Software
Houzz Logo Print
sporthill_gw

Final Modern Aire decisions

17 years ago

Thanks to all the information on GW, I have ordered my 48" Blue Star and am about to order a Modern Aire hood. I thought you might be interested to know that I got a much better deal from Modern Aire direct than I did from a dealer on an equivalent Independent.

I do have a question. My contractor says I have to have a 8" duct. Patrick at Modern Aire (I can't imagine that Jeff could be any nicer or more helpful!) says I will lose some effectiveness and gain some noise but it should be fine to use a converter to merge the 10" into an 8". He also says I should get the 1200 not the 1000 CFM (4 burners + griddle + grill.) Does that sound all right to our hood/venting experts?

TY for any help.

Comments (3)

  • 17 years ago

    10'' is definitely superior: remember that you're talking about an increase in cross sectional area of over 50% by going from 8'' to 10'' duct. Do you know what the limiting factor is in your contractor's recommendation? There may be ways to get around it. For example, we had to run one stretch of our duct through a wall. We transitioned from 10'' above and below the wall to a 4'' x 18'' rectangular duct through the wall. That only drops cross section from 78 sq in to 72 sq in, still better than 8'' (50 sq in).

    But, having said that, it will still work well. Using the larger blower will partially compensate for smaller ductwork, though as noted at the expense of greater noise. I'd definitely go 1200--the difference in price is small, and you won't use full power that often, but it's nice to have it when you need it. When running at less than full speed, there should be no noise disadvantage versus the 1000 cfm unit. (Though as always, did you consider a remote blower?)

    Don't forget to specify a remote infinitely variable speed control rheostat to allow you to mount the control on the wall. MUCH more convenient than craning your neck to reach up into the hood. And put the light switch, with a dimmer, on the same switchplate.

    I also found that ordering the MA direct was very reasonable compared to other alternative, plus I got to specify custom dimensions, plus the workmanship is superb.

  • 17 years ago

    Thank you Clinresga for such helpful information.
    There is only 8" between the joists. If that is unusual, I don't know why, and I don't know if it is typical in our work or just at this point.
    We decided def. on 1200 cfm, then on a square 8x8 duct, until today when my contractor said that the duct guy said square wouldn't work well and we would be better off with a 9-inch round, which he can do. So I said ok.
    So I'm almost ready to order the Modern Aire. Someone on my other thread mentioned Blue Star hoods, which I looked at briefly and thought were expensive. Do you have an opinion about them?
    I like your advice on the rheostat and the light switch, but I think the electrician is done. I'll see what I can get out of him.
    Thanks again.

  • 17 years ago

    I think the 9'' round would be a good choice. Identical cross sectional area as the 8x8 and maybe less turbulent airflow (that's a pure speculation).

    Can't speak to the BS hoods as have never seen one. I just know there is about nothing on my MA that I would change given the chance.

    Depending on how far along you are should not be that tough to get the wiring pulled to allow the remote switches, but it's not a huge issue.