Software
Houzz Logo Print
mahatmacat1

mongo, are you there?

18 years ago

Hey mongo,

If you happen to see this, I would really appreciate if you could share some of your non-bath-related expertise...believe it or not, the wonderful atlantic blue cedar in our front yard (around maybe 50' tall, 24" diameter) fell on our house and car on Wednesday. I was home at the time, but luckily no one was hurt, and the damage was surprisingly minimal given what it could have been.

USAA has already given us their settlement (the writeups for both house and car, not the actual monetary transfers, which supposedly come next week) for the repairs, including a complete re-roof. I was perusing the other fora to find what I can about roofing choices and I'm wondering if you can answer a small question for me. You said you don't use pot vents (back in summer '07 on a post in the remodeling forum). We currently have them, but then again we currently feel the upstairs is like an oven in summer, and a freezer in winter. We'll probably address some insulation issues ourselves, and we could sure use more air circulation. Would you recommend that when this is being done, we have the pot vents changed out to a ridge vent?

And what is your thinking on the stone-coated metal roofs? I like them because they're metal, with all associated ecological and safety benefits, and yet more walkable than usual metal. I also like standing seam, but I want to be able to get up on the roof if necessary to trim overhanging branches...I'm concerned that they'll look --well...yucky. Any thoughts you have on them would be most appreciated.

SO much to learn in the next week! Garage doors, roofing in its entirety, auto body work...ay ay ay... thanks in advance.

Comments (15)

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I'm all for metal roofing, the next time I reroof my house I'll be going metal.

    With regards to your roof and ventilation...you wrote that "...the upstairs is like an oven in summer, and a freezer in winter."

    Is "the upstairs" unfinished open attic space, or is it your finished living space?

    Do you have open unfinished attic? Or is your "roof" also the (cathedral?) ceiling of your upstairs living space?

    Hot summer attics/living spaces are usually the result of radiant gain through the roof, and venting the attic or cathedral ceiling rafter bays does not necessarily cool the space down.

    I've moved away from vented roofs towards "hot" or unvented roofs, but that can only effectively be done with changes in insulation as well. No fiberglass, I use either foam or dense-packed cellulose insulation, or a foam/cells combo.

    More later, gots to go for now.

    Sorry about the roof!

    Mongo

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Thanks for your reply, mongo. Funny, I read about just the kind of roof/wall construction you describe in a piece in the Oregonian today about green building practices. Afraid retrofitting the house would be almost impossible, at this point.

    At a house tour today that I think used those very methods you describe, I *also* happened upon the LP TechShield OSB with a pre-attached radiant barrier with some incisions on it to promote fast drying. That would prevent the radiant gain you describe--we're thinking of going for a complete redo of the OSB (the insurance settlement calls only for replacement of 200 sf--the rest will stay--it's a 2133 sf roof) to put this stuff down, and just staying with the pot vents. Would that be a better idea?

    You are so cutting edge, in this case in your knowledge of construction methods, but of course I know this only scratches the surface of your range of expertise--so cool (and you almost never vent! :)).

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    OH, and I forgot to answer your question, in my enthusiasm about the Techshield. The house is one big A-frame and part of the upstairs is still unfinished attic, part is DD's cathedral-ceilinged bedroom. It isn't heated or cooled centrally, though, as it was originally just open to the downstairs but previous owners closed it off. *Supposedly* in OR, you don't need AC. But with climate change it's gotten very different even since the house was built in the 70s.

    We'd like to avoid getting central AC just for ecological reasons--I'm hoping the TechShield will address the heat that builds in there in the summer. The LP website *claims* that it retains heat in the winter, but I don't see that reflected in the energy bill savings graph.

    Anyway, just thought I'd give you a clearer picture of our domestic situation :)

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Wow!

    I swear I posted a reply yesterday, but it's no where to be found.

    Oh well...whatever I wrote I guarantee was witty, lucid...everything you'd want in a reply from me. Now if I could only remember what the heck I wrote...

    Anyway, it looks like all you're going to do now is a spot repair to the roof? Or are you still going with metal? I've never seen a stone metal roof that wasn't a slate/shake/tile look-a-like. They do work well though.

    Some manufacturer's have energy star rated roofs, mostly due to the color. There have been tax credits in effect for energy star upgrades to houses, they've been available for the past few years. I'm not sure when they terminate.

    But upgrading your insulation and reroofing would qualify you for those credits. If they are still in effect.

    Foil-faced barriers can work...or they may not work. I'm nore concrete than abstract, so I go for the sure thing...either dense-packed cellulose or a couple inches of polyiso foam. Both will air seal your house. Air movement is an R-value killer, and both get rid of air movement.

    They both block radiant, which helps keep you cooler in the summer and warmer in the winter.

    Now I can tell you what I did in my own house. When I built my house, no one sold cellulose around here, so I had fiberglass in my unfinished attic's rafter bays. And yes, my walk-up attic was hot in the summer, upwards of 120 degrees, and cold in the winter.

    The day I added the polyiso I tool my wife's Polder kitchen thermometer, it was 127 degrees at the peak.

    I hung 2" thick sheets of foil-faced polyiso on the faces of the rafters. I attached them with 3 or 4 nails with 3" button caps per 4' by 8' sheet, and I gapped the sheets about 3/8" away from the neighboring sheets. the ends of the sheets do not have to fall over a rafter, they can break over a rafter bay. No worries.

    I then took a sharpie marker and, peeking through the gaps between the sheets, I located the rafters behind the polyiso and put a tick mark on the foil face of the polyiso to show where the rafters were.

    I then used canned foam to foam the gaps between the sheets.

    Then I use aluminum tape to tape over the canned foam. The attic was now tight as a drum. Zero air movement. And the 2" of polyiso was a rock solid radiant barrier, even without the foil face.

    The next day the temperature in the attic was 77 degrees. No exaggeration a drop of 50 degrees.

    I put 2" thick polyiso on the cathedral ceiling and 1" polyiso on the gable end walls.

    I then used 2" to 3" wide rips of 3/4" CDX plywood and ran them horizontally across the ceiling, 16" on center. I used long screws to screw the 3/4" thick strips through the 2" of foam and into the edges of the rafters, which were easy to locate due to the marks I made earlier with the sharpie marker.

    I then had a drywall crew come in (Mongo doesn't do drywall) and hang the drywall, they screwed it to the furring strips with standard 1-1/8" screws.

    Viola!

    I have no heat in my attic, yet we use it year round here in CT. Summertime, since the air handler is up there behind one of the knee walls, I did run a couple AC vents and returns, but we never really use the AC.

    I added some faux beams to hide eletrical wire behind, as well as to break up the long runs of cathedral ceiling.

    Added wainscotting around the entire 45' by 18-19' room. Added five storage doors to each 45' long wall to get access to the storage behind the kneewalls. Did bamboo flooring, about 850 sqft. Built a bookcase around the walk-up stairway. Added five pendant lights that I bought from...ta da...Rejuvenation Lighting out in Portland.

    Total coast was about $8000 or about $9 per sqft.

    These pics are the only ones I have of the process. The last one, half the wood (beams) is painted, half (bookcase and wainscotting) is still only primed.

    There are other ways to achieve the same thing...densepacked cellulose, etc. This is just one way.

    But the thermal performance is indeed awesome. In winter if we go up there, the room may be about 65 degrees. Turn on the lights, a few bodies, and within minutes it's toasty warm. I did run wire to hang a couple of ceiling fans from the faux ridge beam, but they were never needed, so they never went in.

    Half the attic is the TV and home theater, the other half is games, ping pong, foosball, darts, etc.

    I have a window seat running the 18' to 19' length of each gable end wall, they hid the AC ducts and also allow for a lot of storage, board games, etc.

    I'd love to someday build a close to net-zero house, but I could never get my wife to move out of this place. I might get a chance to try with a vacation home I might build on an island. We'll see.

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Ah, thanks, mongo! I wish we could be building the whole room new, but unfortunately the bedroom part is already drywalled, so anything we put in there would have to be from the outside in, hence the TechShield idea.

    Let me clarify about the situation a bit if I can (sorry if I'm coming across muddy): The aspect that is "spot repair" is just replacing the part of the OSB (I didn't put OSB down, PO did) that was damaged by the tree, which is 10% of the roof. The rest of the roof will be complete shingle tearoff and reroof, but the underlayment (or whatever the word is for roofs) stays the same as it wasn't damaged. We're likewise having to get only partial gutter repair--one part is fine, untouched, but about 3/4 of it needs replacing.

    I spoke to one roofer today who very sensibly expressed reserve about any supposed miracle material promoted by LP...I hear him on his concern, given LP's record of promises that turn out to be disasters...he has phenomenal reviews on angieslist so I'm inclined to give him the benefit of the doubt. He's right, it doesn't have the test of time behind it yet, and we don't practically know how it affects the other parts of the structure. He did say he'd look into it, though--wasn't entirely closed-minded.

    We were considering metal, until we found out about the TechShield...now we're trying to decide if we can get a similar energy efficiency without the metal roof...I got one metal roof quote so far (aluminum shingles) and it's about twice what our ins. is offering to pay, but then again I'm waiting to hear what the asphalt roofing bids come in at, with and without the TechShield option...There's only one other metal roof in our neighborhood--otherwise split between cedar shake and architectural asphalt. I am very disinclined toward asphalt, myself, but would choose it over cedar. If all the metal roof quotes come in that high, I think I may have to go with asphalt, unfortunately...my ideal would be standing seam metal--I need to get a quote on that.

    If anyone deserves a shot at a net-zero house, it would be you. Maybe tell her you're building a spec house and then present her with it when you're done? :)

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    My other recommendation, somewhat muddled, would be to add cellulose insulation.

    If the techshield was going to be over your finished bedroom, then just use OSB or ply and blow the space between the sheathing and the drywall full of dense-packed cellulose.

    It will minimize air infiltration, deaden sound, block radiant gain and loss, all without violating the interior drywall.

    And, hopefully, it'll do all that without the installer blowing the drywall off the framing!

    Mongo

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    AH! I get it! Probably less invasive than ripping up the OSB ...brilliant, mongo--I'm going to go research that right now. Maybe a small hole could be cut in the OSB (wish it were ply) to put the hose in, fill up each cavity, and then cover it over? Or is there an open space somewhere when the OSB comes off?

    That's seriously wonderful. Hope springs again...

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    A cellulose installer could give you a better idea when he puts his eyes on your roof. But:

    1) They could drill a 3" hole every 8-10' or so up the bay. Stuff the hoes in, fill from the bottom of the bay up to the hole, then stuff the hose up and fill from the ridge down to the hole.

    2) Just take a circular saw and remove a 6" to 8" wide strip of OSB all the way across the roof, half way between the ridge and the soffit. Same thing, fill bottom to gap, top to gap. Reset cut out strip.

    Emphasize "dense pack" when you talk to an installer, Dense packing refers to blowing in the cellulose at a density greater than its natural settling density.

    Example, blow a big pile of cellulose and let it sit. Over time it will settle until it reaches its natural settling density, then it will settle no more. That number is about 2.7 pounds per cubic foot.

    I normally blow in cellulose at a number higher than that, about 3.5 pounds per cubic foot. This means that the cellulose will never settle over time, as it has been installed at a density higher than its natural settling density.

    How to assure the density is correct? The installer needs to do a bag count. Compute the volume of a rafter bay, and count how many bags of cells it takes to fill that bay. Experienced guys are good, they can tell by the sound and feel. A novice installer? He needs to practice on a stud or rafter bay mockup put together with screws. Blow it full. Run the numbers to figure the achieved density. Unscrew the ply and see just how full the rafter bay is, looking for voids, etc.

    For your unfinished attic, a mesh called Insulweb can be put on the rafter faces in the attic, and then blown full of cells. No need to add drywall at this time.

    ABOVE: Unfilled insulweb.


    ABOVE: Fille insulweb.

    Ain't it grand, Flyleft! I'll have you building houses in no time at all.

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Glad you posted this. We're actually going to be finishing off some 3rd floor attic space, and mongo, your method would fit well (our space is under a hip roof, so it'll be more pyramidal, and with no windows). One question: If you seal it airtight, don't you have problems with humidity/condensation?

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    oh mongo, thanks for the photos--but I'm concerned...

    I found these quotes about the moisture in cellulose when it's blown in:

    Cellulose insulation is mixed with water and can take anywhere from 72 hours to over 1 year to completely dry. The drying time depends on the installation mix, moisture retarder, temperature, climate and when the drywall is installed.

    Blown in cellulose insulation is mixed with water and if it is not given a proper drying time before the wall cavity is sealed up, studies show that it could retain the moisture in the insulation for over a year.

    We'd be sealing up the cavity well before it probably would have a chance to dry...what's your experience with this aspect?
    And this one, concerning the need for a vapor barrier (which I can't figure out how we'd do it (if not ripping off the OSB):
    It's recommended that you use a vapor barrier with both blown in cellulose insulation and fiberglass insulation applications. Preventing moisture/water leaks is a key factor in getting the best results for you home insulation. it's also important to allow internal moisture to escape.

    The vapor barrier one really seems the biggest sticking point...

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    That's wet blown cellulose.

    Blow it dry. When you dense pack it in an already closed framing bay you blow it dry.

    If you need to blow it into an open bay, then use the insulmesh to contain the cellulose until drywall is installed.

    People wet blow cellulose when they are blowing it into open stud cavities without using the insulmesh. The added moisture allows it to stick to itself so it doesn't fall out of the bay.

    I'm not an advocate of wet blown cellulose.

    As to the vapor barrier, as building technology improves there is a move against them, especially i moderate climates like yours. With FG you need one for several reasons, one being the large amount of air that can move through fiberglass. More air movement means more moisture carried though the insulation.

    With dense packed cellulose, you'll get little air movement. Two coats of paint on the interior side of your drywall can qualify as a vapor retarder.

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Superb, mongo...thank you so much. I will look into this--I wonder if hope will send up any little new shoots...

    And on something even *further* off topic, are you watching Carrier on PBS? I can't remember--for which branch were you a pilot? Ever launch off aircraft carriers? Really impressed with the two women pilots in the group.

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    weedy,

    Not necessarily. Like most things, moisture has to be dealt with on a "whole house" level. Briefly...

    Entry: If you have moisture problems in your basement, then sealing the lid of your house may not be a good idea until the basement is remediated.

    Generated: Control moisture generated in the house with bath fans, kitchen fans, etc.

    Movement: If your house is drafty it can work for you and against you. Generally against you. Use canned foam to seal any penetrations between the basement and living space. Seal outlets if drafty. Have a decent air sealed lid if you have a scuttle hole up to your attic. Things like that.

    Air movement is an R-value killer in most houses, and most people have no idea how leaky there houses are. Too drafty is bad. Too tight is bad. You may need a HRV to moderate your air quality.

    Everything in moderation, you know?

    Open vented attics were good in Grandma's day when there was no moisture control within the house. The leakiness of the house actually helped excess moisture out of the house. Grandma's house may have been somewhat cold and somewhat drafty, but she never had moisture or rot problems.

    An easy way to find air movement is when inspecting fiberglass insulation in an attic. Wherever you see discolored areas of insulation, it's usually where the insulation is acting like a filter. Air is moving through that spot and the FG is filtering out and capturing airborne contaminants and pollutants, resulting in the discoloration.

    As far as condensation, that will only occur if moist air touches a surface that is below dew point temperature. The beauty of foam is that dew point occurs within or behind the foam, so warm air from within the house never touches anything below dew point, so no condensation.

    Sort of the same with cellulose, where air infiltration is minimal through dense packed cellulose, so first, you get little moist air into the cellulose. Second, were moist air to hit dew point within the thickness of the cellulose insulation, cellulose can actually hold moisture until a drying cycle occurs, then it will give up the moisture back to atmosphere. All with no degradation to the insulation or your framing.

    When moist air passes through FG and hits dew point, it condenses on the glass fibers, accumulates, compacts the FG, which actually increases convective air movement which can result in more condensation, and the wetness/compaction lowers the R-value and thermal performance of the FG. Plus you have condensing water in your framing bay, with the long term mold/mildew/rot problems associated with that.

    Cellulose isn't the end-all solution, but it's a heckuva lot better than FG.

    Closed cell foams are great, open cell foams are okay but they need to be detailed a bit more than closed cell foams.

    Now, there is a fair amount of give and take with what I wrote. No absolutes. Sort of a disclaimer there. What I wanted to do was touch on the basics in 520 words or less. Brevity is not my strong point when discussing theory!

    Mongo

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Fly, nope, haven't even heard of "Carrier", but I'll give it a look-see.

    I was Air Force. A-10s and F-117s. I'm an A-10 guy at heart. Down and dirty, all the action up close and personal.

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Fly, I caught an episode of "Carrier" last night. Called "Groundhog Day". I like the show, I'll keep an eye out for additional episodes in the series.

    Six-plus month deployments? That's not the life for me. I took the cushy way out.

    Go Air Force!

    Mongo

0
Sponsored
Whisler Home Improvement
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars9 Reviews
Franklin County's Committed Home Improvement Professionals