Software
Houzz Logo Print
lilathabit

Dodging code: Less than 15' o/c for toilet

17 years ago

I would like to squeeze a toilet into a 28 in space rather than a 30" space which would meet code of toilet being 15" on center from nearest object.

I have read that some of you have done just this. How did you get away with it? Out bath remodel is such a fundamental change that we would need to file a permit.

s there something about the inspection process that allows one to get away with it? Do they not bust out the measuring tape? If I can figure this out, I'll be set!

Comments (16)

  • 17 years ago

    i did it but we didn't pull a permit for anything. i would have if it hadn't been so hard to schedule, though i don't know what i would have done about the toilet. it is closer to the tub deck than it should be, though it's not in its own room - i would think they would be more strict about that due to access issues. in my case i don't know what else i could do instead that would be less of an irritation, but it does get to me more than i thought it would to have your leg touch something, even occasionally, while you're taking care of business :)

  • 17 years ago

    In case this helps at all, my understanding is that you need the 15" on each side at toilet-seat-height. So, if your vanity top overhangs by an inch, you don't need to count that.

  • 17 years ago

    Perhaps the inspector will not measure the space. They do not check every detail. What encloses the 28" space?

  • 17 years ago

    It seems like an inspection item they're not going to cover. Draw it on plans at 15" and then explain why it's 14" (e.g., studs required locating waste pipe 1" over.

  • 17 years ago

    I would honestly like to know when these 'codes' ever come into play? It's not when you buy a house in PA, that's for sure! I've bought several, and house inspectors prior to sale never mentioned the toilet placement once. Does this only apply to homeowner changes, not to builders?

    None of the upstairs toilets in my house are remotely close to 15" from a wall, more like 6"! The seat in our master is 6" from the wall on one side, 4" (I kid you not) from the vanity on the other. Total space between the wall and vanity counter (where the tiolet is) is 24".

    My husband finds his shoulders wedged between the window sill and the vanity, which is part of what I'm going to change when I do this remodel of course.

    So if there are all these rules, how did someone get away with doing this? When, if ever, is it enforced? It's not a low cost neighborhood, either. Standard 4 bed, 2.5 bath colonial.

  • 17 years ago

    biochem101: I know this doesn't add anything to addressing the original issue, but I just had to chuckle a bit with the vision of your DH wedged in there while taking care of business. Seems like he would be all thumbs-up for a remodel!

  • 17 years ago

    The toilet isn't required to be 15" from a wall, the center of the toilet is required to be 15" from a wall or other obstruction, like a sink.

  • 17 years ago

    is your space surrounded by three walls? Or is there more elbow room?

  • 17 years ago

    "...the center of the toilet is required to be 15" from a wall..."

    Okay, that makes more sense. Thanks! I am trying to learn as much as I can to plan this project.

    But my hall bath toilet is still only 12" from the wall to center, with plenty of space on other side toward the vanity. The master is 13" wall to center, then 11" to vanity, a total of 24" between 'objects'.

    So my question is, if there are all these codes and inspections how come someone got away with this?

  • 17 years ago

    my understanding is that the code is enforced if an inspection/permit is done and if the code is in effect when the build/remodel is done. maybe your home is older & the code was different? or it was a remodel and the prior owner did not pull a permit? i think builders have to follow it due to the need to get permits.

  • 17 years ago

    Building inspectors enforce code during the design, construction, and inspection phases. At least they should. If work was done without a permit, obviously they can't.

    And yes, if code has changed subsequent to the original construction, "non-compliant areas" are grandfathered.

    Out of code conditions can remain when new and additional work is done, unless the new work is extensive. In that case, the inspection department can require that the old non-compliant areas be brought into compliance, bringing the entire structure "up to code".

    In general, home inspectors don't enforce or quote code. Some might. In general all they do is tell you which systems in the house function properly, which don't, and what systems may need replacement in the near future.

    Realize that most home inspectors want to "inspect" just enough to give a warm fuzzy. "HVAC works fine". "Roof may need replacement in the next three to five years."

    For the most part they don't want to use a fine-tooth comb and be so nit-picky and list so much "non-critical" minutia that kill the transaction.

    The heat exchanger in the boiler is cracked and leaking carbon monoxide into the ducts? Yes. A cabinet knob that needs tightening? No.

    If an overzealous home inspector got into the habit of being so negative with minor things that he scared buyers off and repeatedly killed real estate transactions, that inspector would not get any referrals from realtors.

    So for the most part home inspectors look at the overall condition of the house, and not so much at specific details of the house. And they generally don't quote code.

    Mongo

  • 17 years ago

    It depends on the jurisdiction. In my county, it is an employee of the county who does the inspections, not an independent contractor. Referrals from real estate agents mean nothing; the inspector doesn't get jobs from real estate agent referrals.
    As far as grandfathering in, when we had the final inspection on our build, the inspector required changes to portions of the house that were not affected by the new construction. Maybe he was out of line, but you couldn't argue with him.
    Bottom line, don't assume that your remodel doesn't have to meet code.

  • 17 years ago

    Just to clarify in case I muddled the issue:

    Inspections done as part of the permitting and construction process (typically footing/foundation/framing/electrical/plumbing/drywall inspections) are done by someone from the town or country. And those are code compliance inspections. Those inspectors are in no way affiliated with realtors, or real estate transactions. They only inspect permitted work as part of the permitting process, with the eventual goal of issuing a certificate of occupancy.

    Inspections done by "home inspectors" as part of a real estate buy/sell transaction, those guys are "independent inspectors" and are generally concerned only if things work or if they don't work. In general they are not concerned with code compliance. In my area many of them are affiliated with realtors or real estate agents.

    At least that's how it's worked wherever I've lived.

    Not sure if that clarifies or further muddies the waters.

  • 17 years ago

    Thanks all for your consideration of this question.
    The inspection will be done my a building department employee of the village where I live.

    While I think they're concerned with code, I think they're more concerned with informing our tax department!

    When I measured the space, the 118" I have to work with is figured from the face of a tile wall inside a bath to the opposite wall of sheetrock.

    Perhaps I won't even have the 118" if there is something I might be overlooking? This house was built in 1964. Would sheetrocking & tiling materials be that different now to make my measurement that much more narrow?

  • 17 years ago

    Re measurements--more likely the other way around. Not sure about 1964, but in 50s and before, tiles were often thicker and set in thicker mud, so that might get you an inch here or there.

  • 17 years ago

    heimert, here's hoping you may be right!