Software
Houzz Logo Print
jcthorne

Replacing AC Condenser - Upgrade to HP?

18 years ago

I am replacing a Bryant 4 ton 2 speed AC Condenser. Its 12 years old so replacement of the coil does not seem cost effective.

The gas furnace (3 speed) and coil are also 12 years old but in fine shape.

Other than the cost of the upgraded condenser and a new stat, what would have to change to replace with a 2 stage unit with heat pump so I would end up with a dual fuel system? The differential in cost of the condesers is not that great so while the two fuels are similar in cost to use now, It might be worth the cost for the option as gas continues to rise.

Comments (15)

  • 18 years ago

    you would have to install a heat pump air handler inside the house. if you have the room in your utility area i see no reason you couldnt keep the gas furnace also as backup.

  • 18 years ago

    JC

    I am not clear what the previous poster is referring to.

    When you say your 4 ton AC condenser is 2 speed, I assume you mean the condenser fan is 2 speed. Correct? Your furnace must have a var spd blower to accept a true 2 stg HP condensing unit.

    With a new heat pump condenser, you will require a matching inside evap coil and the necessary hardware/controls to go dual fuel with your existing furnace. You will probably require a new stat for dual fuel application.

    Here is a link for fuel comparison purposes.

    IMO

    Here is a link that might be useful: Fuel Comparison Calculator

  • 18 years ago

    The inside coil must be a match with the new outdoor condenser. To not replace the evap coil is a big mistake, especially if it is a heat pump which is a different animal than straight a/c. If you replace only the condenser, and not the evaporator coil, you are looking at:

    1. Reduced SEER efficiency (less than 10 SEER).
    2. Premature compressor failure due to improper refrigerant charge.
    3. Kicking yourself in the groin for doing it.
    4. The loss of groin function from kicking yourself there frequently.

    Replace the condenser and evap coil as a matched set. You can still keep the furnace and have dual-fuel capability.

    Note that with the old blower motor in the furnace, 13 SEER is probably all that you will get even with a new condenser and matched coil. Getting a condenser higher than 13 SEER will get you no more efficiency.

    Best to you.

  • 18 years ago

    "you would have to install a heat pump air handler inside the house. if you have the room in your utility area i see no reason you couldnt keep the gas furnace also as backup."

    No you wouldn't. It's called a dual fuel system. the heat pump can go on a new MATCHED coil.

  • 18 years ago

    You need to replace the indoor coil not the air handler which is the furnace you will need to have a heat pump thermostat and have the call for backup heat tell the furnace to run then you will have a duel fuel system

  • 18 years ago

    Posted by ryanhughes (My Page) on Thu, Feb 21, 08 at 17:06

    "you would have to install a heat pump air handler inside the house. if you have the room in your utility area i see no reason you couldnt keep the gas furnace also as backup."
    No you wouldn't. It's called a dual fuel system. the heat pump can go on a new MATCHED coil.
    i realize you could just put a coil in the old ac ah but i am not sure why you would want to. it probably wouldnt cost much more to get a matched ah and swap it out.

  • 18 years ago

    Hi Vhehn,

    I'm not talking about AHUs, but rather gas furnaces used with a heat pump to provide a dual fuel system. The heat pump handles the heat when it is above a certain temperature, and the furnace runs when it is cold and the heat pump is inefficient. The setup for this would be: a heat pump, an evaporator coil, a gas furnace, and a dual fuel thermostat. It's probably not all that common but in some areas it's well worth it.

  • 18 years ago

    I STRONGLY RECOMMEND A DUEL FUEL SYTEM. THAT IS WHAT I HAVE ON MY HOUSE AND I LOVE IT. 9 OF 10 AC SYSTEMS WE CHANGE OUT WE GO BACK WITH THE DUEL FUEL. I WOULD RECOMMEND CHANGING THE INDOOR COIL

  • 18 years ago

    The new matching coil is installed in the present furnace cabinet with the existing blower fan - all in one indoor box. This is a dual fuel system - indoor coil for heat pump + furnace (gas, propane, oil, etc.).

    A heat pump without a furnace and instead uses auxillary electric strips has an "air handler" for the indoor unit. Different terminology for indoor unit.

    Take care.

  • 18 years ago

    Let me give a few more details of my existing installation and see if you guys thoughts change any.

    My inside equipment is a single stage gas furnace with a 3 speed blower, not variable speed) My current condenser is a Bryant 4 ton 2 speed unit. It has a 2 speed COMPRESSOR and a 2 speed condenser fan. Two stages of cooling and 1 stage heat. Unit was rated 16 SEER on high speed and higher on low but no official rating. (It was a pretty top of the line system at the time). The indoor coil was matched to the condenser and has a TXV valve for use with the 2 stage condenser. Also shifts furnace fan speed between the two cooling stages. Lowest fan speed is used with the 80,000btu furnace.

    I understand that most all 2 stage cooling units now use dual compressors rather than two speed compressors.

    I need to replace the condeser with a new 2 stage, 4 ton unit. Cost to replace with a 2 stage plus HP is only a few hundred dollars more.

    If I smartly chose the 'correct' condenser to 'match' the coil I now have, I could save the cost of the coil which is far more than the cost of the HP upcharge. I realize this is thinking a bit backward but some careful research might result in a perfectly functioning system with dual fuel at a fairly small upcharge. If I HAVE to replace the coil too, the HP will not happen. Too much money to see a payback during its lifetime from the fuel cost differential.

    SO, some help in properly matching the coil I have to a new 2 stage condenser with HP would be helpful.

  • 18 years ago

    "I understand that most all 2 stage cooling units now use dual compressors rather than two speed compressors."
    - No. 16 SEER uses 2-stage compressors. 19 SEER uses dual compressors.

    "If I smartly chose the 'correct' condenser to 'match' the coil I now have.."
    - Easier said than done.

    Heat pumps are a different animal compared to straight a/c. The required refrigerant charge is not the same when in heating mode versus when in cooling mode. A "system" compensates for this. Your indoor coil is too small for the new outdoor condenser unit.

    You may be saving some money in the short term, but you may lose big time in the long term. Re-read my 1st post.

    If you are not satisfied with these answers, post your question on www.HVAC-Talk.com, a pro site.

    Best to you.

  • 18 years ago

    JC

    Would you mind posting the model number and brand of your outside condenser?

    It would be a mistake purchasing a HP condenser without a matching HP evap coil.

    IMO

  • 18 years ago

    I'll get the model numbers of both the condenser and coil and post them.

    Like I said earlier, if there is any way I can make this happen through research and careful product choice, I will but if it can ONLY be done with a new evap coil, then no way to justify.

    I do not understand the statement that the correct evap coil compensates for the different quatities of refrigerant required between heating and cooling modes. Its a coil with X square feet of fin area and X CFM of air blowing over it. I understand that the normal way of doing this is to size the condenser on load and then look up the matched coil in an applications guide.

    I need the resources to calculate and determine the opposite.

  • 18 years ago

    "I do not understand the statement that the correct evap coil compensates for the different quatities of refrigerant required between heating and cooling modes. Its a coil with X square feet of fin area and X CFM of air blowing over it. I understand that the normal way of doing this is to size the condenser on load and then look up the matched coil in an applications guide."

    The difference in volume of refrigerant charge required from heating to cooling mode is a function of the receiver, or accumulator, in the condenser.

    The matched evap coil (along with a TXV at the coil) allows for the proper flow and balance of refrigerant from condenser to evaporator. Excess refrigerant is stored in the accumulator. If the system is overcharged, you can introduce liquid refrigerant into the compressor. Compressors do not like liquid refrigerant. Scroll compressors are somewhat forgiving, piston compressors are not.

    You may get away with what you want to do in the short term, but you will pay for it in the short term with reduced efficiencies and possibly in the long term with pre-mature compressor failure.

    I still recommend that you post your question on HVAC-Talk.com.

    Best to you.

  • 18 years ago

    if you get me the model # and serial # of the indoor coil i can tell you if it matches up with the new hp condenser and i can tell you what seer it will be. normally as long as you change the expansion valve on the indoor coil to match the outdoor unit it will work fine. carrier and bryant two stage units still use one compressor for two stages. you can also make a r-22 coil a puron coil on carrier coils by just changing the valve. also get the brand of the indoor coil.