Software
Houzz Logo Print
lisepomeroy

downgrading: Wolf to electric range...

16 years ago

Due to a change in circumstances (tmi) I have left my beloved Wolf behind and have been living with a soon to expire 30" electric coil range/oven that came with this house. I have no NG of LP where I am, only 30" and a no induction or Aga budget (~$1k). I have been looking and all I see are the glass top ranges. It broke my heart to go to the electric range but if I buy new, do I skip the coils and go to glass top? What do I need to know?

Comments (3)

  • 16 years ago

    If I had your budget and only electric service, I would buy a glass top range, researching to make sure it has a decent oven, and also buy a portable induction unit. You should be able to do that for I've had a glass top range (GE Spectra) for about 10 years and I've been very happy with it. Like all electric ranges, it's downside is slow responsiveness when trying to modulate the heat. This issue can be mitigated substantially by using heavy pans and not flimsy ones. Also be aware that induction requires pans with enough iron so they can be magnetized. If you have to buy new cookware to use an induction unit, it could blow your budget.

    FWIW, Cooks' Illustrated just reviewed portable induction units last month and recommended the Max Burton AT6000 induction burner, which retails for ~$125, and the Viking ($500).

  • 16 years ago

    I've had glass top ranges for about 20 years. The only problems I've had is that they need flat bottomed pans, and I can't use my big heavy canner on them. I've used cast iron (as long it is flat) and in all these years I've only had one scratch on the surface (did that not being careful moving my presto canner).

    My big water bath canner does not have a flat bottom, but now I use my pressure canners for waterbath so that is not a problem.

    Like warmfridge said, having good solid bottom pans take care of a lot of the complaints - without them I can hardly get water to boil (in a flimsy not real flat pan) but it boils quite fast in my solid heavy flat bottom stock pots.

    I would only suggest getting a coil if you do a lot of canning (or make beer and need to boil large quantites of liquid). And if that is the case then make sure to get one with extra heavy duty coils to support the weight.

    Otherwise the glass top is better - I've never had trouble cleaning mine and I'm a sloppy cook and don't clean as often as I should.

    BTW - Induction won't help with the canning issue as all big pressure canners are aluminum.

    If you were close to SD, I'd let you have my 6 year old glass top stove - it works great but I just brought home an indcution cooktop and getting the range out of the house would sure motivate me to get the cooktop hooked up ASAP.

    Cathy

  • 16 years ago

    First of all, my sympathies on leaving the Wolf behind. I've had a Wolf AG range for 3 years and it's my favorite nice thing. A first for me, too.

    As for the electric range, you'll survive! We lived with one in our rental when we were building our house for about a year and a half and I turned out some nice dinners on it. I will be the contrarion here and say that I prefer the coiltop to a smoothtop if you're used to cooking on gas. My two gripes with the smoothtop (not related to lack of responsiveness vs. gas) in our rental were a) it was difficult to center pots directly over the burners (especially two large pots side-by-side or front-to-back and b) I worried about dropping one of my heavy cast iron or Le Creuset pots on it and breaking the glass. This was a real possibility as I had previously broken a gas-over-glass cooktop when a Le Creuset lid slipped from my hands and hit the edge of the cooktop. On the other hand, the smoothtop is easier to clean. Induction would be best but I think they start at over $2K? I think coiltops are actually hard to find as smoothtops have taken bulk of the electric range market.