Software
Houzz Logo Print
dogpound_gw

Cracks in leather?

19 years ago

I recently purchased Randall Allen (Hancock & Moore subsidiary Made in China) and noticed leather is cracking on some pieces. I don't have the product in direct sunlight, near heat source, nor have I cleaned the product yet as I have only had posession over a month. Anyone have any suggestions is to why this could be? My assumption here is flat out sub par product!

Comments (7)

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I'm not familiar with Randall Allen being one of the Hancock and Moore companies, but they may very well be.

    Leather cracking on a new pieces is caused by too much topcoat or a topcoat that is not elastic enough to stretch (or a combination of both). Almost all hides coming out of China are "finished" hides, which have a heavy tanning process. That is, more material is "sprayed" on the hide because the leathers are not good enough quality to use aniline dyed processes.

    Imagine if you painted a piece of leather with a spray can in your garage. Just regular old spray paint. Its fine until you begin flexing it, and then the paint cracks. Thats whats happening to your Randall Allen pieces.

    If these are relatively new pieces, I would go back to my selling dealer and express my dissatisfaction and attempt a warranty return. However, you would be well-advised to not not get the same product again and see if your store would allow you to purchase a different product.

    I personally have been very disappointed in the quality of leather goods coming out of China. Yes, they allow the customer to buy an item that's price-friendly, but I think it a false economy as product failure rates and product lifespans leave much to be desired.

    Its pretty much true that 'You get what you pay for' in most instances.

    Good luck with a warranty claim.

    Duane Collie
    The Keeping Room

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Duane,

    I really appreciate the follow up thread from you as I see you as the expert in this community. Your assessment seems very logical and one my wife had this in mind all along as she read this somewhere as well on the web. I do know for sure that this is a Hancock & Moore division as if you call the Hancock & Moore customer service line and ask for the Randall Allen division they will transfer the call.

    Having said that, I will definitely be finding out here real soon if Jimmy Moore stands by any of his product and does the right thing as I see most people in this community speak highly of their customer service and the manufacture claims they do as well!

    I must say I was very skeptical of purchasing this line coming out of China and not happy about this one bit, rather convinced this line is no better than anything I can purchase at any low to medium quality store for literally hundreds of less dollars!!!

    Thanks

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I know that Hancock and Moore has eight different companies (including Council Craftsman) but they don't usually 'cross-over' one another. Some are contract-grade, some are for the health care industry, and so forth.

    I know that Hancock & Moore is purposely kept free of imports (other than some of their carved frames are imported) and ascertains to the be the best in the industry.

    Try working through your selling dealer first, then the Randall Allen group if the dealer is no help, to see what happens. If that doesn't work, then write a letter to Jimmy Moore and see what kind of response you get.

    I'd be inclined to get out of that brand and take a credit torwards something thats not made in China.

    Good Luck,
    Duane

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Duane

    Went to dealer this afternoon and brought in several of the defective pieces for the owner of store to review. He unequivocally agreed this product is defective and relayed his assessment to his Hancock & Moore representative while I was in store. He even asked to keep the ottoman which out of all the pieces is probably the best piece in terms of % damaged or defective.

    I have read many of the threads in this community and I have a new profound sense of disappointment with the furniture industry in the sense I believe the disparity between Hancock & Moore and a low in brand such as Ashley is a very wide gap and anything in between to a point is senseless to purchase as you may be wasting your money!

    We did look at and discuss several Hancock & Moore products such as Journey, Citizen, Member, Austin, and City. At this point I am questioning spending an additional $1000 dollars for this brand.

    I ask only what good is a sofa that is an 8-way hand tied deck, hardwood kiln frame, more or less built with the same features as a Hancock & Moore if the leather is cracking along with many other noticeable flaws?

    Sorry to vent here!

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    There are plenty of good brands out there, Hancock and Moore is certainly not the only one with a good reputation.

    The key to buying furniture is getting an education! That's the reason I contribute here, to try to help folks learn about what makes one aspect of a piece better than another. And its also why I take the time and effort to go to places where they make these pieces and learn how they go together.

    I've been running a furniture business since 1985 and not a week goes by I don't try to gain some new information on what makes a piece good - or what makes it bad. My experience is that most consumers don't take the time to learn about what they are buying. The average consumer buys based on these criteria:

    * Price (especially if its 'on sale')
    * Appearance
    * Comfort
    * and most of all.... PRICE (did I already say that?)

    Some of the key elements they miss are:

    * service/performance life relative to price.
    * construction methods (especially on hard case goods).
    * service durability coverings on upholstery.

    I spend a lot of time in my store educating customers who take the time to listen and learn - but then again most stores are more interested in swiping your credit card moreso than helping you make a good decision.

    So, back to leather cracking....its simply a case of a cheap hide that probably had a crappy run on a particular batch and too much topcoat was applied. Its made in China, too - and the real issue is quality control. It can be on the best frame on the world but if the cover is junk, then premature failure is the result.

    When a piece is made in China, the LAST person to see that piece before the local dealer unpacks it is a factory worker who crated it in China. There is no one on the USA that looks at the piece other than to pull it out of the container and load it on a truck - fully boxed. As you can imagine, quality control is pretty sketchy and whom do they (the USA distributor) go back to in the event of issues? There's a language barrier to cross, and most of the people I know in Hickory NC don't speak Mandarin. The end result is that there is more of a tendency to simply throw up one's hands than to try to resolve a quality control problem from a foreign manufacturer. Time and time again when I complained about Chinese made furniture I got the same answer "Well, its made overseas so it is what it is".

    When a piece like your Randall Allen is returned for warranty / QC issues, it doesn't go back to China for inspection or get rebuilt here in the states. Its tossed into a trash heap, given to charity, or marked down to .10 on the wholesale dollar to simply get rid of it.

    Every manufacturer I speak with is loathe to go to China. Not a one of them is excited to do it, but they are forced to do it because the American Consumer demands cheap prices. In the USA, our workers have Workers Comp, Social Security, Health Insurance and make a living wage of $ 15 TO $ 30 per hour. To cut production costs, they go to China where the worker has no benefits to speak of and makes .50 an hour. Production shortcuts are made as well, be it joinery or materials (such as cheap hides), so that when all is said and done the customer can get the three things they look for in the store:

    * Price
    * Appearance
    * Comfort

    But the pieces are poor quality and this becomes apparent due to the quick breakdown of internal structure and systems in the piece, be it cushions failing, or leather cracking, or frames squeaking.

    There's a reason why "Randall Allen" is not sold under the Hancock and Moore label. Its an inferior product built to satisfy the three things customers want (above). Because Hancock and Moore has gone to great lengths to build a superior product not subject to price targets, they do not want to dilute their flagship brand by selling Chinese made goods under that label - so they create new name label that probably was pulled out of thin air.

    Buying Hancock and Moore and thinking its related to Randall Allen is about like getting a General Electric toaster and thinking its related to GE's Aviation Division.

    Here's the thing that no one wants to hear. Folks, you have to spend some money to get quality. There, I said it! As an example, here's how I would rate up leather sofas in various price ranges:

    * Under $ 999 - Don't even bother bringing it home. Junk in the box.

    * $ 1,100 to $ 1,800 - Cheap import, regardless of what the sales droid tells you Expect failure of some component in the first three years.

    * $ 1,900 to $ 2,400. - Entry range of acceptable quality pieces. Expect hides to be low-end. Tailoring will still be sub-par.

    * $ 2,500 to $ 4,000. The sweet spot. Here you are getting top-shelf features, high-quality components, excellent tailoring and good hides. This is where I like to sell.

    * Over $ 4,000. You are paying for more exotic hides and/or a designer label.

    We've discussed leather hides here in-depth in months past, have you been able to find that thread? If you can reselect another brand and hide, look for the mid-line grades. All hides are not created equal! Generally, the more supple and soft the hide is, the less topcoating is on them, and less prone to cracking there will be.

    Duane Collie
    The Keeping Room

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Had my H&M reps come in today and I asked them about Randall Allen, and we pulled out the books and leathers (I didn't buy the line - it would probably be easier to capture Bin Laden than to get me to carry a Chinese-made furniture line).

    Its a fairly typical married-cover, limited selection, limited hide choice line that is done in groupings and 100 % made in China. Its shipped to the Council Craftsman facility in North Carolina via container and then inspected there and reboxed/shipped to the dealer network.

    I'm told it is built to Hancock and Moore specifications, and the line has very few complaints, especially in the past two years or so.

    So I'm thinking you must have a bad batch of leather. It happens from every manufacturer from time to time. It should be taken care of by your selling dealer with no fuss and replaced as it does have Hancock and Moore standing behind it.

    Good luck!
    Duane Collie
    The Keeping Room

  • 10 years ago

    I have not been happy with my Randall Allan leather recliners. They are misshapen and some of the color has rubbed off. I would not buy the brand again.