Software
Houzz Logo Print
italiamom

Gas odor and vent return question

18 years ago

I have a Lacanche, Cluny 1400 and i would of asked this in that particular forum, but this is a general question for all folks that have a high BTU range and a 1200 cfm vent system,(i have a VentAHood). whenever i use the gas oven in my Cluny 1400 we smell gas. when new, we called ArtCulinare, they said not to worry, just the smell from the coating they place in the oven, will be gone after few uses and wipe it out well. 2 yrs. later, still smell the same gas odor. i have used it numerous times, and washed inside several times, no difference. top burners, no problem odors, only when i use the oven. temp.is pretty accurate.time has passed, and i just overlooked the issue. i just couldn't stand the odor anymore, i called and spoke to Greg again, he sent out a service in the Chicago area and when he turned on my oven, he said it's not gas, it's carbon monoxide that we're smelling, and that we need a return line to rid the carbon monoxide, or open a window to let fresh air in while the oven is on and the ventahood is running. we purchased a carbon monixide detector this morning, and tested it to make sure it worked, and placed it on the stove right where the oven vents on top for an hour with the oven set at 400 degrees, some time with the vent on and some time with the vent off, and nothing happened. no alarms went off, i opened the oven door, and held it almost in the oven, no alarms, moved it around the room, nothing. although, i'm happy to find out we're not killing ourselves every time i cook, what can this be? has anyone else needed to install a return line to their vent system or stove,(not sure what he meant), or needs to crack open a window to allow their system to draw the smells out? if so, why did i spend so much money on a 1200 cfm system?

by the way, none of these companies that i dealt with related to the purchase or installation of the ventahood mentioned a return line. thanks for our reply.

Marilyn

Comments (21)

  • 18 years ago

    First of all, I'm not sure how Greg or the service guy arrived at that conclusion. That's some theory!

    Secondly, what you are smelling is the naturally occurring scent of natural gas combustion. Some people just never get used to it, and this complaint appears regularly in this forum...

  • 18 years ago

    Carbon monoxide has no smell so he couldn't have possibly smelled carbon monoxide.

    By a return line he most likely meant makeup air. With a 1200 CFM hood it is possible that you need makeup air if your house is sealed really tightly - older houses typically are not. When you vent a lot of air out quickly if you don't have makeup air you can create a vacuum which can cause backup from your furnace which could be dangerous. Of course, you can always open a window to provide makeup air. There's a faq on this forum which discusses all this in more detail.

  • 18 years ago

    Thank you Joe Blowe and Weissman, i knew i could get some real help here. thanks for the advice. it is a new home, 2 yrs. old. the service man thought i had "sucker" written on my forehead, he wanted to charge me $2,000-$3,000.00 to run a return line in the wall. i'm just thrilled that we're not dying from carbon monixide. i tried to search on this website for Gas odors, and couldn't come up with what i needed. can you tell me what i should search for????
    Marilyn :)

  • 18 years ago

    No such thing as return line. Gas that is piped in is consumed or it leaks, period. If he was referring to a makeup air line, he obviously does not know the proper terminology, and is an idiot. NEVER trust him again.

    Both Carbon monoxide (dangerous and probably not produced in any appreciable amount in your range) and carbon dioxide (harmless in normal quantities) are odorless, so he is full of it. NEVER trust him again.

    I too have a 1200 CFM vent-a-hood. If I run it higher than one blower (300 CFM) I open a kitchen window.

    By the way, great thoughts on the carbon monoxide detector as a test set. You should permanently install it near (not in, as you will get false alarms) the kitchen.

    Now, as to the most important part of your question, the gas smell. Since it is only apparent with the oven going (correct?) and not the top burners, I would suggest getting in a few neighbors in and bake something. If they too detect a gas smell, don't use the oven until it is checked. Most if not all gas and propane companies will check for leaks for free. They have the proper tools to do it.

    What you may have is a leak or a crack in the pipe, manifold or venturi that feeds the oven, and some gas is escaping before it can burn. This is a very dangerous situation and must be repaired before safe operation can occur.

  • 18 years ago

    Cpovey, thank you so much for the advice, the serviceman is history for sure. 2 of my girlfriends were here when the serviceman was here, and they did smell the gas smell. i will call my gas co. on Monday for sure and will report back to all of you what happens. thank you again for all your great advice, you're all the BEST!!!
    Marilyn

  • 18 years ago

    One word of warning.In my part of the country if the gas company detects a gas leak they shut down your gas service until repairs are preformed.Then a pressure decay test will be preformed prior to restoring the gas service.

  • 18 years ago

    tommmy2007, i'm from the Chicago area and yes, they do the same thing here, that's why i'm a little nervous about calling the gas company. i put in another call over the weekend to the company i purchased my range, maybe he'll tell me to ditch the 1st serviceman he sent here and can find another one in my area. either way, that 1st guy will not be touching any of my appliances. it's not Art Culinaires' fault, since they're taking a chance with sub-contracting this work out in the different areas to which they sell, they want to help me, i know that for sure.
    Marilyn

  • 18 years ago

    You should have a valve on the stove's gas supply line . Try turning it off and see if the smell goes away. Or one step more. Put soapy water on the valve with it off and check it also.You might just be able to pinpoint the leak's location in two easy steps.

  • 18 years ago

    Hi
    I am having a gas leak issue as well with my new American Range 36" AG. We went on vacation for a week and when we returned and opened the front door we could smell gas. It was very strong in the kitchen and near the range. After opening all the windows and doors, we called the gas company. They did turn off the gas and tested all the lines. They found the only leak was the range, so they turned everything back on but that. We had a plumber come who checked the gas hookup which had been moved when the range was installed. He checked that and the connector hose and the back of the range and could not detect the leak. Since the gas smell was still there when he had the gas on, the conclusion is that the leak is coming from inside the range. I am waiting for the American Range service guy to come, hopefully tomorrow. We have now been without our range for a week and really missing it.

  • 18 years ago

    One word of warning.In my part of the country if the gas company detects a gas leak they shut down your gas service until repairs are preformed.

    This is not as much of a problem as blowing up from a gas leak.

    SInce the gas smell from the OP only occurs when the oven is in use (top burners produce no smell), it is probable that the leak is in the oven.

    italiamom, any status update?

  • 18 years ago

    Other than the service man calling Art Culinaire and telling Greg that i have a "make-up air problem and my oven is working as designed", he never mentioned i had a "carbon monoxide" issue. i spoke to Greg and told him what this Tony guy said to me, and that i would see about getting the issue fixed. the appliance co. (Abt Appliances), who i purchased my VentaHood from will have the rep (VentaHood rep, that is),call me tomorrow. possibly he'll explain to me what is the best way to fix this. it might be as simple as opening a window to help circulate the air. i just find it hard to understand why a 1200 cfm ventilaion system isn't doing the job. never had this problem with any of my other houses or stoves.
    i trust Abt appliance and i'd rather have their serviceman come out to check the problem and pay for the service call. i will also have the gas company come out if needed.
    i'll definitely tell you what happens next.
    Marilyn

  • 18 years ago

    italiamom - the issue is not with your hood - it's most likely with your range - have the repairman checkout the range itself for a gas leak as others have already told you - you don't rely on the hood to remove leaking gas, you rely on it to remove smoke, odors and grease. Whether or not you need makeup air for your 1200 CFM hood is a separate issue from your range leaking gas. If you have someone from the gas company in, they can test your range for leaks.

  • 18 years ago

    Weissman,
    I tend to agree with you, the smell that i smell is GAS, and only when i use the oven, these "Professionals" that i've been dealing with want me to believe i'm in need of better air circulation. tomorrow is my day off, and i'll make the call to the gas co. in the morning. i'll keep you posted. thanks all of you for your concern and great advice.
    Marilyn

  • 18 years ago

    Thank God you're getting the gas company out. I agree with weissman, the problem is with your oven. You can also buy a methane gas detector if you want to check yourself, but that's what the Gas company and your nose is for. Please be careful with that gas leak.

  • 18 years ago

    When a lot of ovens light they start lighting from one end or side of the burner and the flame follows the gas supply around the burner's orifices.So it doesn't light all at once and some gas goes unburned resulting in a odor. Thats just a odor to me not a leak. If I was worried about blowing up I would turn my on gas off. If you dont know how to do that I would call 911 (and remember thats after you exited your home ). You got to use common sense in these matter. If your gas company like mine it would be to late by the time they showed up.

  • 18 years ago

    Yipeee, Nicor gas came out this morning, within an hour after i called. she had her meter reader thing and, no gas leaks anywhere. she ran it all around the range and i even had her stick it right in the oven and hold it there, all readings were, 00. i had the oven on for an hour before she came, she said she doesn't smell gas, she said it's more like a burn off smell. tommmy2007, the servicewoman who just came out from the gas co. said what you said in your reply above, about lighting initially and it doesn't light all at once and some gas goes unburned. i'm soooo happy i finally got this worry over, thanks to all of your great replies, and suggestions. VentaHood will still contact me today and although i may miss his call due to errands that need to be done,(day off), i'll call him back and see if he can teach me to use the exhaust system properly. i may need to put it on full blast before i turn on the oven, or crack that window as suggested. either way, i'll keep you all posted when i speak to him. Thanks a million for everyone's suggestions.
    Marilyn

  • 18 years ago

    As I mentioned at the very top of this thread, this "I'm smelling gas" issue comes up regularly in this forum, and the conclusion is (from what I can recall) almost always the same: "There is/was no leak."

    I'm not saying that people should ignore the smell of gas, and they should definitely make sure all is well with their equipment. But, hopefully enough of these threads will remain in some minds around here so as not to send up major red flags, e.g. a gentle suggestion that all is probably well, call a repairman for peace of mind.

    Here is a link that might be useful: The last smell thread (only parts of which apply)...

  • 18 years ago

    Marilyn

    I have a Sully and when I start up my gas oven I too smell gas (sometimes pretty strong), but it dissipates quickly. Art Culinaire explained to me that it is gas in the line that escapes before the electronic ignition gets it lit. My igniter does "click" for 5 secs or so before the pilot lights, so that made sense to me. It does take some getting used to if you have been all electric before.

    MaryT

  • 18 years ago

    We have a GE Profile and in the last six months - one of the knobs has gotten kicked on slightly twice. The knobs do not take much to push and turn. Anyway - They get turned on, but not enough for the ignitor to start. The result - a house that smells like sauerkraut and something that seems like it's probably dangerous. Am I overreacting? Is this just the way it is or does our range have issues?

  • 18 years ago

    I don't think the range itself has issues - I think you need to be more careful to make sure you check to make sure the knobs aren't on - particularly when you go to sleep - yes it's potentially dangerous to have the range leaking gas into the house but it's up to you to make sure the knobs are turned off.