Software
Houzz Logo Print
newly_suburban

help with induction understanding of elements, boosting etc

17 years ago

Hi all,

Can someone help me figure out the difference in power and functioning in the induction cooktops.

I have decided to get a 36 inch induction and have been looking at the inductionsite website, but don't really understand what power to look at.

I am considering Wolf (5 elements, 2 boost) and Diva (5 elements no boost) and also Electrolux and Miele which are both 5 element, 5 boost. I can't figure out where there is power sharing and from a pure heat capacity per burner, which is better.

It seems that Wolf does have an advantage in higher capacity in the largest burner (without and with the boost). But I am really not sure I understand all the implications.

Thanks

Comments (8)

  • 17 years ago

    I was never clear about Diva, after reading everything available on the web, whether it truly has no power sharing or not. They have knowledgeable people who answer the phone however, so I recommend calling them.

    You probably know this, but just to be clear: The elements are often paired in order to make the electrical numbers work out to how much of a draw they want to allow you to do. Elements will be paired so that they can both be on at normal, mid-range output, but can't both be at the tip top setting. What boost does is take some of the power that's not being used by a paired element and gives it to the boosted element.

    If you look at the users' manuals of the individual units (not much available online for Diva) they should say which elements are paired, and what output they have, and what they boost to/are limited during boost to. It will also say if there's a time limit on the boost function.

    The things that the boost will be most useful for are boiling and wokking. I'm more of a slow food kind of cook, so can't advise specifically.

    Do take the charts on The Induction site with a grain of salt however (not to be allowed to linger on the unit's surface since salt can scratch). It's an excellent resource, but there are errors that are either out of date, oversights, or misreading of the promotional literature.

    I really recommend reading through the manuals of the units you're looking at. You'll learn a lot that way.

    Tenths difference in output specs shouldn't be noticable for your cooking.

    I haven't seen the Wolf and Electrolux in action, but I can tell you the Miele is very quiet, and if you choose it as a programmed setting, has 17 power levels (though it's billed at only 9). That's not a difference in output, but in how fine a control over it you have.

  • 17 years ago

    I have the Miele 36" induction. It has 12 power levels that can be extended to 23 levels. All burners have boost. The largest burner in the center has double boost and does not power share. The burners on the right power share as do the burners on the left. Power sharing has never been a limitation -- although I can have 3 burners on boost at the same time, I've never needed to boost more than 2 at the same time.

  • 17 years ago

    One thing that has us leaning towards the Wolf is that the Miele only comes in a smooth black finish that will show every speck of dust, fingerprint and scratch (inevitable) on the cooktop; the Wolf comes with a textured pattern that will hide much of that.

    Perhaps silly, but IMHO a long-term practicality issue.

  • 17 years ago

    My cooktop doesn't show fingerprints and I wipe it off every time I cook so there's no chance to accumulate dust. I don't have any scratches. An acquaintance has had this same cooktop for over a year and I looked at hers closely and could see no scratches. She may have been very careful with her cooktop, I'm not sure.

  • 17 years ago

    erika... I'm leaning toward the 36" Miele. Do you use any kind of paper or one of those silicone mats underneath it?

  • 17 years ago

    Hi Elyse, I haven't used anything at all under my pans. I was planning to buy Silpat mats but then I read on the forum how someone's melted. If I were going to deep fry something I might use a paper towel, but I haven't yet. I probably lift my pans when I move them more than slide them, but I don't baby my cooktop. I think you'd be very happy with one. Modern and sleek looking, reasonably priced for a high quality brand, easy to clean, powerful, quiet, lots of functions and pretty!

    Good luck!

    E

  • 17 years ago

    Manufacturers of most anything establish price points for their products and then try to design to cost (cost plus profit equals price in this simplified view). Some manufacturers' customers are used to paying more for more (probably not in a linear relationship) and these manufacturers can afford to use more "hefty" electronics and cooling systems in their induction cooktops.

    One way of having one's cake and eating it too is power sharing, wherein a power supply of fixed wattage is allocated to two hobs. The power available is fixed at less than the continuous duty capability of the two hobs combined. Thus, as noted in an earlier message above, one cannot run both hobs at full power at once. This may or may not be an issue, depending on what one is cooking, and how the different menu items are timed for cooking.

    Obviously, trying to simultaneously bring 5 pots to boil in minimum time would require full power from each hob. Most cooking is done with high power required from only one or two hobs at a time, so the manufacturer's limit on power supply output is adequate. Also I would note as an owner of a Kenmore 36-inch induction cooktop (a clone of the Electrolux model), having a lot of hobs on high power at once is a challenge in keeping control of one's cooking while doing something besides staring at the cooktop. The power output of the hobs is so great that once boiling is achieved, a significant excess of power will still be input to the pans unless the power is reduced. This can quickly cause a spillover. I use a timer and experience to avoid this problem.

    There is another capability besides power sharing that is often included. Power boost allows one hob to operate at a power level that the electronics can't sustain indefinitely given the cooling system. Hence, for about 10 minutes for my Kenmore, I can operate a hob in power boost mode so long as I don't use the shared hob at high power. (I'm not sure of the time limit if the second hob on that side is being used at modest power.) Some processor within the cooktop electronics keeps track of the power allocation and cooling so nothing overheats (except the pan if one isn't paying attention).

    In summary, the hobs, cooling, and power supply designs are established to allow various combinations of boost, continuous full power, and partial power within the limitations of a fixed maximum power and a fixed maximum cooling capacity. Even when the situation forces some hobs to operate at less than full power, the power input to the pots and pans is still competitive with gas.

    And best of all, if you are distracted and get a spill, it is easy to clean up immediately because the spill doesn't normally bake onto the cooktop and the cooktop itself is much less hot than gas burner parts or electric radiant heat surfaces.

    kas

  • 17 years ago

    kucharsk:
    that's funny because the wolf's patterned top is one reason i did not choose it. my post-katrina contractor replaced my orignal cooktop with a kenmore that had a similar white "snowy" pattern. it drove me crazy for months because it reminded me so much of sheetrock dust!

Sponsored
Custom Home Works
Average rating: 4.6 out of 5 stars10 Reviews
Franklin County's Award-Winning Design, Build and Remodeling Expert