Good luck deciphering the model numbers.
For instance, KSCS25FVMK versus KSCS25FVMS versus KSCS25FVSS

My search is focusing in on the Bosch 36" SXS. It's the narrowest depth free standing that I've found. Very reasonable at between 2K-2.3K depending on model.

We are looking at this Fisher & Paykel model, but are a long way from deciding. Everything with ice through the door seems to have serious issues.

Here is a link that might be useful: Fisher & Paykel Counter Depth French Door

Thanks. I agree w/ confusing Kitchen Aid model nos, even the different description of stainless models is confusing, monochromatic, etc.

We are looking at these if we go for a free standing refrigerator.

Here is a link that might be useful: Liebherr Free Standing Refrigerators

Looks like a counterdepth model will run about $500 over the cost of a standard depth with the same features and which has slightly more interior volume.

What justifies the higher cost?

Here is a link that might be useful: Standard Depth

Pay more, get less. It's the American way. :-)

Either that or the demand is much lower and the economy of scale isn't there like it is for standard depth refrigerators. Thus, counter depth models cost more.

Our KA counterdepth KBls20EV was delivered and istalled last Tues. Though I've only had it a few days I love it so far. We have hinge left, full door. I didn't want french doors and am glad I stayed with that thought. With the fridge cabinet built around it, it almost looks built in. It is quiet, roomier than I expected an a nice change to have the fridge on top. Our 1995 white KA is still working great and in our basement now for an extra when needed. Never had a problem with it. I hope this new one is as good.

I'm gravitating toward the Samsung.

I bought a Samsung counterdepth, no ice or water, I really like it. It is 2" wider than my old full size GE & I have way more storage space in it.

I'm looking at the Samsung with ice/water. It's counterdepth and 24-25cuFt. it's taller than the KA/Kenmore/Whirlpool, around 72". That's how it gets the larger interior volume.

The Samsung RSG257AAB is shorter than the Kitchenaid KSCS25FVMK: 68-5/8" versus 71-1/2" and has slightltly less volume at 24.1 cubic feet storage versus 24.5