Software
Houzz Logo Print
thundersweet

Please look at these floors.

19 years ago

We just went through a major remodel. We had hardwoods added and some refinished. They started out saying they were going to do 3 coats of poly. Great! Well, when they did 3rd coat of poly, we had areas around the perimeter of the rooms that looked like pools of stain. They came back and said they used the wrong applicator and would need to add another coat of poly. They sanded or rescreened them and added a 4th coat of poly. We have 2 big dogs. We waited to allow them on the floor again. This is what's happening to the floors.

{{gwi:1518924}}

Now, let me say, the new family room only has the 3 coats of poly. This absolutely does not happen on those floors. In fact, my dogs and kids spend most of the days in there and they look fantastic. Our laundry room is used to hold the doogs while workers are in and out and they too look good. Yes, they have some scratches but you have to find them in the right light. We added an inlaw suite and my mom has all hardwoods put in as well a 2 big dogs. Her floors look great. The only areas we have these huge areas with scratches is the rooms with the 4th coat of poly.

I had another company come out and give their opinion. She said they never should have added a 4th coat of poly. You will almost always get the flaking of the top layer. She also said there was a lot of "picture framing." She said it appeared the stain was not totally dry before they poly'd. She said the correct way to fix it would have been to resand all the way down and start over. Sand , stain and 3 coats poly. Please tell me what you think. We are working with our contractor to try and get them refinished. This flaking is everywhere. The floors look terrible. Well, all except the areas that only got 3 coats. I should say, we have always had hardwoods and never have we had anything like this happen. Yes, the dogs have scratched the floors but its not noticable unless you get down and look. These are noticable from across the room. You pretty much can't live in these areas without damaging the finish. They looked better before we had them refinished. The owner of the flooring company came out a few months ago and said it was the dogs, and they did not warranty against that. But, he had never seen them scratch like that though either. I never did point out the differences between the areas with 3 coats and the areas with 4. Plus we still have those areas that look like stain pools. The stain is Provincial.

Thanks,

Sandy

Comments (11)

  • 19 years ago

    your picture looks like scratches typically caused by pets and are considered abuse of a wood flooring system no one will warrenty.

    As to the wording of your post, only you can decide if your argument warrents further action on your part.

    Few natural wood flooring systems will stand up to pet abuse.

    Many choose a high grade laminate flooring system or ceramic tile for their abrasive and scratch resistance when clawed pets area a consideration.

    if everything you say is true, the flooring company "may" hold "some" liability, but the fact remains that clawed pets caused the failure in the finish layer, and needs to be heavily considered.

    Anyone deciding a case such as this needs to ask the question: "would there be any problem at all if the dogs were not on the floors to begin with?".

    that said, typically 2 to 3 coats is the norm.

    there are cases where extra coats are requested, ordered, or otherwise deemed necessary as a remedy to a problem, and installed with no issues. This is normal.

    From the sound of your posts the flooring company did everything in their power to service you and provide an appropriate remedy to their admitted error, which I might add that screening and recoating is the normal way to handle such problems, which also was a success if you subtract the clawed pets.

    It is indeed a difficult situation and I do feel for you since I have house dogs of my own, but pet-caused flooring problems = no warrenty generally.

    Sorry

  • 19 years ago

    But why would your floors look great in all the other spaces where there is actually more activity? esp since you've had lots of real life exp with hardwood floors and never exp anything like this. I hope you can get this fixed. Don't give up. Somethings not right.

  • 19 years ago

    feebs, thank you, this is exactly my point. Areas with high traffic are fine. If the floor company had not messed up and had to do a 4th coat, we would not be in this position at all. So, that's why we feel they need to fix it back the way it was.

    floorman, I would not expect the company to warranty against dog scratches. I know they never would. But, I feel this should be an exception since they had to do it this way due to their mistake. Had they not messed up on application, my floors would be looking great right now. Like I said, I have always had hardwoods. I do get scratches but fine scratches. They don't take the poly right off the floor in long strips. Our new family room is right off the other areas. You can sttand with one foot in one room and one foot in the other. It just does not make sense that one area doesn't do this and one area does. The only difference is the poly. Here is a picture. The room farthest away, through the opening, has no problems. Everything EXCEPT that room and the in law suite (1,000 sf of hardwoods) is trashed with marks from daily living and dogs. What do you make of it? There is a stair separating these two rooms.

    {{gwi:1518925}}

    Sandy

  • 19 years ago

    I posted from experience on how clawed pets are considered abuse that no flooring company or manufacturer will warranty against.

    Please, lets be totally frank here ...

    You are assuming that you wouldnt be in this situation at all if the flooring company didnt screw up and added a 4th coat, because the other areas are not effected as much as they are in the affected area. There is no way you can know that for 100% for sure ... at least not without an inspection..

    I have been in the industry almost 30 years and I wouldnt know that without assuming or by a certified inspection being completed to determine cause and responsibility.

    The fact remains you admitted that the pets caused the problem. Without the pets, there would be no problem. I am not being arguementative. I am stating facts. Without abusive abrasion of the claws, the wood flooring finish would still be in-tact.

    Now the company may very well hold some civil liability, but they arent exactly beating your door down to attempt to rectify the situation to your satisfaction.

    Coincidences in life are strange indeed, but they nevertheless do occurr.

    I would suggest you request an independent inspection by a Hardwood Flooring Inspector certified by the IICRC, NWFA, or NOFMA.

    They arent inexpensive, and be prepared not to be reimbursed for it.

    If they wont have it inspected, which is their right, you can hire an independent certified hardwood inspector, then armed with their determination of cause and responsibility, you can take legal action civilly. The important thing here is a paper trail, so write everything down from sales to your last communication with them, including all the facts and who said what and when they said it. Also its important to note that the inspectors be inspection industry certified as an expert to do any good in court.

    At a minimum, the pets causing the scratches will probably decrease any liability they have while increasing your own so dont expect to get 100% of your investment back. If you do, great! but dont set your heart on it.

    This is your only recourse if the contracted firm will not negotiate with you or honor your claim that it was their fault and not clawed pet abuse.

    I am sorry my experience can't simply tell you what you want to hear.

    Certified Flooring Inspectors

    Here is a link that might be useful: Certified Flooring Inspectors

  • 19 years ago

    Thundersweet,
    I'm sorry about what happened.

    Can I ask from a COLOR perspective how happy you are with Provincial? Would you say it looks as light/dark in person as it does in the 2nd photo you posted?

    I want to use something similar to what you used, but perhaps a tiny bit lighter. Much thanks.

  • 19 years ago

    That floor looks like a classic case of finish peel. Either the final coat is peeling from the underlying or all four are peeling from the stain.

    Can you peel pieces off the floor with your fingernail? Turn it over and look for the color of your stain stuck to the underside of the peeled piece. If you see your stain color, then all four coats are peeling from the stain. If not, then it is the final coat that is not adhering well to the previous coat.

    Sure pets, especially large dogs, can damage site finished hardwood. But, the floor should at least be resistant to such damage and it appears that yours is not.

    Was this oilbase or waterborne polyurethane?

  • 19 years ago

    I tend to agree with that, the wear coat or coats is not adhering correctly.

  • 19 years ago

    uluvbs, its like a med brown? I love the color. I would say, it's maybe a tad lighter than the picture.

    glennsfc and jerry t, I cant really peel a new spot. We could at one point though. I can peel with my finger nail a little if I start from an area that is scratched. I don't see stain. Now, there are definitely areas that are down to the bare wood. The photo posted above looks like it's just the top layer. At least to me it looks that way. I agree, it should be resistant to dogs. It is in the rest of the house after all. I should say, this damage to the areas with a 4th coat is extensive AND it happened within a very short period. The floors have only been down 6 months. They were ruined within a month. jerry t, that's exactly what the other floor company told me. The 4th coat was not adhering correctly. My kids can't even run their cars and trucks on these floors or play with toys. You should see my living room floor from X-mas!

    floorman, the bottom line is this. The areas with the satin finish, only 3 coats of poly, are fantastic. They do not do this at all. Yes, there are tiny scratches in the laundry area where the dogs stay when the workers are here. But the finish is not flaking off. The scratches look like they normally would on hardwood floors. They are barely noticable. In fact, I could not get get a picture they are so faint.

    We are still working with the remodeling company. We are near done and we are holding a large sum of money for final payment. We are letting them deal with the flooring company s ince they hired them. They are coming this week sometime to look at them. Can anyone give advise as to what to do if they don't want to fix it? My thought is if the flooring company won't fix them then the company we hired to do the project needs to step up and correct it.

    Thanks,
    Sandy

  • 19 years ago

    ___________________________________________________________

    "Can anyone give advise as to what to do if they don't want to fix it?"
    ___________________________________________________________

    if they all refuse to agree with you and refuse your claim that it was instalaltion error, to get what you want you have to either refuse to pay them or take them to court and prove you case to a Judge and have him award judgement in your favor.

    if there is any doubt in their mind about the validity of your claim, withholding money and/or threatening suit might spark them to act on your claim.

    if not, and you are sued, you can always counter sue but you need evidence to prove your claim that it was isntallation error and not the pet abuse that cause the issue ... just thinking it because other areas arent equally affected isnt proof from an expert in the industry ... it's supposition and conjecture.

    this is why independent inspections are performed. They are experts who will determine cause and responsibility, and can testify if needed. At a minimum they will supply a report.

    upon the inspectors finding of cause and responsibility is usually enough to prevent the need for a lawsuit and subsiquent court case, which is why I suggested it in an earlier post ... for the contractor to either: act and rectify the situation to the customers satisfaction if the inspection proves installation error, or it could cause a consumer to drop their claim if it was not installation error and was a liability fator under control of the consumer that caused the problem.

    so, to break it down, you have 5 choices.

    1. request they hire a certified independent inspector to make a determination, then proceed based on that determination.

    2. you hire a certified independent inspector to make a determination, then proceed based on that determination.

    3. refuse payment and hope they act or use the money toi ahve soeone else fix it to your satisfaction.

    4. pay them and sue them first with no evidence backing your claims.

    5. do nothing.

  • 19 years ago

    floorman, I did use your links to find a certified inspector. I have already contacted him. Thank you for that information. I did not know there was such a thing as a floor inspector. Anyway, I will call him today, as he suggested, and then keep him handy if things don't go well and I need a certified report.

    Thanks,
    Sandy

  • 19 years ago

    thundersweet: I'm sorry to hear about your floors and hope that things have been worked out. But I like the colour of your floor and have a few questions for you about that, if you don't mind.

    I believe that you used Provincial - do you know what brand? Also, do you know what wood type you have? I would like to use Provincial in my hall and kitchen on brand new red oak floors because I think that it would look elegant and not too dark. But my kitchen cabinets are dark cherry/burgundy colour and then I worry about using Provincial with them. I noticed in your second picture that you have an armoire that appears to be dark, but that could just be the camera. What colour is the armoire? Do you have any advice for me about using Provincial with dark cabinets? Will it be too dark? If so, what is a lighter colour?

    I truly appreciate your time and attention,
    Anna