Software
Houzz Logo Print
instar8

How about the best medium sized tomatoes?

18 years ago

I had a garden full of big ol' monster tomatoes, and that was fun, but when i wanted to can some whole or halved toms, other than paste types, i found i didn't have much to pick from.

The Neve's Azorean, Chapman and Stump of the World had some smaller fruits mixed in with the big'uns, and the Polfast was a nice size, but i only planted a couple.

What's your favorite 8 oz or less good tasting mater? OP or hybrid, i'm not picky!

THanks!

Lynn

Comments (14)

  • 18 years ago

    Big Beef Hybrid would be my choice. They have everything going for them except large size. Ideal for halving and quartering for canning. Very good.

  • 18 years ago

    The best medium size tomato I've ever grown is Pale Perfect Purple aka Perfect Purple. It was a PL and a heavy producer of perfect shaped crack free tomatoes in the 6-8 ounce range..

  • 18 years ago

    The best productive medium reds for canning have small cores, meaty, and smooth skinned. My favorites are Campbells 1327 and Old Brooks. Rutgers is also good but not that productive in comparison.

  • 18 years ago

    My best medium sized tomato is bonnie best, very good taste, great yields all season and the late blight didn't affect it like some of my other tomatoes.

  • 18 years ago

    My Big Beefsteak get too big to consider medium sized, but they are my favorite tasting tomato. Merced would be my next favorite. It is a hybrid that they keep saying has been discontinued, but I have still been able to find a few plants at H.D. put out by Bonnies Plants. I suspect that they had a pretty good stash of seeds that they are rationing out. Next would be Jet Star, a prolific, good tasting medium sized tomato.
    That is my .02
    Bill P.

  • 18 years ago

    Just be aware Jet Star is low acid, so you have to add some if you plan on canning them.

  • 18 years ago

    Of those I've grown, these three med.-sized red tomatoes stand out in my memory as good ones: Sioux, Wisconsin 55, and Red Brandywine. Finding the correct Red Brandywine is the key. I think the Landis Valley strain is considered the true RB. If someone could recommend a good source for this seed, I'd appreciated it. I'm thinking of growing the three varieties I've mentioned, and comparing them.

  • 18 years ago

    Red Brandywine Landis Valley Strain would be my pick for a good medium sized tomato.

    Duncan, I got mine from Tomato Growers Supply in Ft.Myers, FL.
    Good growing. Len

  • 18 years ago

    Doug
    I think Red Brandywine was introduced to market by Heirloom Seeds. They should have the origional. Look at Heirloomseeds.com

  • 18 years ago

    This tomato might fall on the small size instead of medium but well worth its spot in the garden: Eva Purple Ball. One of my tastiest tomatos in my garden last year, and good production. They form perfect pink balls, beautiful!

  • 18 years ago

    I agree Eva Purple Ball is high on flavor. A great tomato although a bit small. should be perfect for canning.

    I love Jet Star. high production.

  • 18 years ago

    For Doug and Lynn

    Doug
    I think Red Brandywine was introduced to market by Heirloom Seeds. They should have the origional. Look at Heirloomseeds.com

    *****

    Yes, Tom Hauch was the first to get it out of SSE and offer it commercially. He shared seeds with Steve Miller at the Landis Museum in PA and those of us who are SSE members know it's long been listed in the Yearbooks.

    I've offered it here at GW a couple of times when I used to do those large seed offers.

    Good sources might include:

    Sandhill Preservation
    Heirloom Seeds
    TGS for the Landis which is not a strain as Linda wrote, rather just the place where she got it from.

    The above three sources I know are OK,or have been, and I can't speak to any other sources in terms of my own personal experience.

    While there is no one best med sized tomato variety I'll add just a few more:

    Break O Day
    Bulgarian #7
    Druzba
    Jet Star is about the right size but Supersonic is larger
    Picardy
    St. Pierre

    Carolyn

  • 18 years ago

    So much for the idea of pruning back the planting list! I always do Big Beef, but otherwise these are all new to me...THanks for all the suggestions!

    Lynn

  • 18 years ago

    My vote goes to Jet Star. Always good and productive. Supersonic is good also, but bigger than 8 oz usually.