Software
Houzz Logo Print
theinfluence

Old Heat pump died, need advice

17 years ago

Ok, we have had a Vexxar HVAC for 15 years. I know I know, no one has heard of it, we haven't either except its what came with the house. It finally died the other day and we have gotten a few quotes that seem pretty good for the work that will be done.

We currently have a split system but are wanting to move to a packaged unit for better and more even air flow. The unit we have now is a 3 ton and we have a 1500 sq ft house. The unit has never cooled or heated the house adequately and we have checked and rechecked the air ducts and they are all pretty much alright. There was the two at the end of the duct that weren't sealed properly but we have fixed that.

Our windows are in need of replacing and we were about to replace them but then the Unit died and we have to replace that first. Being a modular home it is not the most energy efficient, especially given the 15 years of settling the house has done.

So, my question is, would a 14 SEER 4 ton unit be good? We are going to have a new return put in as well as move the inlet to the middle of the ducts instead of coming in at one end(was suggested by multiple contractors).

And also, between a Rheem and Carrier, Lennox, Trane, Goodman, what would you suggest? The contractor said he would suggest the Rheem packaged units but not a Rheem Split System.

Comments (4)

  • 17 years ago

    What you want is not just comfort, but also the lowest possible long term cost of ownership. My suggestions:
    * Go for the highest SEER rating you can find/afford. There may be some state or electric utility incentives for a higher SEER unit. See your state's listing here: http://www.dsireusa.org/
    * Correct sizing is very important. An over-sized AC in a humid climate can create cold, clammy air - not comfortable for anyone. A two-level system (high/low output) can be one way to avoid this problem.
    * It may be more cost effective for you to increase attic insulation levels (an easy do it yourself project) and go with a 3-ton replacement unit. Ask your electric utility if they have an energy audit program. Window replacement is rarely cost effective in terms of energy savings.

  • 17 years ago

    Increasing attic insulation levels is not an option as it is a modular home we do not have an attic and there is no access to that area. And it is a blown insulation in the roof so we cannot make an access to better insulate it. We don't lose much through the roof I beleive, its just the windows, doors, things such as that. The windows in this house are old windows that use the pocket air insulation but over the years windows on the outside have cracked and broke and windows on the inside have broken so we have essentially just one pane of glass on most of the windows. The doors we have mostly fixed over the years.

    I will look into the incentives. And as for the climate, I live in NC which isn't really a humid climate. Our house is actually extremely dry which is why I was thinking an oversized unit wouldn't hurt. We would of course be putting in correct sized and possibly two returns to help with air flow.

    Does any of this sound reasonable?

  • 17 years ago

    3 1/2 or 4 ton sounds about right for older homes. With a modular home you don't have to much choice as far as making it "high efficient". You can go with Rheem for cost and it is not a bad unit. The Trane is the better unit but it does cost more. Just make sure the duct work is done right. Going to high on tonage,even in NC will make the room feel uncomfortable.

  • 17 years ago

    yeah, we are aware of that, but like I said, our house has always been super dry so I'm hoping that the over-humidification will make our house comfortable. The only reason we are leaning towards Rheem instead of Trane is everyone we have talked to said they charge more to service a Trane because they are harder to get parts for and a pain to work on. We want something dependable but not super expensive to work on if needed.

    Thanks for the advice everyone!

Sponsored
Buckeye Basements, Inc.
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars40 Reviews
Central Ohio's Basement Finishing ExpertsBest Of Houzz '13-'21