Software
Houzz Logo Print
cwyn_gw

Summit drawer freezer is really loud

15 years ago

Does anyone else out there have a Summit under-counter drawer freezer? We recently bought two of them for our kitchen remodel, and had to wait months for them to come in. Now that we have the first one installed, we are noticing that it is incredibly loud- we can hear it throughout the whole apartment, and it is at least 10 times louder than any other appliance in our kitchen (DW, fridge, etc). I'm particularly annoyed, b/c the little $200 cheap freezer that we had been using while waiting for the Summits to arrive made practically no noise at all, at about 1/10th the price. Did we just get a faulty freezer, or are they all this loud?

I'm not sure we are willing to live with the noise...

(But we have to have freezer space, and there aren't many options that will fit in the space we have...)

Thanks in advance for any information/experiences you can provide!

Comments (12)

  • 15 years ago

    It should be noted that Summit freezer drawers are not designed for built-in installation. If you do not have adequate ventilation on the sides and back, it could potentially cause quite a bit of noise as the compressor needs to work harder than usual

  • 15 years ago

    Thanks for the replies. :)

    I don't think it is an issue of it being built-in. The drawer freezer we bought is listed specifically as made for built-in use, and I spent an hour on the phone with an engineer at Summit before we bought it making sure that we have the right specs around the freezer. Additionally, the freezer makes the same noise just plugged into the wall sitting in the middle of the kitchen (before we put it back into the space under the counter).

    A repair person from Summit is coming today (I realized that at least one of the freezers is not maintaining freezing temperatures, despite the temperature display saying that it is currently 3 degrees F, the ice cream inside is like soup), so I'm hoping that the noise is a fault that they can fix.

    If not, I'm going to have to look for an alternative to put in the space (and I'm afraid my only options are subZero and one other company whose name I've forgotten, both of whom cost double the price of a Summit). Does anyone know if other under counter drawer freezers are quieter than the Summit?

    I just can't believe how loud the Summit is - we can hear it in our BR with the door closed...

  • 15 years ago

    i believe that Summit is a rebrander, and they get their products from various sources.

    If I had wanted to buy a particular undercounter drawer appliance from Summit, the "provenance or origin" is one thing I might have spoken to Mark about, if I had gone ahead with a Summit purchase. For example I did call about their CP171, a Vestfrost fridge relabeled. Vestfrost had several other rebranders for a while, so I could see virtually the same fridge in many places, under different names; there was a time when Home Depot sold it as a Vestfrost too.

    It could be that your appliance will always be noisy because it always is, everywhere else in the world too, under another name. Maybe it was "designed as a commercial" appliance and Summit figured they could get the average bear to accept it in a domestic situation. Sorry to be so negative about it all... but I doubt that it's a lemon, as an item (so a site visit is an exercise in PR and goodwill), and I think it's a lemon product as a whole.

    In general, there is no incentive for me or for anyone else to express this kind of doubt, long in advance, when there is no trigger. All I've written here are my hunches, not strong proof.

    Note that some European places force noise information to be published. I wish we would all pick up on that work done, instead of hiding it.

    Hth.

  • 15 years ago

    Thanks for your responses. :)

    Just thought I'd update after we talked to the supervisor at Summit:

    Apparently they've had so much trouble with the model we've ordered (SCFF55) that they've temporarily taken it off the market and are redoing the line. The supervisor said that we could either get a refund, or we could have the current units replaced with the new units once they come out (sometime during the year, but no one knows when?).

    So now we are considering our options. We've already had the countertops and all the cabinets put in (b/c we had to wait 2 months for the Summits to be delivered), so I think we have to stick with the 24" wide under counter freezer. The only other one I know of is the Perlick drawer freezer - anyone have any experience with this one? Is it quiet? Reliable as a brand?

    I don't feel that we can risk waiting for the new Summit models, since no one knows how loud they will be (or how reliable), but I'm a bit annoyed to have to pay twice as much for a Perlick freezer and then still manually have to make ice, since I can't find any other 24" under counter drawer freezer with an icemaker other than the Summit...

    Another option would be for us to go with the 27" subZero drawers (which do have an icemaker option), but this would require ripping out one of the newly installed cabinets to the right of the freezer and replacing it with another one that is 3" narrower - ug. Is it worth it to do this? Is the subZero pretty quiet? More or less reliable than the Perlick?

    Any other brand recommendations that I haven't found yet?

    Thanks again for your responses, everyone!

  • 15 years ago

    I have Perlick Fridge drawers and heartily recommend them. I think they are the best made with SZ a close second, but I also needed the 24" size. My sales person did a luxury skybox after we did our kitchen (we were the first time she'd gone installed Perlick). The original choice of fridge drawers in the sky box was another brand and the owner wasn't happy -- the original unit couldn't keep up with frequent opening and closing. Most of the units we was seemed to be made for light/occassional use in gamerooms, but the Perlick seemed to be the only 24" that would take heavy daily use. She remembered that and replaced the one in the sky box with Perlick and problem solved. You won't be disappointed with the quality or noise. The ice maker is another issue.

    Is that your only freezer -- no other option for making ice? How much ice do you use? We live in TX and use a lot of ice, especially recently when I had two boys in marching band and they filled gallon jugs with ice and water every day, 5-6 days a week for months, plus we had iced tea and other drinks, but our other ice consumption has actually declined 9outside of marching band) since we started chilling more drinks in the fridge drawers. We even make our iced tea with the instant hot, concentrating it and then adding a pitcher of chilled filtered water and refrigerating the pitcher. I used to go through a lot of ice for drinks in the summer, but I can now use a lot less. Maybe you can do more of that type of thing for daily use and get one of those countertop ice makers for when you entertain of need larger amounts of ice. The other thing I would do is see if you couldn't fit an icemaker into a Perlick or have Perlick add one for you. They might not warrant the icemaker, but that wouldn't be a big deal to have to go to that manufacturer for ice maker issues. I think I'd at least ask. Maybe beg a little. ;-)

    How big a deal is that 3" on the cabinet for you? And would you have to do it twice? Are your counters in?

  • 15 years ago

    My wife and I purchased the Summit 2-drawer freezer in November but did not have it installed until December 2010. We also found it incredibly loud. Even in our large house, it would wake me when it runs in the middle of the night. It seems to be on constantly. I measured the heat output from the compressor at about 86 degrees. I would not recommend it.

    I must give kudos to Summit for their responsiveness to our complaint. Summit had a technician inspect the freezer and quickly offered to replace it. However, Summit no longer offers the 2-drawer (as stated in an earlier post). They are crediting us for the price of the unit. Perlick seems to be the only other 2-drawer freezer for the 24" space. Unfortunately, it is twice as expensive.

  • 15 years ago

    No, On Thursday I will receive the Electrolux double drawer undercounter frig. It looks beautiful and it is 2k, cheaper than Perlick drawers. It is 24" and built in.

    There were few reviews but those were good. One person said he had a full size elux frig which was not good but his frig drawers were fine, very fine.

    Satisfied customers mostly don't review things. On the AJ Madison website, elux drawers are the third most frequently purchased frig drawers and that said a lot to me. No or few comments but lots of buyers.

  • 15 years ago

    Unfortunately, Electrolux is not an option for me as I am looking for an all-freezer, 2-drawer, 24" unit.

  • 15 years ago

    westsider - I am purchasing double drawers also and have Marvel on my list because they offer a 30" drawer...but.. please report after your drawers are installed and give a review on the noise and performance. I'm holding out on the order until the last minute and I still have about a week to finalize the decision..Super thanks

  • 4 years ago

    Jennair makes a two drawer dual zone undercounter fridge freezer that could work

  • 4 years ago

    I have the exact same problem with a loud Summit undercounter built-in and I paid $1800 for this unit and Summit will not take it back or repair it. What was the outcome of your deal wit Summit?

Sponsored
The Steele Group
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars1 Review
Industry Leading General Contractors in Franklin County, Ohio