of), he does have a spectacular tree in that front yard.

    But about digging holes, that's a very good point. Raised beds it is. Or maybe whiskey barrels, or pseudo-whiskey barrels, would make sense at least to start out.

    This also suggests a strategy for the flowers & herbs. My basil and I thank you.

    Christine

  • Bill, thanks for the links. I'll be calling the extension service at some point. I called them a few years ago and they worked hard to help and were quite cheerful and friendly.

    I wanted see if they knew any way to get rid of yellow jackets without putting poison in the ground. They told me to pour boiling water down the hole. That seemed like a great idea, but when it came time, I couldn't do it. We were only worried about the neighbor's grandchildren anyway, so we warned the neighbor and left the bees buzzing around the back door.

    Rick, I remember going by Catharpin when it was very, very small. Oh, to have a tractor! I used to love bush hogging.

    It would be an interesting challenge to try and make something of the clay. As someone suggested, I've heard the original top soil was ruthlessly bulldozed to make a nice (?) flat neighborhood and every man with his maple. Well, I'll definitely try a few things to improve the flower/herb bed.

    As far as tomatoes go, I'm going to start smallish with something above ground. I do want to figure out the cage issue.

    By the way, one thing prospered in the clay last year: morning glories. They were a gift that I didn't want, so they didn't get any store-bought dirt. I just stuck them in the ground. They wanted a bit of feeding, but then twined madly up the front porch in a wonderful way, and turned out to be one of the best ventures of the year. Even the mailman was charmed.

    I'm certainly having fun here, and have learned enough to keep me obsessing and researching for a month. I appreciate all the input tremendously; it's probably saving me a few years' grief.

    Christine

  • Thank you for some amazingly pithy and detailed responses. Just the sort of thing I was hoping for, from planting medium to pH to several options for dealing with the dastardly dirt. Looking into this stuff will keep me happy for a month at least.

    This local clay is perplexing. People have been tearing down their houses to build McMansions, and I've noticed that the original 50s era homes seem all to have had just a thin layer of sod laid down over pure red clay. I left a little pile at the end of my garden space, and nothing grew in it all summer. There only are a few straggly leaves of grass in it now.

    Well, I'm looking forward to some real tomatoes. I've always gotten them from the farmer's market, but this year I began making pasta puttanesca with fresh tomatoes, and now I'm suffering from withdrawal. Cans are the devil's tool! So it's time to learn to put things up in jars.

    Where do you get concrete reinforcing wire?

  • I'm in Falls Church, Bill, which is a suburb of Washington. Surely they make concrete pipes around here somewhere. The Maryland 'burbs are not too far away, either.

    Don, it would never have occurred to me that the clay was irredeemable, so thanks for pointing that out. If the grass doesn't like it...

    Water always migrates to our neighbor's front yard. Last year the neighbor on the other side put in a couple of drainage pipes that funnelled rainwater onto our lot; I was thinking about becoming disgruntled, but it just flows right over to the other neighbor's. On the bright side (sort of), he does have a spectacular tree in that front yard.

    But about digging holes, that's a very good point. Raised beds it is. Or maybe whiskey barrels, or pseudo-whiskey barrels, would make sense at least to start out.

    This also suggests a strategy for the flowers & herbs. My basil and I thank you.

    Christine

  • Bill, thanks for the links. I'll be calling the extension service at some point. I called them a few years ago and they worked hard to help and were quite cheerful and friendly.

    I wanted see if they knew any way to get rid of yellow jackets without putting poison in the ground. They told me to pour boiling water down the hole. That seemed like a great idea, but when it came time, I couldn't do it. We were only worried about the neighbor's grandchildren anyway, so we warned the neighbor and left the bees buzzing around the back door.

    Rick, I remember going by Catharpin when it was very, very small. Oh, to have a tractor! I used to love bush hogging.

    It would be an interesting challenge to try and make something of the clay. As someone suggested, I've heard the original top soil was ruthlessly bulldozed to make a nice (?) flat neighborhood and every man with his maple. Well, I'll definitely try a few things to improve the flower/herb bed.

    As far as tomatoes go, I'm going to start smallish with something above ground. I do want to figure out the cage issue.

    By the way, one thing prospered in the clay last year: morning glories. They were a gift that I didn't want, so they didn't get any store-bought dirt. I just stuck them in the ground. They wanted a bit of feeding, but then twined madly up the front porch in a wonderful way, and turned out to be one of the best ventures of the year. Even the mailman was charmed.

    I'm certainly having fun here, and have learned enough to keep me obsessing and researching for a month. I appreciate all the input tremendously; it's probably saving me a few years' grief.

    Christine

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    If you really intend only to grow a half dozen tomato plants or less, you should constructing a small raised bed rather than fight the native clay soil.

    First till up your clay soil bed about 8 - 12 inches deep and thoroughly incorporate at least 5% organic matter into the native clay. Then construct your raised bed atop this prepared subgrade.

    Make your side boards 12 - 18 inches tall and use untreated lumber, some of that composite outdoor decking, concrete blocks, decorative manmade landscape stones, etc. Allow enough room for 2 - 3 feet between plants and 2 feet from the end plants to the end boards. The beds should be 3 - 4 feet wide if you plan a single row of 4 - 6 plants. If you're going to stagger plant them, measure your raised bed layout accordingly.

    Get some concrete reinforcing wire cylinders for cages. Get 8-foot tall cages for aggressive indeterminates, 6-foot cages for semi-indeterminates, and at least 4-foot cages for determinate short stake types. Don't bother with those cheap wire cones ... they're worthless except for 2-foot tall free standing dwarf tomatoes ... and then you need a stake to keep the cone upright.

    Fill the bed with a good planting medium comprised of organic material like composted bark fines, rotted wood chips, composted horse or cow manure, composted leaf mulch and other lawn and garden wastes, coarse sharp sand, and some of that fine native clay soil. Your mix should be loose textured and well drained. The organic material and the clay will provide good moisture retention and ionic nutrient bonding, and the sand and bark fines will help with drainage. The fact that you worked up the tilth in the subgrade native clay will prevent chronic wetness because the irrigation water won't be trapped at the ground line.

    You should be able to obtain a small dump load or large pickup load of a nice growing mix at a local nursery. Tell them you want a well-drained medium for growing tomatoes with a pH of about 5.8 to 6.8 and you want some limestone or dolomite content (to help prevent BER). Nurseries have this stuff because they use mass quantities of it to hold and pot up their nursery stock. It will be cheaper and easier than mixing up your own stuff or buying it in bags at Wal*Mart or Home Ripoff, and you can improve it annually by mulching with grass clippings and leaf mulch from your yard and turning more good compost into it year by year.

    Plan on using some additional fertilizer and soil amendments even though you buy a high quality growing medium. Tomatoes like to eat. Get some tomato formula fertilizer. Bone meal is good too. Some Epsom salts will help as well. Consider drip tape or soaker hoses under a 2 - 4 inch layer of grass clipping or leaf mulch. Maybe you'd rather use plastic, landscape fabric or red plastic mulch. Whatever. Good growing!

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I thought that was good advice. If you have clay, you will be fighting it and amending it and cussing it forever if you don't get it right in the beginning. It will make gardening a misery.

    Raised beds are the way to go. Mine are 4 X 12, and I can have six plants each a little crowded. Some growers have even more than that. Another was is a 3' wide bed for a single row of tomatoes. I have a double row in my 4' wide beds, but this year I may cut back to a single row of 3-4 per bed.

    The above post mentioned un-treated lumber. This has been discussed at length on several gardening and raised bed forums. My research shows that a university study, I believe in Oklahoma, proved that there is no leaching of the treated lumber preservatives into the plants or roots. They vouched it was safe. Others have confirmed this belief. I was concerned about it too, but I could find nothing that really convinced me the preservatives ever had any effect on the plants, roots, or fruit. So, I used the treated lumber. If not, your beds will rot out sooner than you think. Also, use some sort of metal brace on the corners to keep them from pulling apart. Nails or long screws just don't seem to hold up well for me. You can find these braces at any hardware store.

    Another option if you don't plan to grow a lot of plants is to simple use containers. This might work good for you. Lots of people use them. And the larger the better. They now have these plastic type containers that look like wooden whiskey barrels. They are better insulated than most containers and will last. You might want to consider that.

    I also agree on the concrete re-enforcing wire. Some people swear by the Texas Cages, so I am sure they are good, and they are attractive, but pricey. I just always used CRW as many people do.

    Just my opinions. But you really can't go wrong with good, deep raised beds. Lots of ways to go wrong trying to garden on hard clay.

    Don

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I've been fighting clay for years. Mixing 2/3 amendments into it is a waste of the 2/3 amendments. Well... not really... If you keep doing it, year after year, you'll do it some good, but it will still be clay.

    I think the best thing to do is GROW STUFF in it, even if it's just weeds. Don't let it sit idle. Grow things with deep roots.

    I also dump select garbage items in my flower bed (this is the very-lazy-man's compost plan.) We got about 10 pounds of pistachios around Thanksgiving. (Belch). One of my flower beds is a lovely tan color now from pistachio shell mulch. I like to think of all the opportunities for air pockets they add. That's what you want: air pockets. Really bad clay has no room for air.

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Don,

    The reason I advised "untreated" lumber is that the program I'm in advises against treated lumber ... particularly anything treated with creosote. So, whenever I say build a bed from lumber, I'm supposed to say "no treated lumber."

    However, I know about what you're saying, and yes, there are studies that indicate little or no leaching of treated lumber. Also, recently, treating lumber with arsenic compounds has stopped and the new compounds are supposed to be non-lethal. Whatever. But there still may be lumber available whether new or salvaged that contains preservatives that are not considered safe for food gardens, so I'm obligated to advise "no treated lumber." Simple as that.

    And you're right about connecting the corners. Nails will split the lumber. So, it's advisable to use some other connecting system at the corners especially. Pre-drilling for bolts or screws works well. Put the bracing lumber on the inside. And you can use "batter" strips on the outside to further protect the ends from splitting so badly.

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    It's always safest to advise the use of un-treated, epecially if you belong to a garden group who has that policy. I debated the use of treated for a long time and never did like the idea of creosote oozing from new rr ties for a garden. I stayed away from that.

    However, concerning the other standard treated material, here's what I did, even though the university studies said it was safe as it was. I got a roll of the heaviest clear poly I could find and lined the beds so none of the wood touched the garden soil. I did this in strips that fit the lumber and just stapled it on. That was my solution, and made it even safer. I figure over time all those chemicals evaporate or break down anyway as the wood dries, but I wanted the extra safety of the lining. Once I decided to do that I was OK with the treated lumber. But I certainly did it.

    I didn't use the corner braces initially. I thought those long screw would be enough, but they weren't. So I had to patch some up later. And have more to do.

    Another thing, instead of adding too much height to the bed you can do what you said and till down an extra few inches and just remove all the clay and fill the whole thing with organic material. I didn't think of that in time! So, my beds use 12" lumber, which is actually about 11" but the plants seem to do fine in that. The higher the beds are the less stability you have in temps and moisture. The soil gets hotter and drier. Doesn't matter much in the Spring, but here in the summer it makes a huge difference. Therefore, most of my container plants are playing out long before the bed plants are. Mother earth does a good job in regulating temps and moisture, so the idea of digging down is a good one.

    I also noticed long ago when the farmers disked up for spring planting, the disk just sorta loosens the top very few inches, and the plants still seem to do fine. And we've all seen a tree growing from a crack in a rock facing. Plants can do funny things. I think raised beds would be several times the depth of loose soil as opposed to regular farming. And when you think about No Till farming, you have to wonder where the roots find a place to grow. But they do. But for tomatoes, I think raised beds are the way to go....unless you are planting huge amounts. Then, obviously, the cost becomes impractical.

    Finally, if you pull up a tomato plant in the fall, it is amazing to me how small the root ball actually is. I doubt it has much/any meaningful root growth deeper than my 11" inch beds. I'm sure smaller root hairs tear off when you pull them up, and I know some studies show some incredible root depths on certain plants, but the main portion of the actual tomato root ball really isn't that big. I can usually fit them in a two gallon nursery container. Always amazed me and made me not want to side dress, but put the water and fertilizer and other liquid nutrients right at the base of the plant, or through a short PVC pipe that I add to each planting hole for this purpose...getting water and nutrients right to the roots. And I always use liquid dilutions. Otherwise solid fertilizer has to sit on top of the soil until watering or rain breaks it down, then it has to leach into the soil, and some of it just runs off in a heavy rain. I'm a firm believer in applying the water and nutrients right inside the planting hole where the roots are. Helps keep weeds down too, since the water and nutrients aren't directed to the top of the soil.

    Anyway, schools never out, we're always learning if we try. Still learning. That's half the fun.

    Don

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Where in Virginia do you live? Maybe I can locate a source of ready-made CRW cages nearby.

    Bill

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    If you scrap around, you can probably find some on constrution sites they might let you have. You mentioned all the new housing going on where you live, you might find a contractor that will give you a half used roll. Otherwise, Co-Ops, Farm Supplies, Lumber Yards, Building Supplies, etc. will have it. I would advise you to make them 24" and fasten with hog rings. Ask at the Co-Op, they can explain about hog rings. You will need a special type of pliars. That's the best way.

    Sounds like your soil is very unsuitable for gardening, especially if it won't even grow grass! Save yourself some trouble and go ahead and start on your raised beds and don't worry with amending soil as clayey and hard packed and sterile as yours sounds to be. Sounds like you will need a load of organic material, or go to Home Depot, Lowe's, Wal Mart, etc. and just by it by the sack. Read another post here on "Earl's Hole Method for Tomatoes." He gives good advice on soil amendments and he also uses raised beds.

    Just my opinion.

    Don

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Don,

    The reason I asked about the poster's location is because if a concrete pipe manufacturer is nearby, the poster may be able to acquire ready-made CRW cylinders that are seconds or rejects. If the welds or structural integrity of the precast pipe reinforcement cages aren't perfect, the pipe manufacturer has to recycle them. I can get these cylinders quite cheap from a local RCP manufacturer. I find the pre-made CRW cages for 21, 24 and 27-inch diameter reinforced concrete pipe are perfect for tomato cages as they're 8 feet long and already spot-welded and ready to go.

    Also, the reason I advised amending and tilling the raised bed subgrade is to get at least some percolation through the clay subgrade under the raised bed. This is very important and should not be skipped as you indicate. If you place your raised bed directly on top of hardpan clay without breaking up and amending it with some organic material, you risk benching an artificial water table in your bed same as if you were to build a raised bed directly on a concrete slab. Good drainage is important to avoid chronic wetness in the raised bed.

    Same goes for the Earl's Hole Method. If the poster simply digs potholes or postholes in hardpan clay and fills the holes with all the most wonderful amendments, the holes are just gonna hold water like a bowl and drown the roots if the clay soil is as hard and tight-grained as the poster indicates. The native soil is going to have to be amended to some degree in order to achieve some percolation for at least minimal drainage.

    Bill

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Christine,

    I'm very familiar with Falls Church as I lived in Alexandria from 1964 - 1971. My father and brother still live in suburban Northern Virginia. I'll see if I can find a concrete pipe manufacturer near you that might sell reinforcement wire seconds and get back with you if I do.

    Clay soil is redeemable ... it just takes a lot of effort, time and materials. If it weren't redeemable, coal mine reclamation efforts would be impossible and gardening in lots of locations would be near impossible too.

    It's just that raised beds and container gardening often is a quicker fix using less effort and confining the amending materials in a smaller area with well defined depth and edges that prevent the organic material floating or washing away.

    If you're interested in building clay based soil up, you can access some great information from your local Virginia extension service. Purdue extension gives great info too and the Master Gardener and extension services in Virginia are very comparable to ours.

    Just be aware ... it's gonna take a lot of time and effort to build up native clay soils especially in areas where development has severely disturbed or removed the native soil "Horizon A" where all the natural accumulation of decomposed organic material formed the topsoil. That's long gone, and what you have in your yard most probably is totally subsoil. And you're gonna have to do in a few years what it would take Mother Nature a millennia ... build 12 inches of topsoil.

    Bill

    Purdue Fact Sheet - Raised Beds and Container Gardening

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Raised beds, Raised beds, Raised beds!! Any veggie that I put in clay fails big-time! Mine are 4' x 12' and they work wonderfully. ( I don't want to tell you how many I cram in them).

    Don't forget to support the middle of the bed with some re-bar or metal stake so they don't bow out and pop the corners.

    Greg

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Hoosier,

    You are very right about digging holes in clay--it holds water like a vat. I dug holes one year here in my backyard, and it has some pretty good soil. I think I dug 78 holes. We had a couple of good rains that spring, all the holes filled up and held water and I think I lost 72 of the 78 plants. That's when I converted to raised beds!

    I was in a panic over losing my tomato garden, but jumped right in and converted to a few raised beds and saved the day. I think I started with three beds that are 4 X 12, using 2 X 12" treated lumber. The next year I added six more, and now I have 20 in two locations. I would advise Christine is she is planning on doing a lot, to try to have a truck load of organice matter delivered. You can't imagine how many 50 pound sacks of organic matter it takes to fill a bed. If you are only doing 2-3 it doesn't matter so much, but on more it gets to be a pretty big chore.

    Good point! I had forgotten about my own fisaco with water-holding holes in the ground.

    Didn't mean to butt in on the CRW. If she can't find those ready-made ones you mention, she can see in this thread how she can build her own.

    Hope this helps.

    Don

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Christine,
    I'm really close...Catharpin (just north of the Manassas battlefields). We have clay but it sounds like it's not as bad as yours. Since my garden is a little larger I thought I would just till and incorporate organic matter. I guess it helps to have a tractor with a tiller. Anyway, it's possible to turn clay into good growing soil. Just keep digging and adding organic matter.
    Rick

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Christine, I re-read your original post. If the garden center lady dug out all her clay and replaced it with real soil, that should be enough evidence right there that you will probably have to do the same if you want good garden soil. She probably tried amending and just gave up. Many do.

    I also re-read that you only want 3-4 plants. If that is all, then you are better off using containers. They make some nice plastic-type imitation half whiskey barrels that will work fine and last a long time. For 3-4 plants this would be the best I think. Especially for you to start with. You would have a guarantee of good soil, without too much expense. I can't suggest that you go to the expense of raised beds, lots of new soil, CRW cages, etc. for just four tomato plants. If you wanted to try a dozen, then the raised beds would be best. If you want to start small and work your way in, get some plastic whiskey barrels. Or those inexpensive 18 gallon containers that Wal-Mart carries. I think they are around $7. Not sure of the price, but inexpensive. With either, and a few bags of organic matter, peat, bagged top soil, bagged and aged manure, you would be in business in a few hours day.

    Hope this helps. Just my opinion. But I think you will be happy with that arrangement.

    Don

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    My first "real " garden was on some very heavy clay, here in Northern Indiana where the glaciers gave up, there are huge silt deposits, usually mixed with big-ass rocks, and that's where i started out.

    THis was some serious clay...the kids and i made pots and cured them in a homemade solar oven....my neighbor offered to till up the garden area from sod for me...he came on a rainy day because he wasn't busy...i WEPT when i saw what an expletive deleted mess I had left when the sun came out. Yikes, i could almost cry now!

    Thank goodness I was only 31 and real strong!! THe only way to get rid of the bricks he had created by roto-mixing old sod with heavy clay was to dig ditches and bury them.

    Raised beds really woulda been the way to go, but after clearing out all the bricks, i did 'raised rows', and hauled tons and tons of any manure, leaves, etc in, plus rock powders.

    On the plus side, the soil was really fertile, and didn't burn through the ammendments like the sand morraine-on-top-of-a-gravel-pit where i am now. It really holds water well, and most leafy type crops loved it. Not so much melon/cuke type stuff, or undergroud things until i had good 'raised rows' built up. (see Eliot Coleman)

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    It can be done, but like you said, it was an over-load of work and you had to haul "tons and tons" of organic matter in. I'm thinking if Christine is new to this, that might sour her on the whole thing. It just isn't worth it for 3-4 plants.

    I feel more and more blessed when I hear of these terrible clay problems! And more and more happy with raised beds and containers!

    This is a fun thread!

    Don

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Yeah, that's what I meant to say...it can be done , but if i knew then what i know now, I'd have gone with raised beds from the start.

    You can't really go wrong, if you get more ambitious later you can add more beds, or even work on your native soil, but you'll always use that raised bed for something.

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    If you are really determined to deal with the clay, you can fix it in one day if you want to spend a little money. I'm not sure how big an area you have but this will work as well as any.

    Hire a small backhoe to come in and churn up the ground at least a couple of feet deep. Have dump trucks of organic matter or topsoil ready and let them sift it out over the scratched up land. Maybe even add some sand for areation and better drainage. Get the backhoe operator to stir it up good and smooth it. (If you have a cotton gin nearby, get a load of cotton gin trash...works fine.) Then you can add more topsoil or organic matter on top.

    Sounds like a big operation, but you can do it all in a few hours and be done with it. Otherwise you will be hand digging and amending forever.

    Extreme situations call for extreme measures!

    Don

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I'm sure all your suggestions are well intended, Don. However ...

    1) there are no cotton gins in Northern Virginia. They don't grow cotton in Northern Virginia. The cotton industry left Virginia a century ago.

    2) Before determining how much sand it will take to effect any significant change in a clay soil's texture, one should consult the Soils Triangle available by clicking here and studying carefully. I think you'll find that it may take as much as one foot depth of sand across the entire lawn area for every foot depth of clay soil you intend to amend with sand before a soil with a predominantly clay texture becomes anything approaching "sandy clay."

    3) Adding enough sand to a hard clay soil to effect any significant change will change the elevation of the yard to the extent that the protective grade away from the house foundation most likely will be compromised and the result will interfere with sheet drainage away from the house and most likely interfere with the common drainage pattern set for the adjacent lots in the subdivision.

    4) Adding "topsoil" and organic matter on top of the sand-filled reworked clay soil would further raise the elevation of the yard and compound the grading issues particularly regarding the protective grade away from the house foundation ... which should be a minimum 6 inch fall in the first ten feet.

    5) Since there are no laws or state regs of any kind defining "topsoil" and since most true topsoil long ago was eroded away or destroyed by poor farming practices and subsequent suburban development in the Falls Church, Virginia area, the most likely source for anything truly topsoil would be a nearby national forest. Otherwise, you are gonna get manufactured "topsoil" or river bottom silt or generally whatever the local vendors are calling "topsoil" which again has no regulated definition. Buyer beware!

    Lastly, yes, adding organic matter is the best bet and that's been covered, but can be re-addressed by the homeowner after a soils test is done to assess the needs, and then the homeowner can follow the recommendations for amendments provided by the soils lab and the local extension service. And compared to sand, it doesn't take as much organic matter to convert a clay-based soil to a suitable medium for growing grass. Christine already has said her garden plot will be small, so when addressing the rest of the yard, a massive reclamation project re-excavating the top 2 feet of soil and adding 2 more feet of amendments isn't required to grow grass turf.

    Bill

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Excellent points. Another six reasons to go with raised beds.

    Don

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Coming in late here, I see, but, do not add sand, or most commercial top soil preparations to a clay soil. The actual ratio of sand to heavy clay required to change the soil classification makes it unfeasible to do so. Also, do not add sawdust, grass clippings or other fines unless you are willing to deep till, by deep, I mean 18 to 24 inches. Clay soil can be exceptionally fertile if handled properly. In my experience, it is best to handle clay when it is nearly dry, not wet, to avoid the aforementioned brick effect. I recommend the use of residual hard wood scraps from 1/2" to 1" in size. This can be made to work just fine. Some feeding may also be necessary, with slow release, full spectrum fertilizers. I am also a fan of folair feeding in clay soils. Finally, one of the biggest issues will be moisture control, that is too say, mulch heavily, water infrequently and I like to put a couple of small perforated pipes into the ground near the root ball to make water and air penetration easier.

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Just one suggestion: GROW SOMETHING. Even if it's just weeds or a lawn. You need organic matter, preferably deep organic matter, and a lot of time. If you're going to live there more than a couple of years, you should get started. Grow aggressive plants with deep roots. Thornless raspberries, for instance, like Heritage.