Software
Houzz Logo Print
katrinavhh

Would you buy open box induction?

17 years ago

Would you buy an induction cooktop - open box - at a scratch & dent?

My husband and I are building a new house, on a tight budget, and we are nearing the last 8 weeks of the process. I have been an avid reader of this site as I started making my selections (especially for appliances). After recognizing that there were no "perfect" choices, I made several appliance purchases at a local scratch & dent (AppliancesMart in Atlanta GA) with great savings. (The house is not yet complete, though, so I can't comment on functionality yet!)

I have been planning to purchase the induction cooktop and the double wall ovens new from a reputable dealer, but now I am tempted by a cooktop I saw at the scratch & dent today. I planned to buy the Viking 36" for a few reasons, mainly the fact that the hobs do not share power and the classic knob controls. A friend who works for Hadco can buy it for us at 15% savings, making the total $3650 plus tax.

Today, however, I came across three Siemens 36" induction units on sale for $1379 plus tax. The difference is enough to make me stop and consider buying it scratch & dent, BUT then I wonder if this is a piece of electronics too sensitive to purchase out of the box. The units look fine, but they are completely out of the package and sitting on a table. Is that OK?

Other than being out of the box, there are some other differences between the units:

1. The Siemens has 5 burners; Viking has 6

2. Siemens shares power between burners (I think), Viking does not (I know)

3. Siemens requires only 40 amps; Viking requires 50 (and we put that in the electrical already, anticipating the need

4. Siemens uses the "touchpad" controls; Viking has the knobs. I prefer the knobs because they seem so fool-proof, and I am a little intimidated by the touch screen.

5. Siemens has a much larger "largest" hob - 11" - while the Viking's largest is 8"

I am in desperate need of opinions here! Here are my specific questions for you:

1. Is an induction cooktop an OK item to buy out of the box at a scratch & dent store? (The warranty is the manufacturer warranty, you can buy an extended one, too.)

2. What is the reputation of Siemens' induction units? (I already know Viking's is not good, and have made peace with that.)

3. Would you sacrifice the few other differences between features (intimidating controls, one fewer burner, less overall power capability) for the savings of $2200? (We are young and the house is a stretch, so I'd love to save when I can, but I don't want to regret a major choice...$1400 is still not pocket change to me.)

A few details if they help:

- I'm already totally sold on induction for many reasons, there's very little chance I'd choose gas or electric at this point

- I have shopped hard for most of the house parts (lighting, other appliances, hardware, cabinetry), so I like saving when I can, but only when I can get a comparable product for less (saving a few dollars now to upgrade in a few years is not really saving to me)

- I have no experience with either Viking or Siemens anything - this is our first real house, and we've been using GE Profile in our townhouse for the past few years with fine results, no complaints

- The model numbers are:

Siemens 36" induction cooktop: EH9772UC

Viking 36" induction cooktop VKVEDO130SS

Any help you could provide would be SO appreciated!

Comments (11)

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I am pretty sure siemens is the same as thermador and gaggenau. If it comes with the standard warranty, I would go for the siemens. The central hob on the thermador does not share power and the boost goes pretty high. The only thing that you did not mention is whether or not either of them have timed cooking (not just a timer).

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Sure, I'd buy it. But is it being sold 'as-is'? Or do you have a chance to plug it in and try it to make sure it works?

    The way I feel about electronic controls is: if you have the skills necessary to post a message here, you have the skills required to use electronic cooking controls.

    An 11" hob is bigger than any pan that I own. The bottoms of all my large pans (12") are 9" or less and will fit comfortably on an 8" hob. Hence that large hob becomes less useful. But I don't think I would want to spend another $2200 for one more hob. If I were going to do that, I would go look for a single or dual hob and save a grand.

    I'm cheap enough to think that I would like to put that extra money into other things, like a good hood or extra fridge or 2nd dishwasher. With a new house you can certianly find other things to spend $2200.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Thanks for your thoughts here, this helps. I would love to save the $$$, and $2200 could go far with lots of extras around the house.

    Anyone out there think it would be foolish to buy an open-box appliance like this?

    Scrappy, the Viking definitely does not have timed cooking, but I think the Siemens does. I'm not 100% sure yet, though, because I can't find a manual for this model (it has already been discontinued and the material online so far is not very thorough.)

    Weedmeister, yes, it is "as is" and they say that if you have problems, you will go through the manufacturer warranty channels. I'd love to plug it in before I bought it, but I don't know how to do that with the 40 amp cords hanging off the back. (Remember that I am the girl intimidated by the touchpad!)

    I like the idea of the 11" hob for use with a large flat griddle. I have a toddler who eats pancakes and grilled cheese 100 times a week.

    Thanks again for your thoughts!

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    First thing I would do, is make sure there is sevice for the Siemens in your area, a warranty is useless as you may have seen from other posts here, if you can't get somebody out to your house to fix it.
    Except for a post or 2 about a cracked glass top, there are few post about failures of any induction unit.
    Be sure to go over the top with a fine tooth comb looking for cracks(assuming it is a glass top) I would also ask why is it "Open Container" was it a demo model or one returned from a customer.
    Good Luck, You will Love the induction, regardless of which way you go.
    Gary

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Gary, thanks very much for your advice. I did not look as closely as I should have for any cracks in the glass. The store has three of these units, so perhaps at least one is in good shape.

    Your first suggestion to see whether there is Siemens service in my area (Atlanta GA) has me stumped, because I don;t know where to look. I have been trying to find a Siemens website with no luck. I get the international directory, but the US page is apparently down. (It takes you to a weird site, not Siemens-sponsored.)

    What would you suggest? How would I find out whether they are serviced in Atlanta GA?

    I am also trying to find a product manual for the cooktop, with no luck. I can't imagine buying this without a manual, but the scratch & dent does not have one with the unit. Anyone have advice on this?

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    My advice is to make sure it works. I recently got a Kenmore induction cooktop and the first one installed did not work. The main electronic board was fried and that was on a brand new unit. The repair guy said they tended to be fragile and may have been damaged in shipping. The second unit was fine and we love it.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Seems they are discontinued model items being sold at half off regular price. Maybe used only as display units or refurbished with factory warranty would be ok?

    Here is a link that might be useful: Siemens USA web page

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    danny has the right advice. Note the "repair guy said", unfortunately if He does not exist for your Siemens-well You Know?
    Maybe some of the folks here recall another Atlanta poster that could not find service for an even more common brand name as I recall. It was only because Home Depot came to her rescue that She was finally able to get her appliance operational---and unfortunately Your dealer is telling you, "You are on your own (with the manufacturer)"
    Since you are willing to take a chance with the touch controls on the used Siemens, maybe you can find something "half way" or so that could fit your needs between the Open box Siemens and your first choice?
    Hopefully the link that laa2 will be useful.

    Gary

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Siemens is made by Bosch (as well as Thermador and Gaggenau as pointed out above). I would think there would be no problem finding Bosch/Siemens repair in Atlanta. A third option may be to go to another store - even Lowe's - tell them you're considering the open box Siemens for $1379 and see if they can do anything on price on a new unit for you even if it is a different manufacturer.

    My answer to the question you asked though - yes. For that amount of money I would try the Siemens. I have the impression that induction technology is not really all that complicated. Doesn't seem as though many folks talk about much breaking in their induction units. Try the Siemens. If its bad, with the warranty they may end up having to replace it with a new unit. Then you'd really be the fiscal hero!

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Many thanks to everyone for your comments and advice. I hope in 8-10 weeks I will have a kitchen to post! Until then, I am going to 1. find a Siemens repair in town (just to be sure one exists), 2. check out similar deals around town, and 3. go back to inspect the units with a fine-toothed comb and ask about plugging it in. Thanks again!