There have been some really long threads here on the "two sinks versus one sink" issue. Some people absolutely must have two (I'm in this group) and some people absolutely think one is all they need. So, you need to think about how you feel about two sinks versus one sink.

If you do need/want two sinks, then doing a nicer shower in your bath and then an upgraded tub in the other bath might be a good way to go, especially since you don't take baths every day. Lot's of people do just have a shower in the master bath, and as long as it's decent size and nice it doesn't hurt resale, in you're concerned with that.

Part of whether that's a good idea or not is whether other people (kids?) use the other bath. If you're not going to be able to have that other bath look nice and/or be able to relax in it, because of it being used by a bunch of kids, then maybe having the tub in the master bath is a better idea.

Let us know what you end up deciding!

It seems like the tradeoff is not one vs. two sinks but a second sink versus a tub.

If you really like baths, I would think having the tub in your master is more important than being able to brush teeth simultaneously with hubby. (BTW, it seems to me the issue is more counter space rather than having two sinks, but that's probably just me).

Thank You for the input.

No, there would not be children using the tub in the guest bath. Only occasionally guests. It is just my hubby and I at home.

And yes I believe you are absolutely correct that if I went with the tub and shower in the Master, counter space would be a major issue.

What I really really want is both the tub and the shower in the master but I am afraid of hurting the resale value with only one sink and I am afraid of not having enough counter space. I was thinking of putting a vanity table in the bedroom where it would get some nice natural light.

Totally confused in California

When are you planning to sell? I would not worry about resale value on this one, because one buyer might value two sinks and another a bathtub. There's just no way to know. And having recently sold a house with totally renovated baths, I can tell you that the price of the house is going to be determined by many things other than the fact that you have one sink (or no tub).

Without seeing a floorplan I'm not sure if its even possible. If it is, it will take some creative solutions to get there.

For instance, have you considered a single long sink with two faucets? I've seen some pics of this arrangement, and it can look fantastic. Saves considerable space while still letting each party take care of business.

Maybe that could be paired with a tall, deep soaking tub. These can actually be more comfortable than the 'lay down' tubs, especially if you like to read in the bath. The japanese style soakers have a low seat in them, take up very little room.

So alot will depend on how big a shower you need, where the door and plumbing are located, etc. But I *think* it can be done...

Thank You everyone for your input. I believe based on what I have read here and in other threads, that I will go with what I really want vs what I think the market might want.

I am the only one that uses the master bathroom and it has a nice size walk-in closet attached. The extra sink that is currently in the bathroom just sits there unused. A waste of space. So I think I will go down to one sink and have both a tub and a shower. It will still require creative used of space, as noted, but I think it can be done. That upright soaking tub is an interesting idea.

OK, so one decision down and a million to go. Where do I start? There are so many beautiful materials and fixtures.