Software
Houzz Logo Print
ras9999

Drywall time: 1/2' or 5/8 '

16 years ago

Contract for our new home states 1/2" or 5/8" drywall.

He prefers 1/2" as the jambs (door, window) per his recommendation would look nicer. But 5/8 is thicker and maybe prevents some sound and better solid wall ?

Any thoughts Pro or Con for going with either?

Please help

Home has rounded corners as well.

Comments (11)

  • 16 years ago

    The choice is not a matter of one being better than the other.

    Where a wall contains a door, the difference in GWB thickness will have no effect on actual sound transmission and the thicker GWB would probably require a custom door jamb size or a trim shim (if the buck is not split/adjustable).

    Where there is no door, and acoustic separation is important, it is better to use one layer of 1/2" GWB on one side and two layers of 1/2" GWB on the other (imbalanced wall) which also avoids having two kinds of GWB on the job.

    The next step in acoustic separation is double layers of GWB each side and then adding acoustic dampening systems like resilient channels, Isomax channel clips, acoustic drywall (dampening layer), or green glue (assuming there is not enough room for a double studded wall).

    How a wall is sealed at the floor and ceiling and how many penetrations occur (especially back to back - insulation is effective here) is often more important in the real world than the wall design. Sounds will easily find and travel through cracks; make it work harder.

    So, 1/2" GWB is fine if you use it wisely. Mark up the plans in red with a symbol for "double layer" (eg, D.L., heavy line, etc.) on the appropriate side of an acoustically improved wall so the drywall contractor will know what you want. Try to trade the additional GWB for the thicker board.

    Regarding fire protection, non-fire-resistance-rated GWB disintegrates to quickly (as it gives up its water in a fire) for the thickness to be important. For better fire protection you must use fire-resistance-rated GWB and in that case 1/2" Type C is as effective as 5/8" Type X especially on the most important surface, the ceiling. The next step in residential fire protection would be to use solid core doors and then add a closer (or just forbid smoking in the house).

  • 16 years ago

    Thanks for such details.
    Should I just go with the 1/2" ? My contract has the 5/8" as a free option and other builders wanted 3K addition for that option. I just want to get my money's :) worth but obviously I have no idea what I am doing.

    Does the 5/8 really give me anything?

    Is the door jambs really a issue that they might charge me for or maybe its already assumed since the drywall option is there?

    Will it make the walls more sturdy?

    By change do you know much about A/C and Furnances?
    I need to decide those this week. My house is 2 story and I have the Trane XR95 (95%) furance and the XB13 A/C. Should I upgrade? I saw that they make the 2 stage models but not sure if I need it. House is 3900 in the bay area but I have 2 furance and 2 a/c's to be installed (1 for each floor).

    thanks again for all the help

  • 16 years ago

    Any framing members that are called out for 24" centers, it's a good idea to go with 5/8", ceilings, walls, under floor,etc. Also if you have tall rake walls that are 2x4 constructed, you would also want to consider 5/8" there.

    The door jambs depend on if you are having standard pre-hungs, or standard jambs for that matter installed. A standard jamb for a 2x4 wall is 4-9/16". This is typically geared for a 2x4 with 1/2" rock either side. A 2x6 wall would be 6-9/16". If you have 5/8" on one side or both sides of a 2x4 or 2x6 wall and are using standard jambs, it's not that big a deal to fur out the jamb with an extension, but is more costly to produce. No big deal for an experienced trim carpenter as they deal with it now and then.

  • 16 years ago

    5/8 will not make a noticeable difference for acoustics or strength for 16" o.c. framing. It would be better to trade the 5/8 for double layers of 1/2 where it would make a difference as I explained in detail earlier.

    The alternative is to pay more for additional double layers of 5/8 at acoustic walls.

    Looking for simple "one size fits all" answers in building design is usually a mistake.

  • 16 years ago

    I think you covered the acoustic part of the op's ordeal right fine like M.A., I was only commenting on structural values of using 5/8" where the members are 24" o.c. Those values are that 1/2" has a tendency to be a little more wavy between the cavaties when the members are 24" o.c.

  • 16 years ago

    I agree and it is even more important on a ceiling in a humid environment.

  • 16 years ago

    There's a downside to applying 5/8 to ceilings framed on 16" or 12" centers. Any particularly "low" joist/member can cause the 5/8 to crack along it, because 5/8 will just not bend for anything at all. 1/2 flexes very easily, and will conform (for better or worse) to wonky framing. The remedy is to carefully plane any low members, or use shimmed furring on the entire.
    I really like 5/8 on ceilings, it has a harder acoustic (more live) than 1/2, closer to veneer plaster systems sound-wise. 1/2" drywall rooms are very dead spaces acoustically, compared to 5/8 or veneer plaster.
    In commercial partitioning, on steel studs, the 5/8 is the only thing giving the wall any substance.
    Casey

  • 16 years ago

    Ceilings should always be strapped. Whenever I have forgotten to specify strapping the contractor applied it anyway. In fact, in 40 years I have never seen drywall applied directly to framing.

  • 16 years ago

    "In fact, in 40 years I have never seen drywall applied directly to framing."

    Strapping joists for drywall is not a common thing in the places I work (Virginia mostly now).

  • 16 years ago

    The only area of the country I've seen strapping is in the northeast/new england. I ilke the idea of it for many reasons.