Software
Houzz Logo Print
cella_gw

Trane System - newbie question

17 years ago

We live in South Texas and have scheduled to have a new air conditioner/gas furnace installed. It is a 4 ton Trane, 15.5 seer unit.

4ttx5048 a 1000a outside

TUD080R9V4K - furnace

4txfh063 coil

We are being charged $7800. A vent is being relocated from the end of a long room over the garage to the middle of the room.

My questions are:

What is the "AHRI" website?

I can find the coil and the condenser listed together on the AHRI site, but not with the above furnace.

Does that mean that they are setting up with the wrong equipment?

Thanks for any light you can shed!

Comments (19)

  • 17 years ago

    cella

    AHRI is the certification directory for HVAC.

    Here is the AHRI Directory matching number.

    1422211 Active Systems XL15I TRANE 4TTX5048A1 4TXFH063AS3 *UD080R9V4 48000 12.50 15.50 1 RCU-A-CB 334

    It does not qualify for the Fed Govt HVAC tax credit of up to $1500. I would not want to leave that on the table.

    IMO

    Here is a link that might be useful: AHRI Directory

  • 17 years ago

    Thank you for finding that on the directory.

    Why would it not qualify? (I realize it isn't not the right minimums for seer/eer) I tried searching with the indoor coil by itself and no system set-up shows as qualifying, the same with the compressor only.

    Is the system junk? old? What is going on here?

  • 17 years ago

    cella

    junk? no.

    but the larger ton AC and HP condensers in the Trane line are light in EER and SEER which eliminates them from qualifying for the tax credit.

    and the furnace you listed is only 80% efficient.

    you have several options available.

    1.discuss with dealer about upgrading to a qualifying condenser either AC or HP. Tell your dealer you will not pay any higher cost. I don't like this suggestion though. Why? The only qualifying models that I saw used third party evap coils plus why should you jump through hoops because of Trane shortcomings.

    2.move up to a 95% eff furnace. This is probably a more reasonable option but again I would not pay any higher cost.

    3.drop Trane altogether and look at another brand.

    one final thought. if you stick with Trane, go with the Trane 803 stat but if you want the best dehumidification which you need for your area/climate, then go with Honeywell VisionPro IAQ stat.

    IMO
    Good Luck!

  • 17 years ago

    I agree with all the above. Trane is great equipment, but will not qualify for the tax credit with the 4 ton models throughout their product line.

    Is this an attic install? I can look up other possible qualifying systems for you, but need to know this to determine which coil to choose. Some coils are upflow/downflow only, some are horizontal for attic installations. It makes a differences in whether a system may qualify, because it can impact the SEER/EER rating.

  • 17 years ago

    I called and now have a different carrier dealer coming out to quote a Carrier Infinity. He said it is a 4 ton, 16 seer, variable, 2 stage heat
    $9700
    $1100 in rebates from Carrier
    $1500 tax credit
    comes to $7100 in cost

    I asked him to come out to verify the price. This would be a $700 savings.

    It is an attic install, laying down.

    Thank you both for the help!

  • 17 years ago

    for ryan

    furnace is upflow model if that helps.......

    TD

    and BTW, there are a great deal more qualifying options both Carrier and Bryant in four ton condensers both AC and HP.

    What about it Mr Trane?

  • 17 years ago

    Cella

    I really don't see any Carrier systems meeting your home's sizing needs that would qualify you for the tax credit. That said, don't let the dealer leave without providing you proof with an AHRI certificate/number proving the setup qualifies.

    Only Carrier setups I saw qualifying used third party coils and/or furnaces too big for your home. And these used the Infinity model condensers.

    When you get into the 4/5 ton size, seems like it's hard for many manufacturers to get the necessary ratings.

  • 17 years ago

    Too big as in tonnage? And third party coils are bad?

    We were told to look for either tin coated copper, or aluminum coils.

    The Trane system is to be an aluminum coil.

    We were told the tin coated or aluminum reduces leaks, which is what our current a/c suffered from.

    The Carrier guy should be here in 30 minutes.

    Tiger & Ryan - I am so grateful for the help. There isn't an easy way to know how to shop for an A/C!

  • 17 years ago

    Here is what Carrier quoted:
    RESIDENTIAL CHANGE OUT
    CARRIER, INFINITY, GAS FURNANCE, 4 TON 16.8 SEER
    ARI CERTIFIED NUMBER 1076891
    CONDENSER, CARRIER, INFINITY MOD 24ANA148, 16.8 SEER
    W/ R410A REF. (PURON),
    CARRIER, INFINITY, FURNACE, MOD 58CVA155
    EVAPORATIVE COIL, CARRIER. MOD CNPH6024ATA
    CARRIER, INFINITY CONTROL (W/ DEHUMIDIFICATION)

    UNIT QUALIFIES FOR FEDERAL TAX CREDIT OF $1500.00
    AND A CARRIER REBATE OF $ 1000.00
    TOTAL: $9,700.00
    REBATES AND CREDITS: $2,500.00
    TOTAL AFTER CREDITS AND REBATES: $7,350.00


    ONE INFINITY AIR PURIFIER MOD. GAPAA OR GAPAB $550.00
    CARRIER REBATE $100.00
    TOTAL AFTER CREDITS AND REBATES: $450.00


    Price Includes:
    Equipment and Labor
    Disposal of old equipment
    Electric breaker for condenser unit (if needed)
    One condenser slab (if needed)
    Add two supply ducts and one return duct to the upper rooms
    WARRANTY: 10 YRS PARTS 1YR LABOR.

    EXTENDED WARRANTY 10YRS LABOR AND PARTS $750.00

  • 17 years ago

    cella

    I don't want to confuse you. On the surface, it appears the Carrier is a great system. However, it solves one problem but creates another. I suspect the furnace is way oversized and dealer should have told you this.

    If this was my decision ,I would go back to Trane dealer and ask him to substitute the XV80 furnace for the XV95 without any difference in price. That gets you the tax credit without being oversized on heating. Here is the AHRI matching configuration.

    1422239 Active Systems XL15I TRANE 4TTX5048A1 4TXFH063AS3 *UH2C100A9V4 49000 12.00 15.00 1

    any other idea Ryan?

    IMO

  • 17 years ago

    I had a feeling they'd do what I feared they would above, as tiger pointed out. They're trying to quote you a furnace that is twice the size of the Trane--in Texas that's the last thing you need! And don't let them tell you the 2-stage operation will help out, because it's still probably too much on low as it is.

    I heard of some Trane distributors even giving a free upgrade to the XV95 to overcome their shortcomings in efficiency for the tax credit. You might be able to get them to give you the XV95 at no extra charge, but expect to pay for the additional PVC exhaust lines.

  • 17 years ago

    I love the suggestion and am ready to call the Trane guy. However, when I put in the #1422239, the AHRI site doesn't say that it is eligible for the rebate.

    Regarding the Carrier system, what is the problem with being over sized on heating? Is it similar to the problem with an oversized A/C not cycling long enough?

  • 17 years ago

    "Is it similar to the problem with an oversized A/C not cycling long enough?"

    That, and not having the ductwork to move that kind of airflow. While the Carrier dealer did propose adding extra supplies/one return, that won't likely be sufficient, and you don't want the short cycling.

  • 17 years ago

    "I heard of some Trane distributors even giving a free upgrade to the XV95 to overcome their shortcomings in efficiency for the tax credit. You might be able to get them to give you the XV95 at no extra charge, but expect to pay for the additional PVC exhaust lines."

    One of the Trane dealers did that for me, offered me an XV95 for the same price as an XV80. I had another quote from a different Trane dealer for an identical system, only with an XV80, and both quotes were within $100 of each other, so it really was a case of getting a free upgrade.

    As far as the PVC line (exhaust & intake for the furnace), I had a couple of salesmen tell me I really didn't need a new line running to the outside for intake of combustion air with 95% furnaces, I could use air from the basement just like the existing system did. The Trane salesman offering to substitue the XV95 for the XV80 was one of the ones who told me that, along with a Carrier salesman on one of their 95% furnaces.

    I insisted on having a new line run for both the exhaust and combustion air, and the Trane guy ended up throwing that in for free also. They used a single PVC vent pipe (coaxial/concentric design with one line inside the other) made for that purpose. It was a very neat solution, and with the rounded cover on the outside of the house, was not noticable at all. Maybe too much info, but something to be aware of if you're dealing with 95% furnaces.

  • 17 years ago

    I still can't find where using the xv95 qualifies me? I put in the 1422239 AHRI number and nothing comes up.

    The Trane guy has propsed going with a cheaper model for the outside unit - rather than XL15i, he suggests the c model. He said it was the same unit in every way, just not special top on the outside unit. Little bit lower seer, but may save almost as much as tax credit would.

    He is supposed to get back with me on the exact price.

    I looked at notes from when he had been at house and I see he had quoted an xr14 at $6462. To add in a variable speed it would be $7556.
    This would include Digital T-Stat and 10 years parts & labor.

  • 17 years ago

    Here is the latest offer from the Carrier guy:
    The original Carrier set-up proposed, but add in an air cleaner for free. He did exactly as Ryan predicted and said the 2 stage heat would be good.

    Or he proposed a Lennox system instead:
    Lennox, elite, gas furnance, 4 ton 16 seer
    AHRI certification number 3319349
    Condenser, Lennox, elite, mod xc16-048, 16 seer
    Lennox,dlsc, furnace, g60uhv60c-090
    Evaporative coil, adp. Mod lh49/60
    Lennox control (w/ dehumidification)

    Total: $7,500.00
    Rebates and credits: -$2,000.00
    Total after credits and rebates: $5,500.00

    Thanks for all of the help, and Steven that info is good to know. I wouldn't have thought you could have an exhaust/intake like that.

  • 17 years ago

    Don't consider the Carrier setup if your dealer wants to oversize the furnace almost double what you likely need. This would just cause you more problems

    The Lennox would be a good setup all things considered, though I do wish a Lennox coil could be used (ADP coil used to qualify for tax credit--not uncommon). What is the warranty provided on the equipment?

  • 17 years ago

    The warranty for the Lennox system is 10 years parts, 1 year labor. Lennox offers a 10 year parts & labor for $750.

  • 17 years ago

    cella

    not wild about the third party coil but it is what it is.
    I suggest you ask what the warranty is on the ADP coil.
    great pricing. you might ask what the upgrade price is to the G61v and G71 model furnaces. overall, the Lennox system is a much better balanced system both heating and cooling. You will require some type of air cleaner. too bad Carrier has a gaping hole in their product line-the Infinity is tops.

    IMO
    Good Luck!