Software
Houzz Logo Print
swva_gw

Did I Overpay for heat pump

18 years ago

My heat pump and air handler bit the dust last week. My wife and I came home late Friday night to discover it was 20 degrees both outside and inside our home. I called our HVAC guy who had worked on our system before and he advised our original 31 year old carrier unit had died. I wouldn't be too upset if I had gotten 31 years out of the system but I have only lived in this home 2 years and so needless to say got the raw deal on this one.

Anyways after 3 hrs on Saturday he determined that we needed to replace both the heat pump and air handler. The heat pump was only 7 years old but apparently because of cross compatibility issues we had to replace both. He advised us that he could replace the system with a 3 ton 13 SEER Carrier for $4750. My wife and I were freezing and didn't think about getting quotes because this sounded fair and this guy had worked on our system probably 3 times in the last 2 years.

Anyways, long story short is I go into the basement on Tuesday after the HVAC guy had been working all day on the install and the equipment says PAYNE and not Carrier. When I confronted him about this he said Payne was made by Carrier and it was the same stuff but different packaging and a little cheaper for me. I did get a 10 yr warranty on the equipment and 2 years on labor.

However, after reading posts and opinions on this site about PAYNE I am really concerned that I made a big mistake because I was trying to get this done quickly. I now have a 3 ton Payne Heat Pump w/ Air Handler and Heat Strips 13 SEER and 7.7 HSPF and feel that $4750 should have bought me at least a comfort series Carrier model. Do you guys think I overpaid and if so how badly did I get the old bait and switch.

Comments (12)

  • 18 years ago

    Lesson learned. Model #s of the air handler and condenser must be written on the quote to avoid the "bait and switch".

    You have confusing info stating that the "heat pump and air handler bit the dust", "original 31 year old Carrier had died", "heat pump was only 7 years old".

    If the heat pump condenser (outside unit) was only 7 years old, you could have kept it and put in a new air handler if the indoor coil was the problem. It is OK to have a larger indoor coil but not the other way around. You would have gotten less than 13 SEER, a TXV would be needed for the indoor coil, and it would have taken some effort to match the new indoor coil. The warranty on the new air handler may have been voided without a new matching condenser. It is best to have a matching system especially for heat pumps.

    Payne is the lower tier of the Carrier brands. If you feel mis-guided, ask for an extended labor warranty (10 years) to match the parts warranty.

    What are the model numbers of the condenser and air handler?

    If you are worried about price, call another Carrier dealer and ask "How much for a Payne or Carrier heat pump and air handler model numbers XYZ?"

  • 18 years ago

    swva

    Payne is not the same as Carrier. It is low end builder type equipment sold more on price than quality. Depending on model, it does not have the features of a Carrier and is usually noisier. It appears your dealer has given you "the bait and switch". The price you paid is better than the equipment. An HSPF rating of 7.7 is very poor. You may have been better off trying to get a matching air handler if your 7 yr old outside HP condenser was in good working order. Of course I realize you were in an emergency/breakdown situation. Sorry for your troubles.

    IMO

    Here is a link that might be useful: Payne HVAC

  • 18 years ago

    "I did get a 10 yr warranty on the equipment and 2 years on labor."

    - Do you have the equipment warranty in writing? According to Payne's website, there is a 1 year parts warranty and a 5 year compressor warranty.

    The link provided by TD is incorrect. It is a link to a family HVAC business owned by the Paynes.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Payne

  • 18 years ago

    Thanks Gary

    Sorry swva for the incorrect link....

  • 18 years ago

    Payne is lower end but seems to be built ok. We replaced a Frazer Johnson that was installed 22 years ago with a Payne furnace. The payne seems to be ok. It was smaller in phyisical size. It is quite enough for dad. I question the cost for new boards when it fails. I have replaced several expensive Carrier PCB's in the last year that failed in only a few months.

  • 18 years ago

    Thanks for the input everybody I really appreciate it. I checked the manuals and found the following information the system is a PAYNE 13 SEER R-22, Single Phase Heat Pump Model # PH13. The air handler is a PF1M model and as I said the HSPF is 7.7. I know that the airhandler is 15kw, I do not know if this is referring to the heat strip power in the air handler or not. As I indicated in my previous post, I am not an expert hence the reason I made a rookie mistake by not getting 3 bids. But I trusted this guy as he had worked on my old system 3 times before, my house was cold and I was worried about freezing pipes and I thought the guy could do it fast and that even if it was a little bit higher it was worth it to get it done. Now I just don't know because I have seen posts were people are paying $5000 for Trane and York units. While I am sure they are the mid grade and not the $15k and up units, it still makes me believe my unit should have been about $3750 instead of $4750. If anyone has had a mid grade unit 3 ton put into an exisiting 2000 sq ft house let me know if I am crazy to think that I should have gotten a better system for the money. I would have glady paid a couple hundred more dollars if it meant I wasn't stuck with a builders grade piece of crap. I feel so stupid. By the way I'm in southern Virginia so it's not like the cost of living is high here and that is the reason the price was high. This is a rural area.

    I guess the old saying holds true, "Experience is a tough teacher because she gives you the test first and the lesson afterwards."

  • 18 years ago

    Hey guys I did some more research online and found prices for the components themselves. The Air Handler and Heat Pump cost $1704.30. I got a programmable dual fuel Carrier Thermostate which is $244.00. I also had the HVAC guy working on the system for 3 hrs on Saturday trying to fix it before he determined it would have to be replaced. I sat in the basement and watched him replace a burnt fuse, then the transformer and finally when we got to the relays that aren't made anymore in the Air Handler we knew the 31 yr old monster had died. I figure his time for that work on Saturday to be about $300. Therefore, I see that the total cost of the system and his work on saturday would have been $2248.30. That means he made $2501.70 labor to replace the system and he was here for about 8 hrs when he replaced it and that would equate to $312.71 per hour. Once again the more I look into this the more it seems too high. I mean I know labor is where the costs are but this just seems excessive to just replace the unit. He didn't even have to replace the pad outside, the old one was perfectly new, I don't know how much a concrete pad costs but you would think he would have reduced the cost because he didn't even replace it.

  • 18 years ago

    An installer typically marks-up equipment prices by 300% to cover overhead and other costs of doing business.

    Payne can be bought by anyone, Carrier has to be purchased through an authorized Carrier dealer. Is this guy an authorized Carrier dealer?

    What was written on the quote for the equipment? Was there even a written quote for the equipment? If there was no written quote, lesson learned for you.

    The 15 kw refers to the heat strips in the air handler - three 5 kw back-up electric strips.

    I think it's too late to worry about if and how much you overpaid. You were in a crisis and now have a new heat pump system.

    Next time have a back-up plan if the heat goes out - kerosene heater, propane heater, pellet stove, wood stove, etc.

    Relax and enjoy your new system.

    Don't worry, be happy.

  • 18 years ago

    An outdoor pad costs like $35.00- not a big deal

    Next time you go to the doctor, dentist, hairstylist- ask them to break down their bill for you.

    A quoted, flat rate price given by a professional HVAC co. is no different than any other professional service. If you went with a moonlighter or unqualified/unlicensed professional, shame on you-Caveat Emptor!

    Buyer remorse is a common feeling after a significant purchase, don't worry about it and move on.

  • 18 years ago

    "Tuesday after the HVAC guy had been working all day on the install and the equipment says PAYNE and not Carrier."

    Did he put on the quote Carrier or equal? If so, you really can't complain other than Payne isn't exactly equal.

    "Payne is not the same as Carrier. It is low end builder type equipment sold more on price than quality. "

    Carrier -> Bryant -> then Payne. All owned by Carrier.

    To the installer's defense, if you needed a system right away, it was probably in stock quicker at his local distributor, some Carrier units can take a few days if not weeks to deliver.

    Still overall, he probably saved no more than $500 to himself.

    Still you got a good price. Over here a furnace by itself direct replacement would be close to $3000. Whole system little over $6k with a leading brand.

  • 18 years ago

    If it makes you feel any better, I had a Payne outdoor unit installed in my home (2513 sq. ft. in Montgomery County, Maryland). They are fine units, but they aren't meant to be at the tier of a Carrier or Bryant; they are builder grade and that is obvious. Nonetheless, it is a heat pump that will serve you fine if you take care of it. For the outdoor unit alone I believe the quote was $3200. I no longer use this company by the way.

  • 15 years ago

    Ihave no idea about prices on heat pumps,but I just replaced my out door unit and I pay 2,255,00 on a payne brand,PH13NR036-K R-22 labor included I dont know if its a good price