Software
Houzz Logo Print
castironcook2_gw

The Great Kitchen Hood Caper

17 years ago

The kitchen hood: No single appliance causes more angst in its selection. All we knew at the beginning was that lack of adequate ventilation is the single biggest kitchen boo-boo. And we were stuck with a "recirculating" (read, useless for our kind of cooking) 36" OTR over a 36" glass cooktopdefinitely not the optimum equipment for HubbestÂs searing and stockmaking.

WeÂd already settled on a 4-burner BlueStar 30" slide-in rangetop as suiting ourÂwell, hisÂflamboyant cooking style. Larger would have been nicer, but absent a complete kitchen realignment, existing cabinetry constrained our size choice.

So if youÂve got a lovely 30" BlueStar, youÂre going to require a 36" hood with adequate depth and some decent CFMs, right? That much we figured out right away. What was tricky was deciding what to do about the decorative over-the-cabinets soffit that transits the length of our kitchen. (This house has many stunning architectural details, but sometimes it reminds me of a kidÂs electronic gimmick where the toy gets to do all the playing.) We had a maximum of only 14" below the soffit, considering that 30" above the cooktop is generally the recommended placement for the bottom of the hood. Furthermore, that soffit absolutely dictated a hood that vents out the backÂin our case, straight out through the wall.

Now, Modernaire had a product that cosmetically would have been perfect; besides that, their ability to do custom sizing meant we could have gotten a nontraditional hood height of 14", provided with back venting. But negotiations broke down when we were referred to a distributor who took so long to return our initial call (and never did respond to e-mail inquiries) that we knew this: If theyÂre not there when youÂre handing out the money, what assurance do you have that theyÂll be there if anything goes wrong later on?

"Bless those who disappoint you, for they are leading you toward a better path." I live by that creed. And my better path led first to Eurostoves, because of their knowledge, responsiveness, and reputation for excellent customer service. Trevor recommended Prestige, by BlueStar, but it was pricier than Hubbest wanted to go, given that the Modernaire negotiations for my dream hood had fallen through.

Then we flashed on EurostoveÂs special on the Cavaliere hoods, whose finish Trevor found quite lovely, and the height was acceptable, so I said, "Send it." THEN I looked at the specs and realized it only vented out the top, a real deal-breaker for our circumstances (because of the infamous soffit, remember?). A quick call to cancel the order, which, fortunately, had not yet shipped, and it was back to the drawing board.

Are we having fun yet? You who have agonized over hood selection know the feeling.

For some time, BroanÂs Elite had been on our radar screen, but I was concerned about the loudness (they rate their 600 CFMs at 13.5 sones) and the seams. Still, itÂs a stainless baffle, pro-style hood with adequate capture area. And Trevor felt it could be a decent answer, given our parameters. So although itÂs 18" tall, we ordered it.

Then began the real headache: what to do about the soffit? One contractor suggested cutting into it. A second said heÂd truncate it. A third envisioned rerouting it (up and over the top of the hood), to the tune of $2,700. I just closed my eyes, crossed my fingers, and prayed.

Meanwhile, our BlueStar arrived at the local dealerÂs warehouse. "Send it out," said Hubbest with excitement. And for three days we admired it, parked ingloriously on our dining room table, awaiting the installer and the arrival of our Broan Elite hood. Hubbest petted it daily. Then, anticipating its installation, he removed our dainty little glasstop Creda.

Finally, here came the installer and his helper. One look, an "I donÂt do tile," and there went the erstwhile installing team, leaving our gaping hole unfilled.

What now?

Remember that old camp skit where the villain is threatening the sweet young thing with eviction and the hero comes charging in, eyes flashing, and declares, "IÂLL pay the rent"? ThatÂs my man. (Fortunately, heÂs very handy, having been a sailor and a mountain man, and the BlueStar is a simple machineÂespecially in its rangetop iteration.)

But now what do you do when youÂve got two 22k burners right up front and rarin to go, and no hood to vent their fury? You pace the floor. You check your tracking information. You measure and remeasure and fuss and fume and sweat a lot.

And then the hood arrives and you say "Yay! Hooray! (But what about the soffit?)" And THEN you get out the tape measure to check the dimensions of the hood, which isÂ30" wide? Blink. Gape. Gulp.

EverybodyÂs paperwork said 36". Mine, Eurostoves, everybodyÂs. Yet the hood was indisputably, undeniably, unremittingly 30" wide, no more.

But thatÂs why you go with a company known for their exemplary customer service. Despite all the ordering information to the contrary, the hood had arrived in the wrong width, and Eurostoves made good on it, immediately and forthwith.

Did I mention that Hubbest is also a Harley rider? Do you think, champing at the bit, that heÂd wait for a 36" Broan to be shipped from the East Coast? Right you are.

So we called for the 10" tall, 36" wide, back-venting, seamless Kobe within our grasp. The soffit would be inviolate. We could cook again. And we would have ventilation. 800 CFMs on high, with only 4.5 sones. In Quiet mode, at only 1.5 sones, we let her run all the way through dinner, vacuuming the last cooking smells from the air.

Somebody on GW found the KobeÂs halogen lights to be too dim. ThatÂs not our appraisal. And we improved the capture area of our KobeÂs 22" depth by building it 2" out from the wall, thereby achieving the effect of a 24-incher.

I like its sleek, seamless lines, and though I still look wistfully at the photo of that Modernaire hood that grabbed me, I think our Kobe looks just fine. And at less than half the price.

Finally weÂre the ones doing the playing.

Comments (12)

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Wow, what an unbelievable saga. Congrats on fighting through to a successful outcome.

    BTW: would you mind listing the Modern Aire distributor who was so incompetent? It might help future hood shoppers to know which one to avoid. Or at least the region of the country you ordered from?

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    sfjeff and I spoke on this board of our dissatisfaction with Luxury Products, out of Santa Rosa. He and I both would have loved to be able to work direct with Modernaire, but here in Northern California we were each referred to LP as MA's distributor for the area. All my dealings with MA themselves were encouraging; things stalled when it came to the "Who is your dealer?" stage. Such a pity.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I loved reading your post -- a beautifully told tale with a happy ending and some good tips along the way. Gives us all hope that we too may be able to find that perfect vent hood for our pro ranges. Thanks for sharing your story with us.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Big happy grin. Deep bow.
    I posted a pic. No clue how to get it inline, but there's a link @ Kobe Loves BlueStar.

    The decor between rangetop and hood derives from our identity as cast iron cooks. ;-)

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    castironcooks2,

    Sorry that you had to go through this caper but it did make for an entertaining story. And all's well that ends well. I've been looking at Kobe Hoods and was wondering how they would work for the Blue Star so I'm glad that you're happy with your choice. And thanks for the heads up about Luxury Products. I had looked up Modernaire and then looked for their closest distributer to me which was LP in Santa Rosa, only about 20 minutes away. I won't be checking them out now.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    carecooks, it may be that LP, having by our anecdotes been properly chastized, has seen where their customer service needs to be improved. Being a firm believer in the power of redemption, I'd suggest that as a trial run, you might try contacting them and seeing if they respond with any reasonable alacrity. Perhaps there IS a new and improved Luxury Products. One can only hope.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    You're probably right although I'm more likely going to go with Kobe than with Modernaire anyway. I'd love to get the best possible system for the least possible bucks. At this point, I don't know the cost of putting the hood ventilation system in and I find that more scary than other costs. By the way, do you live near Santa Rosa? If you so have you used any local vendors that you liked?

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    You can see the both the Kobe and the Modern-Aire hoods in Concord at Friedman's Appliance. The also carry Broan, Best by Broan, Elica, and Zephyr, as I recall. I can't comment on the business practices or quality of advice there. One salesman I had was pretty close to clueless; the one that they replaced him with (at my request) seemed reasonable.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I'm glad sfjeff chimed in about local vendors, 'cause I haven't a clue, being way up here in the Eureka boonies, myself. (Ah, but it's a beautiful place to live, even though moderately emporium-deprived.)

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Thanks SJeff for the advice about Friedman's. I'll keep that on my vendor list. Castironcook2, you are way north of me. I'm in Healdsburg.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    carecooks, Healdsburg is a most engaging town. There's actually a "there" there. Hope there are a few good vendors, too, and I wish you all the best on your hood quest. Keep us posted on your waypoints and your outcomes, OK?

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    we are looking at the same hood for our Capital Rangetop - do you have any pictures of your hood and specifically how you built it out to cover the front? I think that idea would work for us. Thanks.