Software
Houzz Logo Print
moku_gw

Did Bluestar's V1 solve all the problems?

16 years ago

Having read through many discussion threads about Bluestar and Capital Culinarian, I gather that at least the earlier version of Bluestar ranges had some recurring problems, including the following:

(1) sticky or frozen oven door

(2) "explosion" when starting the broiler

(3) excessively hot oven door and kick plate

(4) general fit and finish issues (gaps under burners, poor fit of oven door allowing heat to escape)

(5) imperfect color finish

(6) failed ignition

I've also seen reference repeatedly to Bluestar's V1, which I understand was a revision to the line intended to address at least some of the concerns that customers had expressed.

These are my questions:

First, what precise changes were made in the V1 revision?

Second, did those changes adequately solve the problems that had been identified in the earlier version? I would be especially grateful for comments by anyone who has a V1 range and has had real-world experience with it.

Third, though Trevor's website does a terrific job of comparison testing BS and CC, is CC likely to be a sufficient upgrade over BS V1 to justify the risk of early adoption? My impression is that BS is already an outstanding product with a well-established service and support infrastructure. I would be nervous about buying the first round of a new line of ranges from a company without a local presence and without a track record of success. I'd appreciate any thoughts on this issue too.

Comments (26)

  • 16 years ago

    Have been using my Bluestar 6 burner V1 range for about 5 weeks. So far, no issues. The burners light readily. The oven door hinges seem to be fine. There is no broiler explosion or oven bang when heating up and I've had it up to 500 degrees on several occasions. The oven door remains as cool as my former "Harvest Gold" Hotpoint and the fit & finish is good.

    I'm extremely happy with this range.

  • 16 years ago

    have been using my bluestar v1 30" rnb for about 6 weeks now. no issues. burners light just fine. no broiler explosion nor oven bang with heating up (there is a woosh when it lights) and i've had it up to 500 degrees on MANY occaisions. oven door is warm not over hot but the knobs can get hot enough to need to be careful and it retains heat like no one's business.

  • 16 years ago

    ebean - I am so glad you are happy with your Bluestar.

    About the knobs... Are you saying they get too hot to handle?

  • 15 years ago

    I am NOT happy with mine nor the service from bs. period...

  • 15 years ago

    Lamermaid, can you tell us what problems you are having. We have ordered the v1 36 and hope to have installation during January. I was hoping all the earlier complaints had been addressed.

  • 15 years ago

    Ordered a 30RNB -- expect it in January. Like you, I agonized over this for a long time. After doing the reading and corresponding with several owners have concluded the machine problems are largely fixed. Many of the headaches were caused by customer service shortfalls and from what I can see, Blue Star recognizes this and the situation has gotten better. One of the remaining Achille's heels is the ignitors which are vulnerable if you accidentally bang it or get it too wet (boil over). So you have to be careful and/or be prepared to replace some along the way. The oven problems seem to have been addressed in V-1 along with several cosmetic issues. There are still some people who concerned about how got the door gets but many others are saying it's tolerable.

    It's a great range-- not perfect. I think it is well worth it to cope with the "problems" to get those burners.

  • 15 years ago

    No one will be able to give a good answer to the OP's question until at least two years from now.

    We just don't know.

    Third, though Trevor's website does a terrific job of comparison testing BS and CC, is CC likely to be a sufficient upgrade over BS V1 to justify the risk of early adoption? My impression is that BS is already an outstanding product with a well-established service and support infrastructure. I would be nervous about buying the first round of a new line of ranges from a company without a local presence and without a track record of success. I'd appreciate any thoughts on this issue too.

    My impression is the BS is already an outstanding performance range with low quality in it's price range.

    The CC is a Capital Precision with lower btu Therma-Tek burners from their commericial line. If you compare the Bluestar "V" vs Capital Precision in terms of quality and non-Trevor/Eurostoves customer service I think it is a no brainer. The Capital wins hands down.

    I am in no hurry and waiting for in home reviews to confirm what Trevors test state. Then buy sometime next spring.

  • 15 years ago

    Brand new 30" V1 model. No issues with any of those things. We found a small hairline crack in one of the top bowl grates the day the stove arrived, a blemish in the stainless steel on the 8" backplate we ordered separately (range came with shorter Island Trim) and an issue with the silkscreening of two of the five control knobs.

    Called BlueStar, reported these issues and they did the following:

    Sent FOUR new bowl grates
    Sent new 8" backplate
    Sent complete set of replacement knobs

    I would call that above and beyond the call for any manufacturer, considering that those grates weigh a good 20 lbs a piece, so shipping could not have been cheap, nor were the parts themselves!

    The stove adjusted perfectly at our mountain location (3600 feet), and everything else works beautifully. I did have an issue with the oven thermostat being set too high which caused the oven to reach close to 425 when the dial was set to 325.

    I fixed this myself with a simple adjustment to the thermostat (remove oven control knob, dig out little silicon plug in shaft with mini flat blade screw driver, and then insert screw driver into shaft and turn the thermostat control screw clockwise to cause the oven to turn off sooner than it was before. I used a high quality digital probe to measure the heat inside the oven, and adjusted the thermostat accordingly.

    Now when the oven dial is set to 350, the oven settles in at exactly 350. The same holds true for 450 and 500. The thermostat adjustment, like all aspects of this product are ridiculously simple and easy to work on yourself. The need for a technician to perform these adjustment tweaks really isn't needed once the product is hooked to gas and adjusted by a certified tech on installation day.

    Could not be happier with our BlueStar. I personally do not care for the look of the Culinarian cooktop, and do far too much Wok cooking to ever consider doing without the BlueStar bowl grate design that I can just drop my Wok into without the need for any other ring or special appliance.

  • 15 years ago

    Oh.. and the claim that the BlueStar is high performance but LOW quality is a lot of Hogwash! You generally only hear that BS bandied about by people who don't actually own one, and just parrot misinformation they read on forums like this one.

    I find the quality to be equal with the performance, which is stellar.

  • 15 years ago

    goldengoose7 - Can I just verify, you say you turned the oven thermostat control screw CLOCKWISE to get the oven into adjustment when it was running too hot. I had to calibrate my oven too and that is the direction we also used. However, that is backwards to what the Bluestar instructions and service manual says so our original adjustment made the problem worse. Just want to check that was your experience too. Thanks!

  • 15 years ago

    Hi. :o)

    Yep!

    The printed instructions I saw posted here were backwards. The opposite was actually the case as you point out. That became obvious real fast while I was making the adjustments. With the oven preheated with a knob settings of say 350, when I turned my screw driver to the left about 1/4 of a turn (counterclockwise) the thermostat clicked and the blue light came on which would then ignite the oven burner. Turn the screw back to the right (clockwise) and the light went out and the oven would be turned off.

    Dialing in the perfect "settling" temperature was just a matter of finding the sweet spot that allowed the oven to shut down just before the heat rose to the set temperature, and getting an average that worked for all popular temps. Took me about an hour of playing around with the set screw to get mine perfect. Mechanical thermostats are kind of tricky like that. I would have preferred that BS used a digital thermostat, but they must have their reasons, since the oven does hold temp very nicely and at the temp on the knob, once adjusted.

    Only thing I can think of regarding the adjustment direction being backwards is that at some point between when that paper that was posted here was actually published by BS and now, they started using a different thermostat with an adjustment scheme opposite of the old model. The only other explanation is that someone made a mistake in typing up those instructions. ;o)

    Were you able to dial in your oven to be more in line with the knob setting? Don't know why BS covers that screw up with that blob of putty. The oven usually needs to be adjusted just as much as the top burners would.

    Everyone with a BS oven should check their temp settings for accuracy with a quality digital probe and adjust as needed themselves with a mini flat blade. It is really easy and kind of a fun little project. :o)

  • 15 years ago

    Hi - What make/model digital probe did you use to check the temp.? Just curious ... I have a CC waiting to be installed and I'll want to check the temp accuracy once it's in. Thanks!

  • 15 years ago

    My 30 RNB is installed but I am not using it yet as kitchen is still in progress. What I can say is this: rolling oven rack arrived broken. Received a new one within three days. Some people reported oven door does not open all the way. Mine opens all the way and the rack can go all the way out even on the bottom most level.

  • 15 years ago

    I own this Fluke infrared thermometer and used it along with an MIU analog oven thermometer inside the oven.

    Any reasonably accurate oven thermometer would work for calibration purposes, but I would recommend using more than one just to make sure you are getting close to the actual oven temp.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Fluke 561 IR

  • 15 years ago

    Kintrex recently came out with a digital probe that looks very good on paper and is a lot cheaper than the Fluke I have. Might be fine for this purpose.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Kintrex IR

  • 15 years ago

    Here we go again! :)

    To the OP, there's a couple of folks that will always post against the Bluestar and, surprise, they sell the competing product. No conflict of interest, or anything.

    I have had my Bluestar 48" RNB w/French cooktop for about 6 months now and to answer your questions:

    (1) sticky or frozen oven door

    Nope. Nice solid door with a strong spring.

    (2) "explosion" when starting the broiler

    Nope. Starts exactly how I would expect it to.

    (3) excessively hot oven door and kick plate

    Nope. If you are a pansy and you need ice cold doors, buy something else (forgive me!). The oven doors and kick plate heat up to about 130, maybe 140. My three small kids, dog, au pair and wife have so far managed not to light themselves on fire. You know what I tell them? It's a STOVE, it might be hot! Don't play on it.

    (4) general fit and finish issues (gaps under burners, poor fit of oven door allowing heat to escape)

    This is bullcrap. It's a beautifully crafted, hard working machine.

    (5) imperfect color finish

    Bullcrap.

    (6) failed ignition

    Not for me. Never once.

    I have attached a link to a longer review I did. Might be useful to you. Some pictures as well.

    Beware the armchair commandos and internet ninjas that have all the facts but don't even own the product.

    Feel free to ask more specific questions.

    -Stooxie

    Here is a link that might be useful: Bluestar RNB48 review

  • 15 years ago

    Thanks Goldengoose7 for the info on the probes. I might have to invest in a Kintrex. Sorry to go off topic.

  • 15 years ago

    I have now been using my 36" RNB for 3 months with almost zero problems. Stooxie is spot on - seems like a lot of the critics don't have a BlueStar in the first place!

    Oven is consistent, no broiler issues, no hinge issues (haven't even oiled it!...maybe i should :)), no ignitor issues. I love it.

  • 15 years ago

    No problem Steve! I actually ordered a Kintrex after I posted the link! I have been looking for another IR digital probe and the specs on that thing looked damned good, and you rarely see so many 5 star owner reviews for a product on Amazon! Can't beat the price!

    Good post stooxie!

    You will always have the armchair quarterback types that talk a good game, but have zero actual hands on experience USING the product they claim to be an expert on. And as Shorts so accurately pointed out, most of these folks don't even own a BlueStar, so why would anyone even care what they think?

    The other complaints from actual owners, I chalk up to isolated incidents and pilot error. Like you, I certainly don't see any of these problems with my stove.

    This is how I feel about the subject...

    If you want restaurant quality results with your own cooking, then you need a restaurant caliber stove. While there are many brands out there "pretending" to be of this pedigree, when you start looking at the internal design and burner performance, very few are much more than glorified consumer ranges.

    As I mentioned in some other posts... I made my living cooking on a Garland for nearly 10 years, and this little BlueStar 30" is the closest thing to that monster I have ever cooked on in a residential setting. Nothing else I have owned or used at a friend's home has come remotely close to feeling like cooking on that Garland. This little BlueStar takes me back every time I fire it up and start doing my thing.

    When BlueStar says "Genuine Restaurant Ranges for the Home", they aren't kidding. ;o)

  • 15 years ago

    It's really encouraging to hear, here and on other threads, that Bluestar's customer service has taken a turn for the better.

    That said, from this thread alone it's impossible not to notice quality control issues. God bless them if they're dealing with them better, though of course it would be nicer to read about no problems.

    I am NOT happy with mine nor the service from bs. period... I've not been on "appliances" much, has lamermaid elaborated? She certainly was a vocal pre-customer.

    It's a great range-- not perfect. I think it is well worth it to cope with the "problems" to get those burners. Happy customer, but once again problems.

    Called BlueStar, reported these issues and they did the following: Sent FOUR new bowl grates Sent new 8" backplate Sent complete set of replacement knobs Awesome, but should it have been necessary in the first place?

    I have now been using my 36" RNB for 3 months with almost zero problems. Shorts, could you elaborate on what "almost zero problems" means?

    I think it's very fair to say that issues with the product have been well-documented for YEARS on this forum. There have been trolls, and several have been weeded out. More importantly, there have been countless customers who have been very happy despite issues that they may have had. Great, but that doesn't negate the fact that there's been issues. If the phones are being answered faster and parts sent out without question, awesome! Still an issue though, no?

    p.s. No I don't own one. Still on the top of my wish list despite all, but please don't bash me for stating facts even though I don't own one.

  • 15 years ago

    Mr. Stump...

    Technically you're not stating facts, you're aggregating data from an unknown sample size. That's called meta analysis but you're not exactly dealing with much of a "study" in the first place.

    I don't think anyone is saying that the people that have been done wrong don't deserve some recourse. All we are saying is that if Bluestar has made improvements to their products and customer service then it has to stand. You can't just say "Well, they were bad in the past so they will always be bad."

    I've looked through the Capital Culinarian threads and there's all sorts of weirdness there, too. Ignitors that start sparking even when there IS flame, parts that need to be replaced, etc.

    Gee, sound familiar? Now, they might not be REPEATING the same mistakes that Bluestar made but it's baloney to think that this company is going to ship every unit perfectly from the factory.

    Study the concepts of Six Sigma and get back to us. If the Bluestar and CC cost $100,000 I would expect them to be flawless. Until then, expect some customer service issues.

    -Stooxie

  • 15 years ago

    I thought I would chime in...my wife and found this forum while searching for a 30" all gas range. We had just order a Viking 30" sealed burner range and then read this forum and all the issues with Viking products and their Customer service (or lack thereof). We immediately called the vendor and canceled the order. We were intrigued by the Bluestar and went to go take a look. I was impressed with the burners, the size of the oven and the overall solid build quality. We brought along a few pots and pans of various sizes and were very happy with the burners.

    We received our 30" V1 Jan 10, 2011 and have been extremely happy with it's performance! Fit and finish is amazing!

    We went out and bought a 14" carbon steel wok, seasoned it and all I can say is WOW - with the 22k burner and wok cooking is so much fun on this stove!

    My wife made a batch of brownies the other day. She always had issues with our old Maytag oven - the edges would always cook faster than the center. Not with the Bluestar - they came out perfectly!

    The only problem with this range is I may start to put on a few pounds :)

    Steve

  • 15 years ago

    Stooxie, what I'm stating is what I accept as facts based on feedback from people whose feedback seems plausible. Just as I've accepted your positive feedback as plausible. Should I not?

    Bluestar vs Culinarian? You brought them up, I didn't. My only gripe is you and goldengoose apparently making blanket dismissal of others' past issues with BS seemingly based solely on your own recent positive experiences.

    Now this admitedly opinion, but I don't think you need to spend $100K to hope for a flawless range. Your best bet is probably in the $1K-$2K ballpark. It's $5-$15 that seems to have the problems. What's Six Sigma got to say about that? (I'm genuinely asking, I don't know.)

  • 15 years ago

    Food,

    I didn't bring up CC vs BS, scroll up, it was deeageaux.

    In most basic terms, Sig Sigma is a business methodology that looks at defect rates in processes. A typical metric is "defects per million X" and The "six sigma" refers to the probability of one defects in a million iterations. The airline industry is among the best on the planet with a sigma factor approaching 7. That means one death in almost 10 million passengers flown.

    Getting back to stoves, the more complicated a unit is the more opportunity there is for defect. Metal is stamped and bent, parts are cast, joins are made, pipes sealed, etc, etc. If a vendor was going to control all of this to exact tolerances you really would see prices 5X-10X of what they are. They control it to the point that makes sense for their business. BMW might know that they can get their quality control 99% right off the line, and the remaining 1% will have a defect that is covered under warranty. It might cost BMW $200M to wring out that last 1% or they could just let the warranty department (which is funded by sales) take care of it. It's a business decision.

    My Bluestar stove weighs 614 pounds. That's a LOT of metal. A LOT of stainless steel and cast iron. For me, if they got my stove 99.9% right and all they had to do was replace the smallest of my burner heads because of a casting defect? Shoot, I call that a job well done.

    FYI, the only way they were going to see that defect is if they individually inspect each and every cast iron burner head coming into the factory. I would say 99% of any defects show up immediately in a function test, i.e. flame pattern not right. It's not worth their time, or my having to pay for it, to having someone spend any more time than they do looking at them. Another way to catch such defects would be to Xray them, and then we're back to that $100,000 stove.

    Perhaps a knock in Bluestar is that most people don't subscribe to any of this. They want everything perfect and shiny forever. Trevor from Eurostoves has spent countless hours, I'm sure, telling people not to worry about cooking grids that aren't shiny black any more, griddle tops that no longer sparkle, baffle grills that don't look like new. This is why there are so few manufacturers that make something like the Bluestar or CC. Too much dancing in the minefield!

    To me, this also fundamentally explains the difference between the BS buyer and the CC buyer. Ultimately they want different things and that's fine!! All of this agonizing over which to get and all of this reseller puffery about which is the "best" just ignores the real issue: What kind of a cook are you and what do you expect from a range?

    -Stooxie

  • 15 years ago

    Stooxie,

    I could be wrong but I think I know what might be a bit off putting. It seems that because BS is now being responsive and so far the ranges are performing well that all of the issues and complaints over the last few years were overwrought unskilled folks that didn't know how to use the range. Not ever having been a professional chef and all.

    This is not the case, there were issues, and if they weren't why did BS tell folks they were being addressed with the V1? CS has been not so hot either. I think most on this list understand that all things do don't come off production lines perfect, it just won't happen. If it is taken care of promptly everyone is happy, if it isn't not so much.

    Many folks on this list have been waiting on reports of the V1 to see how it did, now that more are out and about that info is showing up. The reports on excellent CS are also important, that way folks know that IF there is an issue it will be dealt with promptly. Knowing that makes folks more comfortable about buying a BS.

    However even with the new and improved BSV1 and CS, folks have the right to be leery, will this last? That is not in the least being unfair.

    The BS and the CC are both cooking machines and I see little difference in the type of folks that want one or the other. There are folks on this list that have experience with true pro ranges and some from the restaurant viewpoint, they just don't flaunt it. Some have owned both a BS and now have a CC, flip a coin.

    Personally I am thrilled to death I do NOT have black shiny grate/grids on the CC.:-)

  • 15 years ago

    As a reminder, the OP asked 3 questions (I'm paraphrasing)...

    1 & 2) What changed with the V1 and did it solve all of the BS problems?

    I think the first question has been answered sufficiently. The short answer to the second question is no. But we all know there is no range mfr who ships zero defects (they would be happy with 3-sigma I think Stooxie, no?). The early returns from a few V1 owners seem to indicate BS made significant strides with previous issues, including customer service.

    3) The OP asked about a comparison between BS and CC, specifically, "is CC likely to be a sufficient upgrade over BS V1 to justify the risk of early adoption?". Well, this is a loaded question. As a proud CC owner, I don't think even I would be silly enough to classify the CC as an ''upgrade'' to the BS V1. I won't even say it is better - how can I, I've never used a BS. I do know I love my CC, even though it too had a few minor issues that required some attention. So to answer the element of the OP's question about early adoption, the several people who own CCs have reported only minor issues that have been resolved quickly and completely, and we all love our Culinarians (...ahem, and we love Trevor too). Time will tell, but so far the CC appears to be a solid, well designed, reliable product.

    I think the CC and BS are actually very similar to each other, especially when compared to products from other mfrs. They certainly have differences in performance, features and aesthetics, but I think this forum tends to artificially magnify those differences.

    So in summary, the BS and CC are both made here in America (OK, some parts are foreign sourced), they are terrific cooking machines, their build quality appear to be quite good, and the customer service provided by their companies appear to be excellent (so far). Can I get a big woohoo for us consumers?

    ...and GG7, if you are still reading, I can't help but toss a friendly jab your way...you own an IR thermometer, and you call others gear heads? That's funny. ;-)

    Happy cooking.

    Jon