Software
Houzz Logo Print
execassistant

Electric downdraft cooktop

17 years ago

For our remodel, we have discussed venting for an electric cooktop in an island and have determined that we do not want an overhead vent hood. That decision is based on the fact that we don't want the bulk from the ceiling and we don't cook full meals that often. We know that we won't live here forever, so I still feel a ventilation system is necessary. I assume a telescoping vent will take up more counter space and the downdraft will require more cabinet space.

If that is a fact, which downdraft electric cooktop requires the least amount of cabinet space.

What are the tradeoffs between the telescoping vent and the downdraft cooktop?

Comments (5)

  • 17 years ago

    I have heard that most people are not happy with the drawing power of the in-cooktop exhaust fan. The telescopic downdrafts are more effective.

    A separate telescopic downdraft and cooktop will be significantly more expensive.

  • 17 years ago

    I had a JenAir downdraft and the venting wasn't worth much. Then I went to Thermador telescope and I will say it worked much better.

  • 17 years ago

    I originally had a Jenn-air downdraft electric with the coils. When I revamped the kitchen, I wasn't willing to spend the extra money to redo the island kitchen in order to get a telescoping vent. It takes more depth to the cabinet to get both the top and the vent unit. Also, like you, I didn't want the hood hanging down in the middle of the kitchen.

    This was a few years ago, but at the time, there were only about three different models with a built in exhaust system. I rejected the newer Jenn-air because the slot was so small that you couldn't get your arm in to clean the area. The Whirlpool controls were on the outside area of the stove. A friend had complained that her gas stove was giving her fits because of the outside placement of the knobs. They were getting too hot and scorching from over-sized pans.

    I bought the GE profile with the center downdraft. I know people gripe about the glass tops, but it is so much easier to clean. Just buy the cook-top cleaner and wipe it off every time you use it. It is way easier than cleaning those old drip pans under the coils. The stove has more than enough power to pull all odors and I've never had an issue with the downdraft. With the knobs on the inside I've never had an issue with knob burn. It actually lined up with my old duct work, so the actual installation was a breeze.

    If nothing is there on your current installation, you will have to exhaust it to the outside. That will require some duct work under the house.

  • 17 years ago

    Thanks for the input. So is there any storage space left in the cabinet under the cook top with a telescoping vent?

  • 17 years ago

    We also have our cooktop on the island and didn't want a hood to block the view. I had a Thermador gas cooktop with the pop up vent for 18 years and it worked fine. We had the remote blower motor installed outside the house so we had plenty of storage underneath the cooktop and we also had 2 shallow drawers.

    We remodeled 3 years ago and installed a Dacor gas cooktop with a Dacor telescoping downdraft. This one is better than our old Thermador. It has significantly more power but is actually quieter. We utilized the same duct and mounted the blower motor outside the house. Since this cooktop is deeper we gave up the shallow drawers but we have even more cabinet space underneath. We're able to store most of our pots and skillets inside the cabinet. The Dacor ventilation system can also be installed with other brands of appliances.