10 year old Ceramic Tile floor popping up..Help!

15 years ago

I need some help from a Floor pro if possible. I have a customer who has a 10 Year old ceramic tile floor installed over concrete in a semi basement. The tiles are 12x12 and have been perfect for the past 9 1/2 years. In the last few month they noticed the tiles heaving up about a 1/2 inch or so. The tiles are NOT individually lifting up, but whole areas of the floor. The tiles are all still held together perfectly with the grout. No cracks at all.

I chisled away the grout lines on one tile and the thinset was firmly attached to the bottom of the tile, but was cleanly pulled up from the floor. There was evidence of old black mastic on the back of the tile.

My questions are as follows:

1- Why did it take so long for the tile to loosen its grip?

2- Should the installer had laid the floor over the previous VCT floor adhesive directly?

3- If a new floor is installed over the concrete again, how is the old VCT adhesive removed?

4- Would moisture from recent rains have caused this? The cement appeared dry under the removed tile.

Thanks

Robert

Pittsburgh, PA

Featured Answer

PRO

Cancork Floor Inc.

9 years ago

Ceramic tile is known to do stuff like this (tenting) because it is slightly porous. Porcelain tile has LESS chance of tenting because its porosity is extremely low - almost impervious to moisture. It is much lower than ceramic.

And yes, it can take as much as 10 years for a "bad" install to show itself in wet conditions. It can take that long to get the tile so wet that it's expansion is so great it breaks the bond of the adhesive.

And yes...cut back adhesive is a poor substrate to bond to (for the Original Poster). Both of these photos (OP and andreadell79) are complete redos. Once a section starts to tent, you have to assume the WHOLE THING is going to go to he!! in a hand basket. Sorry but these are complete redos.

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (11)

stoneeater
15 years ago
1.Conditions were finally right for tenting to occur.
2.Cutback adhesive is a poor substrate to bond to.
3.Scrape away as much as possible. You can test it for asbestos and if it comes back clean you can mechanically abrade or scarify it. If it's asbestos you either abate it or you just have a poor substrate to bond to.
4.Moisture can have alot to do with it. It makes stuff expand and contract.
Was the floor cut/grouted tightly to the wall?
Stud or masonry walls?
Expansion joints in the feild?
brickeyee
15 years ago
If you cover the concrete with cememnt board forst the problem should no recur.

It CAN be a major pain to get the borard down tight though.

I use plastic water 'bladder tanks' designed to fit in a pick up truck bed (flexible plastic).

After lying down thin set and cement board, the plastic bladder tanks are put on the cement board and filled up.

They provide a nice uniform compression to hold the cment board down tight.

If you fill the bladders up so they are about a foot thick you have ~60 pounds per square foot holding everything down.
Related Professionals
Sedalia Flooring Contractors · Philadelphia Flooring Contractors · Fall River Flooring Contractors · Madison Flooring Contractors · Santa Barbara Flooring Contractors · Grand Forks Tile and Stone Contractors · Albany Tile and Stone Contractors · Savannah Kitchen Remodelers · Manhattan Kitchen Remodelers · Muskogee Kitchen Remodelers · Muncie Kitchen Remodelers · Grand Rapids Kitchen Remodelers · Lansing Kitchen Remodelers · Chula Vista Kitchen Remodelers · Ottawa Kitchen Remodelers
User
15 years ago
Cement board is not approved to be set over concrete - if your installation fails you will be out of luck because no manufacturer will back it. The only correct way is to completely remove the VCT floor adhesive.

Have you had unusually wet weather? Your floor may simply contain too much moisture, a problem that would have to be addressed first in order for any flooring material to be laid without problems.
brickeyee
15 years ago
"Cement board is not approved to be set over concrete"

According to who?

Cement board has been used over concrete for a LONG time to provide the isolation layer and prevent defects in the concrete from moving into a top layer if tile.

Most of the warranties are hardly worth the paper they are printed on.

Material replacement (a common warranty remedy) does not cover labor to remove or install.

There is actually no way to completely remove VCT adhesive from a concrete surface.
It has soaked into the concrete and contaminated the surface.
User
15 years ago
According to the manufacturers. It is to be set in thinset and screwed down. Of course, as with any item, the purchasers may misuse the product as they see fit - they just lose the right to complain if it goes badly. Advising a clearly inexperienced person to misuse a product seems unwise.
andreadell79
9 years ago
We are having this problem now. Our tiles in our house have been popping up randomly all weekend. It is crazy. Our house is 10 years old this year.
andreadell79
9 years ago
One piece that was already unattached was still making the cracking noise. In a matter of 1 minute a few tiles rose up 2 inches.
dauglos
9 years ago
Wow. Didn't know this sort of thing was possible. My first thought probably would have been either ghosts or graboids!
geoffrey_b
9 years ago
House isn't built over a cemetery? :)

Seriously, this is an indication that there is movement in the building. I would look for a small water leak. Or a leak in the roof and water is coming down an inside wall. Something is making the wood floor expand - my guess.
PRO
Avanti Tile & Stone / Stonetech
9 years ago
Failure to put in a siliconed expansion joint or grouting firmly to perimeter walls leaves nowhere for tile to go other than "up" due to natural movement of floors and walls. Not uncommon. Looks as though there are other issues as well....failure to bond well to cement, cutback or a sealer over the slab come to mind.