Software
Houzz Logo Print
mimi72_gw

Can someone help me evaluate architects' proposals??

18 years ago

I have interviewed 4 architects and received proposals from 2 of them so far. One I'm still waiting on and the other I didn't care for the designs of too much.

If there's anyone who has gone through this process and would have some sage advice, I'd love it. The 2 proposals I have differ by $8k. I'd love to email someone the details to get your input. I know the scope of services makes all the difference. My budget is "only" 400k for the entire project (incl arch fees and swimming pool but excluding land) -- one of the guys said "no problem" while the other looked a little skeptical and his proposal at up the entire $400k without including the pool or driveway and also excluded any/all engineering fees. That was the guy who's arch fees are $8k more. But maybe he's being more realistic than the other one. Anyway, if anyone can help email me at mmueth@siumed.edu and I could send you the proposals.

Comments (4)

  • 18 years ago

    My experience with architects has led me to the conclusion that they are great at coming up with interesting and innovative design ideas, but really bad at staying within budget. If hitting you budget is important I recommend carefully checking references to evaluate your candidateÂs past performance in this area.

    I have not found the value added by having an architect supervise the job to be worth the expense. However, I am a civil engineer and spend a lot of time on site and working with my GC and his crew.

  • 18 years ago

    I would never use an architect that was has not had "draw and build" experience. Most architects can draw a "pretty picture", but do not have a clue as to how much the structure will cost in the end. Chose your architect very wisely or he could end up costing you lots more $$$ over your budget~~~

  • 18 years ago

    Has anyone had a GOOD relationship/outcome when working with an architect? If so, how did you orchestrate it? Interestingly, one of the architecture firms I referenced above (the lower priced one actually) has included the services of a cost estimator to ensure the budget is met. Any experience with that kind of service?

  • 18 years ago

    Architects provide considerably more valuable services than drawing "pretty pictures". In fact, some of the best architects I have known couldn't draw well at all. What they do is interpret a family's needs and translate them into a building that works far better than what a typical builder or homeowner could. The essential skill is imaginative problem solving and empathy with the people who will live in the house. Of course, homeowners have differing needs, standards, and tastes so not all of them will want what an architect offers. Some builders offer similar services but so far I have not found one who was willing to put the homeowner's interests ahead of his own.

    If your budget is tight you should ask the architect for cost estimation services at the end of the preliminary design and design development phases. Cost estimation is not normally considered a basic architectural service. It should be added to the contract as an additional service just like models, 3D CAD, attendance at hearings, etc.

    Alternatively, you can hire an architect and interview builders, select one, and then pay him to provide cost estimations and give advice, then negotiate a Cost of the Work contract with a GMP and shared savings. This approach can also get you into the ground more quickly which could save money in the current rising material cost environment.