Software
Houzz Logo Print
simpleallu

Need advice on front elevation

17 years ago

Do I keep the gable over the front door? It doesn't serve any purpose. I feel conflicted about it. On paper it looks good to me but I feel all those gables might make it look too busy in real life? What do you think? Any suggestions?

Comments (11)

  • 17 years ago

    Isn't there a roof over the porch? The front elevation seems to show one.

    You need some sort of roof to protect the front door and those standing in front of it from the elements. Front doors without protection can be miserable to live with in bad weather.

  • 17 years ago

    Since you asked for suggestions, here goes:

    Doesn't the gable provide cover to the entrance? It would seem to be the most functional gable on the house.

    To me stone stuck on the bottom of a house makes it appear as if the house has sunk into it's foundation. Why not use a historically accurate water table detail?

    A small point but the swing of a door should not be shown on the elevation drawing because it will also be shown on the plans and such information should only be documented once to avoid ordering errors.

    To me, the garage door design seems out of place on this house.

    I would not use LP SmartSide on a house unless you plan to paint it every 5 years. It is not actually a "composite" since it is treated aspen wood OSB with a water resistant paper face which makes it an "engineered" siding similar to laminate flooring which is also a short sighted material choice.

    Victorian Stick Style houses usually have double-hung windows. I suspect double-hungs would be considerably cheaper so you might be able to take a step up in quality. It might also be easier to meet the code requirement for emergency escape from the bedrooms. Some casement windows do not have adequate hardware strength to be used in a fully open position for emergency escape. Check with the manufacturer.

    The large blank space above the garage doors is troubling. Is there some kind of windowless space behind it?

    I would take the design more toward the Stick Style with more decorative trim detailing or more toward the Shingle Style with less trim and more shingles.

    Are there no gutters, guards or handrails?

    Why are the front steps off center?

  • 17 years ago

    I like the look of the front elevation (assuming that the lower roof covers the front porch) except for one thing, but it's a big thing....it seems to me that the house is unbalanced. When I look at the elevation, it seems like there should be "more" on the left side of the house. Of course, I'm just a guy, not an expert. :)

  • 17 years ago

    Macv,

    What is historically accurate water table detail? I hope that isn't a stupid question. I'm reviewing the latest elevations for our plan and this just seems like something I should know.

  • 17 years ago

    I apologize. I am not at all familar with the building lingo. I probably didnt refer to the right thing when I said gable. The lower roof covers the front porch and the front door. I definitely want for the main door to have a roof but just not sure about the decorative triangular thing with fascia above it. Does that make it any clearer?

    rsc2a
    You probably have a valid point about the imbalance, you think if the porch was wrapped around on the left side it would fix it? Although, we dont have the right lot for it. There would only be 20ft of space between our house and our neighbors.

    macv
    Thanks so much for all your feedback. Again with my total lack of technical knowledge of anything building related I would really appreciate it if you explain some more about the following.

    Stone/Water table detailing - Do you mean that instead of having the stone set randomly like how the plan shows, have it set in a more defined pattern. I am guessing that water table detailing is somesort of a pattern like this.

    .

    If so then yes, that is how I plan on having it set. Uniform square shaped stones. Garage doors- We are planning on carraige style doors like below. I just assumed that the draftsman didnt have a prototype to represent these doors.

    Do these look any better to you?

    Good catch on the steps. I will get them corrected. Now to the more important stuff. I don't have too much insight on what type of exterior materials are good/not good. But when you compared LP Smart side to laminate, it made me panic. I called my builder and she told me that we had only two choices. Either cedar/LP Smart side because of deed restrictions. She said cedar would require yearly maintenance. Do you have anything specific in mind that you would recommend? I could talk to my Builder about it.

    Blank Space above garage- you know I didn't notice this. I just assumed this was normal. But I guess not.

  • 17 years ago

    A water table is a horizontal trim board shaped like a sill on top of a horizontal trim board at the bottom of the siding to force water to drip free of the foundation.

    The detail you show is also a "water table" on top of stone cladding but because it doesn't project beyond the stone and have a drip, water will eventually enter the stone work and if the weather is cold enough the stone will be displaced by repeated freeze thaw cycles.

    Homes used to have their first floors built 3 or 4 feet above the ground requiring 4 to 5 steps plus a half step at the door. This allowed windows in the basement without window wells as well as access for coal chutes and smaller bulkhead hatches. Today houses are built as close as the ground as cladding material will allow. The amount of foundation showing has decreased from 3 ft to about 6". Adding stone to the face of the house up to or above the window sill heights is supposed (I assume) to mimic the old foundations but to me it just looks silly. Unfortunately, since the stone veneer is generally thicker than the upper siding, an awkward "water table" is necessary. This detail is expensive when done properly and even more expensive later if it isn't done properly.

    My advice is to stick to a more traditional design.

  • 17 years ago

    It is not possible to judge the balance of the elevation from the drawing above. If the garage wing protrudes forward enough it would become a separate element and there would be no reason to try to balance it.

    I see what you mean about the porch having a decorative gable that duplicates the one just above it. It's a bit too cute and forces an expectation of symmetry. My instinct is to delete the upper one but that could be because I'm not a big fan of repeating gables. Try it without the porch gable; it might simplify the house and give the upper gables more architectural authority.

    Of course, you would need a gutter if the gable/cricket wasn't there. See what I mean about it being the most function gable?

    Maybe the end of the porch roof should be hipped.

    This house has such huge attic spaces. Since there are no windows in them I assume they will just be used for storage. Historically, a house like this would have had a third floor with a servant's bedroom and possibly a billiard room. Leave room for a stair so someone can use the space later. Boom times can't last forever.

    The garage doors you show look like a pressed metal type with simulated colonial iron strap hinges that aren't fooling anyone. These doors are on the front of your house so you should budget a bit more money for them or move them to the side of the house.

    Here are some doors built of wood with more convincing proportions and detailing:

  • 17 years ago

    simpleallu, I agree with your gut feeling -- the front of the house looks too busy to me, too.

  • 17 years ago

    Thanks so much everyone. You guys are great as always.

  • 17 years ago

    I tend to agree with most things people have said. I dont agree about the stone base. I prefer them. The windows should be double hung. As stated they are usually less $$$.

    The garage doors do need changed and those shown are good examples but there are a few more available as well. Also search craftsman style homes ( images) and look at the various details. I would suggest the columns go to the ground, breaking the porch slab plain. If its not a budget killer they(base) or the column should be tapered as well.

    Are the garage doors 7 or 8 feet tall? If not, they should be 8 ft in my opinion and that would help with the space. You could also make the trim above the door a heavier trimboard sa 1x8 or 1x10

    http://www.homeplanscanada.com/craftsman/images/uploads/garage.jpg

    The gables are not a big deal to me but as pointed out it doesnt need to have all them detailed. Do remember, you dont see the elevation this way there is depth to the various elements.

  • 17 years ago

    One other thing...On the elevation I would have the shingles removed from the roofs. They are one reason the elevations looks so busy here as well. Its not the only reason but it makes the drawings read poorly. There is no relief from Hatching. Then while again its minor...if you can screen the hatching on the elevation you will make the main elements stand out more appropriately. Im not sure if this is an issue or not but you may need to look at the roof where the garage meets the house. Will it propersly shed water /snow ? Just a thought