We need to choose an architectural 30 year shingle SOON! Looking for something in the dark grey/charcoal. Is there much quality difference in the GAF timberline high definition and Tamko Heritage 30? Consumer reports rates them similar.

We're looking at Tamko in black walnut, rustic black and GAF in charcoal.

Here's the exterior color scheme we are aiming for (whitewash brick, black clad windows, mahogany wood door)

{{gwi:1512873}}