Software
Houzz Logo Print
mereanne_gw

Recommendations for 36' dual-fuel range

17 years ago

I'm looking for recommendations for a pro-style 36" dual-fuel range that will be installed in an existing brick kitchen fireplace. Reliability and style are my highest priorities and I'm willing to be flexible in other areas (btus, low simmer, oven capacity, etc) since I'm just an amateur and definitely not a master chef. Because of the existing architecture of the fireplace and location of two adjacent recessed windows, I can't go any wider than 36."

I've researched this forum for days and have seen many opinions but am still completely confused. What are your thoughts on the Viking, Thermador, Jennair, and Monogram dual-fuel freestanding ranges? Thoughts on other brands that I should consider? I was ready to go with the Viking but the comments about repair issues scare me.

Comments (17)

  • 17 years ago

    Bosch.

  • 17 years ago

    I couldn't find a 36" dual-fuel Bosch (saw a 30"). Thoughts on the thermador 36" pro grand or pro harmony?

  • 17 years ago

    Oops, sorry. Yes the Bosch is only 30" wide. Can't help you with the others.

  • 17 years ago

    I love my Thermador 36" DF PH range.

  • 17 years ago

    Great to hear that you are happy with the Thermador range. Right now that's my favorite but I'm not sure whether to go with Pro Grand or Pro Harmony. We have sufficient depth available in the fireplace to go with the 27" deep Pro Grand, but I don't know that we need it.

    DH just threw me a curve ball last night when he said he really loves the La Cornue Albertine... totally different type of range and not what I was expecting at all. It's an interesting thought though and something I should probably look into.

  • 17 years ago

    I don't normally like to chime in unless I have personal experience with a product, but I did quite a bit of research selecting the range that is going in our new lake house that is still under construction. I looked at lots of different manufacturers before finally settling on a 48" GE Monogram Range. As I said, the house is not finished yet so I don't have any first hand experience cooking on the range, but I was quite impressed with it when I examined it in a showroom. Fit and finish on it were excellent. There are a lot of excellent features shared by both the Thermador and GE Monogram ranges, so I won't go into them. The GE Monogram, however, has some features that I think make it better than the Thermador that you are considering, so in case you haven't considered these differences, I want to call them to your attention...

    * Max BTUs: Thermador-15,000; GE Monogram-18,000
    * Low/simmer: Thermador-2 burners; GE Monogram-all
    * Wok grates: Thermador-special order: GE Monogram - all grates reversible to wok
    * Oven racks must be removed for self-cleaning?: Thermador-Yes; GE Monogram-NO

    As an aside, I LOVED the GE Monogram's full extension oven racks that are on a ball-bearing system. After sliding them I understand why the other posters raved about them.

    In terms of reliablity, both companies seem to make reliable products and I have been happy with the Thermador cooktop and ovens in our primary residence. I have been monitoring these forums to see if there are any reliablity or service issues with the GE Monogram ranges. Although there are a number of people who are unhappy with their GE Monogram refrigerators, I haven't read of any service or reliability issues with their new ranges.(Up until last year the ranges were made by DCS, but I understand GE is now making the ranges themselves.) For what it's worth, of the ranges on your original list I ruled out Viking and Jenn Air immediately, because I had read too many reports of unhappy owners.

    It's all so personal, so I urge you to actually go to look at each of these ranges and then make a choice. What is important to me, might not matter to you. The La Cornue Albertine certainly looks beautiful, so I can understand why your husband is attracted to it. Just make sure that you both like the features that it offers vis-a-vis the other ranges you're considering, so you are not disappointed in the long run.

    And again, sorry for the flub re: Bosch at the beginning of this post. We installed a 30" Bosch at the garage apartment of our lake house (which thankfully IS completed) and I do like it very much. Too bad they don't make a 36".

  • 17 years ago

    I think Bertazzoni just realeased a 36" dual fuel range. The look is very nice on the Berta and if you were wanting something different they come in colours as well as stainless.

  • 17 years ago

    I went to our local appliance dealer today and checked out the Monogram ball bearing oven racks- wow, that is a super feature!

    I also lookeed at the installation specs for both the Monogram and Thermador ranges. For some reason, the Monogram specifies 12" between the range and a combustible side wall whereas the Thermador only specifies 3". We will have 6" based on the width of the fireplace opening. Our architect has said that this shouldn't matter, since a brick fireplace is non-combustible- it's okay for fires, right?

    I would add a 3-D rendering of the space, but I haven't figured out how to add a picture to a posting yet.

    I've seen pictures of the Bertazzoni, but haven't seen a real one yet- it does look nice though.

  • 17 years ago

    From looking on line (link below - see page 4) it appears that there is the usual requirement for non-combustible material on the wall above the range and below the hood. Countertops can be installed on both sides of the GE Monogram range, but any side wall adjoining the countertops must be at least 12" away from the range burners. I assume this is because of the intense heat that can be generated by the burners.

    I'm not sure exactly what you are calling a "fireplace" that you are installing this range in. Is it totally brick from floor to hood, or only from the cooktop surface up? I recommend you check with your architect, contractor, and your GE dealer (and check local codes), but my guess is that you will be fine if you plan on installing the range within a brick "fireplace"(?) that provides a suitably insulated noncombustible surface on both sides. The drawing accompanying the GE Monogram installation manual shows what appears to be a sheet-rocked wall (not brick) 12" away from the cooktop, but better safe than sorry.

    BTW - Re: the "fireplace" that you are installing the range within. One other thing you might want to consider is the width of the range hood above. Although we're installing a 48" GE Monogram hood above our 48" range (doing this because we got a terrific deal on the exhaust hood, and I think it will be adequate), there are many folks on the forum that recommend that your hood be at least 6 inches wider than your cooktop. Do a search on this forum and you'll find plenty of threads on the topic. You might want to figure out your hood before you lock yourself into a particular width of brick "fireplace."

    Here is a link that might be useful: Installation Manual for GE Mongram 36

  • 17 years ago

    We actually have a functioning all brick fireplace in our kitchen, floor to ceiling and 1.5 stories high. This fireplace is part of the chimney on one end of our home. The prior owner painted the chimney and used the fireplace as a decorative nook rather than using it for fires. We haven't ever built a fire in it, but considered installing gas logs at one point and then changed our minds.

    In any case, right now there are no cabinets or appliances on that wall. We are planning to partially recess the range in the fireplace opening (20" deep firebox) and build shallow cabinetry (12" deep) in front of the brick wall for a continuous built-in look.

    Here is a snapshot of the design- the first image shows the fireplace wall without including the island in the way (for better visibility). The second image includes the island.

    This design assumes that the opening is widened to 48" so that there would be 6" on either side of the 36" range to accommodate pot handles, etc. and ensure sufficient clearance between surfaces. Because the opening is 48" wide, we are assuming the need to install a 48" range hood. I am worried that the hood will overwhelm the range...but not sure how else to design the integrated hood/chimney and are still working the details with our architect. {{gwi:1404930}}From Kitchen Remodel
    {{gwi:1404931}}From Kitchen Remodel

  • 17 years ago

    I have the Monogram DF range. It has been 85% satisfactory. The ignitors/spark plugs sometimes don't shut themselves off. But it bakes great, convection is quiet, simmer is on all 4 burners (mine has a grill) and is amazingly low. The fit & finish is excellent, no sharp edges or unfinished-looking places. In service since Jan 07.
    Casey

  • 17 years ago

    Casey, do you know if your GE Monogram range was made by DCS, or is it one of the new ones made by GE? Just curious...I think the changeover occurred in 2008, so it sounds like yours might be one of the DCS ones (which were also reputed to be very good).
    Can you elablorate on the ignitor/spark issue? Have you had a service call to fix it? My Thermador cooktop occasionally does this when I have the downdraft running, but I just have to cut off the downdraft briefly and it stops.
    Thanks!

  • 17 years ago

    Look at Ilve....It's Italian and very high-end!!!! I also would strongly urge you to look at the ALL GAS BlueStar. It is truly a restaurant quality range (they do not use electric ovens) with POWER and PERFORMANCE. CHeck it out!!!

    Here is a link that might be useful: Ilve

  • 17 years ago

    Wow the Ilve range is beautiful- I love the look of the antique white version. I've never heard of this brand before, nor have I seen one in a showroom. Does anyone have any experience with this range? It looks like the oven capacity is pretty small.

  • 17 years ago

    Yes, mine is a DCS-era range. The ignitors, of their own volition, decide to keep sparking after a burner has lit. It mostly quits after 10 seconds. This sometimes happens after a pot overflows and wets the sparky-deal. One time, the sparky-deals stopped working all together. This initiated a service call; by the time the repairman arrived, they had already started working again; this has never recurred.

  • 17 years ago

    Hi all -

    Glad to find this thread because we're in the middle of a house renovation, and I have the new 48" GE Monogram dual fuel on order. I looked at ALL the other choices mentioned above, and chose the Monogram for the same reasons mentioned by all of you. Would love to hear more real life experience on it.

    Also, I wanted to add my two cents about the older GE Monogram dual fuel made by DCS. In our last house, we had a DCS all-gas range (bought in 2003) and although we liked it very much when it was working, it had frequent issues. The spark igniter problem was an onogoing frustration with our range. Our service guy indicated that it was a common issue with the DCS range so I imagine that it was also an issue with the Monogram when it was made by DCS. I know that the burners were the exact same on the older Monogram as on our DCS (which we loved when they were working properly). Hopefully, that burner ignitiion/sparking issue won't be a problem with the 2009 Monogram, now that it's made by GE. Not that GE has a stellar track record themselves, but they probably addressed the spark/igniter issue because it was a major pain.

    My appliance salesman (who is very proud of the fact that he's recently been to GE for Monogram training) said that before pulling the Monogram range production back in-house, GE did a lot of research, took what was best about the DCS design/performance and added their own improvements to come up with the new range.

    Mine will be installed by late summer. In the meantime, I'm looking forward to hearing more news from Monogram owners.

    Thanks
    Susan

  • 17 years ago

    Have continued to investigate the Ilve and it looks like we may be able to squeeze the 40" model into our space. I am particularly intrigued by the Coup de Feu feature. Does anyone have experience with that model?