Software
Houzz Logo Print
alice462

Preliminary appliance choices........feedback please!

18 years ago

After many hours of research and looking, we are in the preliminary stages of making appliance choices for our new kitchen and would appreciate any feedback/koodos/concerns that anyone is willing to share on the following:

Refrigerator/Freezer:

1st choice: Kenmore Pro all frig/all freezer

2nd choice: Kenmore Elite All frig/All freezer

Price is an issue and I really want the single units - Bosch and Thermador are out of reach. The Kenmore accepts a cabinet panel, which was a consideration.

36" Rangetop, fueled by LP:

1st choice: Dacor EG366SCH -burners w/ differnt ratings: 2 @18,000; 2@16,000; 2@8,500 simmer goes down to 1000BTU

2nd choice: Dacor ESG366 6 burners @ 15,000BTU, simmer goes down to 1,500BTU.

As we will be using propane I want a "factory ready" unit and not have to convert on site. Our regualr appliace repairman who services all of our various appliaces is a certified Dacor tech. so this helped tip the scales on this one. Also, called Dacor and confirmed that w/facory prep LP, BTU output remains the same for NG or LP.

Downdraft pop-up vent: Thermador is the only unit that I have found that goes to a height of 14", all others only went to 9 or 10. As this is an island, my very elementary physics tell me that if I get the vent up higher, the effectiveness may improve. Also, I feel like it would provide additional protection for anyone walking by.

30" Double Wall Ovens:

1st choice: Kenmore Elite 2247913

2nd choice: not really one here, but would probably consider the Jenn-Air

For our ovens, I do want 3rd element true convection, hidden bake element, but am mostly interested in a solidly performing unit that is reliable and easy to use. Don't need a lot of bells and whistles. For those with wall ovens with the "roller racks" -- how do you like them and can they go to different positions in the oven or are they fixed?

Warming Drawer (if we do one): 30" Kenmore Elite

Microwave: Kenmore 20-63263 - dont't need this to be fancy, will mostly be used for popcorn, defrost, quick re-heats, etc. But not as a true "cooking" vehicle. Needs to sit on a shelf above a counter so cannot be too deep.

Dishwasher:

1st choice: Bosch SHV68MO

2nd choice: KitchenAid KUDMU03FT or KUDT03STBL

Reason that we tipped toward Bosch is that while the KitchenAid will accept a panel, rep. indicated that it is very difficult to get those units "flush" w/cabinets w/out cutting out back of cabinet to "jam it in there". Also, Boshc allows for a top rack only wash and since we are not doing dishwasher drawers and w/3 boys we could use a DW that lets us run a load of cups/glasses only.

Cost was a consideration in all of our choices as we are really trying to find the "most bang for our buck" -- pricing all of these except the Thermador downdraft, the appliance rep that I worked with this morning can bring us in for around $9950. That is before any rebates that could save as much as an additional 30%.

I researched a great deal on this and other web sites to narrow to these choices, and would certainly appreciate hearing from those with experience with any of the above. Let me know if you think we are headed in the right direction! Thanks so much - this forum has been invaluable to us!

Comments (14)

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    In researching appliances, my appliance dealer says not to let the top rack only wash be a determination as he showed me the Bosch dishwasher only uses $48 of energy per year (per the tag in the dishwaher). I have a Bosch, am fairly well satisfied, enough to get a new one for the remodel. It is super quiet which is a plus.

    I don't know a lot about your other appliances but check out the Gaggenau 36 inch drop in cooktop - also goes to 18,000 BTUs and a much lower simmer - plus the GE Monogram 36 inch drop in cooktop - goes to 18,000 BTUs with a very low simmer.

    JanetZ

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Janet - thank you, will look at both of those. A

    Am starting to second guess the wall oven choice...seems like lots of folks like the Monogram?

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Do you know who makes the Kenmore oven? The Monogram (ZET2 models only) were one of my top choices. Well worth looking at if you haven't seen one in person. The shelves do adjust.

    We have the Electrolux all-fridge and all-freezer units, who make the Kenmore ones (the layout or features may be a little different). We are happy with them.

    We are also happy with our Bosch dishwashers, and had one at our last house that was good, too.

    You seem to have very well-thought reasoning for deciding on the Dacor rangetop. BlueStar, Wolf, Capital, and Monogram also factory-configure for LP, if you want to consider any others.

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    rhome410 -- thank you for your response, it is very helfpul! I do not know who makes the Kenmore oven. I think I may have overlooked the Monogram and am going back to consider it.

    Glad to hear that you like your Electrolux frig/freezer. I did consider the other rangetops you mentioned - while the Wolf was our top pick, Dacor seems solid and was a bit less $$, which has become a huge concern as this project moves forward!

    We thought we had a reasonable budget in mind but it just keeps growing. I have told my DH that anywhere we have control over cost, i.e. choosing fixtures, etc - we just have to make sure that we are spending the $$$ as wisely as we can and getting what will do the job, what we need - may not always be the "top of the line" but want everything to perform as it should.

    We have not even broken ground and the "unexpected" costs took a huge jump when we looked at the 3 bathrooms that will also be overhauled and found that we will need to do additional work on them! Just add it to the list!

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I would not get anything that has Sears name on it. Their service is awful.

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    If I were trying to get more out of my budget, I'd forego the appliance panels. They are pricey, and really, what's so bad about appliances in the kitchen looking like, well, appliances in the kitchen? The costs involved in the panels are (1) the panels themselves, (2) the labor to install the panels, and (3) the upcharges the manufacturers charge for their "panel-ready" appliances over their standard-door appliances. Please sit down and do the math on the panels given those 3 components. You could take that money--and it will be substantial--and get better appliances for that money.

    You've noted quite a few times in your OP that cost is an issue. Also, you seem already aware that sometimes installing the panels can be tricky. They need to fit "just so". Given what you've said in your OP, I would skip the panels.

    On another subject - downdrafts aren't that great, and should be avoided if at all possible. I understand that it may be the only option for you if the configuration of your kitchen won't allow an overhead hood. But if there is any way you can get an overhead hood, you should try.

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Am I reading you correctly? - that you are still in the construction phase, yet are CHOOSING downdraft??? Usually people opt for downdrafts when they are completely constrained by existing construction and have no other choice. If you have the luxury to be in the construction phase you should run away from a downdraft! They are a poor exhaust - it's just physics; smoke and grease waft up. A downdraft is going against physics, and will also pull on your burner flames.

    I hope you did not choose a downdraft cause an architect or developer said you should - we've seen that situation before on this forum. Poor advice. Meanwhile, an island hood will not only be many times more effective than a downdraft, but the look of an island hood can really add "wow factor" to your kitchen.

    My only other comments would be that I prefer the Kitchenaid dishwasher. The only panelled appliance I have is a dishwasher, and for me, in hindsight, the panel was a waste of money. It was expensive, and my installer had to tinker with it quite a lot to get it to fit without interfering with how the DW door opened. I could have used that money elsewhere. Also, re the rangetop, I myself like all the burners to be the same btu's, but that's just the way I cook. I don't want to be worrying about having to shift pots around according to how the burners are laid out.

    HTH.

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    My appliances are old - 21 years to be exact - but I agree, the downdraft is a loser and in my remodel I am doing an overhead and making it work. The downdraf never really worked well as an exhaust plus it pulled the flame from the burners so I had to be cognizant of what pan was where and how high he burner was. I also am not doing paneling on any of my appliances. I did it on my initial dishwasher and it wasn't a problem it just never "integrated" fit-wise so I replaced it with a Bosch and have been happy with the look.

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Thanks again for all the feedback - the panels are a definite "option" not a must have. We have a very "historic" home and the idea of lots of stainless in my kitchen was a look I am trying to avoid. That being said, I am very conscious of the additional cost and our first choice now seems to be the Kenmore Pro, which I learned yesterday does not accept panels -- so may save the $$ anyway.

    Regarding a downdraft, while not a construction issue, it is a DH issue -- he is tall and hates the idea of a hood hanging down in the middle of the room over the cooking area. We have an old Jenn-Air solid burner stove currently with a downdraft and honestly, it works pretty well. We are looking at the Thermador downdraft b/c it rises to 14", not as close to the flame and higher than any pot I would be using. Will continue to discuss this one!

    Thanks again for all the feedback!

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Funny. We are short and hate hoods because they get in the way visually. We have the Dacor downdraft paired with a Dacor cooktop. Got both as display models for cheap. The downdraft works fine at clearing smoke and grease and does not pull the flames. The physics of smoke going up are correct, but the idea of the downdraft is to pull the smoke before it has a chance to go up. We had a JA downdraft for 14 years, then moved to this house where there was a hood. We used to grill indoors on the JA and never had smoke or grease issues in the kitchen. Here we had the smoke alarm going off constantly until the kitchen redo. Now the smoke is captured before it has a chance to get into the air.

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I agree on the topic of avoiding downdraft. May I suggest an island hood for you I think is nice and attractive?

    Here is a link that might be useful: Kobe IS-124

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    We have the Thermador downdraft that you are contemplating on purchasing. When we remodeled our existing kitchen, we didn't have much of an option. Our cooktop is also on an island. Although a hood would be better, the Thermador works better than our previous Dacor downdraft. We do have a remote blower which helps maximize the venting. Good luck with your decisions.

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    thank you again - mominttennies, it is good to know that the feedback on the Thermador vs. Dacor is very helpful re: downdraft.

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I too am considering the Kenmore Pro all refrigerator and would love to talk to someone who had it. I can't even find one in a store to look at.