Software
Houzz Logo Print
twilitemoon

Dishwasher Magic?

18 years ago

Hi all. I recently used the product Dishwasher Magic inside of my dishwasher because the dishwaser was leaving spots on our dishes (oddly enough, not on our glasses). A friend of mine suggested that we use the product. I just would like the opinion of others who have used it, or a similar product, like jetdry dishwasher cleaner, because I am concerned that the product may still be inside the dishwaser since the dishwasher still smells strongly of the product -- a citrus smell. I am pregnant, so I want to be extra cautious. I have run the dishwasher through two cycles and it still smells. To all who have used it, is it normal for it to smell like the product inside, and is it safe to load the dishwasher and do my dishes now? Thank you!

Comments (9)

  • 18 years ago

    I use it regularly and yes afterward you smell it but then after you run a load of dishes(or 2) it is gone. Kinda like the Cascade version of Jet Dry--when I use that I always smell it after the dishes are done.(Cascade Crystal Clear-I couldn't think of that above).

  • 18 years ago

    The reason I ask is because before this post, I contacted the company that makes Dishwasher Magic to ask them if the product was safe and if the dishwasher should still smell strongly after using it. The representative told me that she was unsure of what was in it other than a concentration of 10 to 40% citric acid and that the dishwasher shouldn't smell of it afterwards. She then said not to use my dishwasher and that she would have to research my question and call me back. It's just frustrating, considering that a product marketed for exclusive use in the dishwasher would have representatives who are unsure of the safety of the product. I really do appreciate the responses. It makes me feel better to know that others use it and have had the same experience. Sparky823, when you use it, do you do a load of dishes immediately afterwards? Or do you run several cycles first? And you have never become ill from using the product? I used it because the inside of my dishwasher had caked on white stuff and I wasn't sure if it was mineral deposits or dishwasher detergent residue. My dishes were coming out with spots on them, although my glasses weren't, so I wanted to remedy the problem.

  • 18 years ago

    I've used this product a few times and never have noticed a smell afterwards.

  • 18 years ago

    If the white gunk has been removed, your DW is safer now than it used to be.

    Your DW has a plastic tub, right? Plastics can absorb some chemicals in small amounts, particularly small molecules like citric acid. The smell will disappear after a few loads.

    If in doubt, run a few loads with no dishes or detergent. This should remove the odor.

    Quoting from Wikipedia on Citric acid: Citric acid is recognized as safe for use in food by all major national and international food regulatory agencies. It is naturally present in almost all forms of life, and excess citric acid is readily metabolized and eliminated from the body.

  • 18 years ago

    Yeah I always just washed a load of dishes after. Mine is a stainless steel tub--is yours? If you have the white plastic kind maybe the smell just sticks to the plastic for longer. After the dishes washes and rinses(a cycle is usually 2 of each right) there isn't going to be any of that left in there to get on anything you are using. You are just worrying over nothing. The company just had some person answering the phone and half the time I don't think they even know what the company they are working for even makes/sells. Run you 2 cups of white vinegar through it and then start using it. If you are afraid of the DM use the vinegar from now on. It will help clean it out. There is just no way that is left in there after it rinses a few times. Do you use Jet Dry? If so it is left on the dishes evrytime you wash them cause it goes in the last rinse--that is why they dry fast.Try doing a load and see if they smell. They will be fine.

  • 18 years ago

    Thanks to all who posted. I ended up running the dishwasher on a heavy load and dumping two cups of vinegar in there when the machine filled with water. I really appreciate all your help. My dishwasher is a plastic tub, which, as you all mentioned, is probably the reason the smell persisted after several runs. I am assuming that the vinegar will rid of any remaining Dishwasher Magic product considering that it is used to combat soap scum. I did do the right thing by dumping in the vinegar when the machine fills up right? Thank you.

  • 18 years ago

    You should be fine now. Try running vinegar in it once a month and that should keep it clean.

  • 18 years ago

    Not much difference between citric acid (DW Magic, oranges) and acetic acid (vinegar), except for strength. DW magic is 50% acetic acid, whereas vinegar is roughly 5% acetic acid. In other words, vinegar is no safer than DW Magic. Simple chemistry.