Software
Houzz Logo Print
daffer

Deception in SEER designations?? Can it be??

18 years ago

It seems that many of the majors (I've looked at Trane, Carrier, and Lennox) use a detailed brochure for each of its model numbers, and designate "up to" in the SEER ratings-- but don't bother to show, even in fine print, what it is for the different tonnages. I've been comparing high-efficency 5-ton A/C and Heat Pump units for these manufacturers and no one has ever stopped to point out that the SEER ratings being tossed about and highlighted in the brochures are generally for the 3-ton units. For example, the 5-ton Lennox XC21 brochure talks all about the "up to 20.5" SEER. But that's for the 3-ton, not the 5-ton (which is 17.3 SEER).

Isn't this deceptive? And less-than-honorable for salespeople to make formal proposals (using just the general model number) without correcting the conclusions the consumer comes to based on literature showing only those selected SEER numbers- and in my example, quite a bit more favorable than what would be attained by the unit being quoted? Guess I know the answer (and the best defense which is buyer beware- and pay attention to the details).

Just curious as to experiences others may have had.

Comments (9)

  • 18 years ago

    I agree with you but we may be in the minority. Pretty common for a unit to be called a 21 SEER even if only 1 match out of hundreds hits that. Been going on for years. AHRI may be tightening up a bit, not sure what the changes are. But anyone shopping should look at the rating for the unit, coil and possibly furnace they are considering. At 5 ton, you will be far from the max SEER.

  • 18 years ago

    Baldloonie is right.
    If you don't oversize the condenser tonnage & use a digital adjustable setpoint room T-stat for controlling run-time during milder weather conditions, that will increase the Operating SEER Rating.

    Pay more attention to the EER.
    I am not at all high on the ultra high SEER Rated units & see a lot of side issues depending on your specific climate!
    The link will explain some of the factoids.- udarrell

    Here is a link that might be useful: SEER Payback

  • PRO
    18 years ago

    I always present ARI certified efficiencies in my proposals, and I arm my service techs with certified ratings in our price book for most common system combinations.

    Unfortunately, many less than honorable sales guys/service techs use the "up to" SEER instead. Sales literature from every manufacturer I've seen does the same stuff - so it is up to the contractor to make the effort - few are up for any more work than "necessary" it seems sometimes.

    At any rate, when replacing a 5 Ton system, I almost always recommend two-stage systems matched with variable speed furnaces/air handlers. This allows for maximum humidity control, air distribution and lowest energy costs (16 vs. 17 is largely insignificant if both are two-stage and variable speed).

    Depending on energy rates, also consider the heat pump versions as a Dual Fuel system can save a lot of moola - especially in a propane or oil house.

  • 18 years ago

    Sales literature is sales literature and will always present the most postivie info to be read quickly. The issue is when you get a proposal it should say 14 seer unit or whatever. If the proposal says 14 seer then the unit they are proposing should be 14 seer. If it is not then they are being dishonest. If they give you a proposal listing the model number but no seer rating then you can't say they lied. I would call it sneaky but they never said in writing what the seer for your unit would be.

  • 18 years ago

    SEER is a established under perfect lab-type fixed conditions.

    In the real world, there are climate differentials, ductwork & airflow differentials that can dump the quoted ARI certified SEER ratings into never land ratings.

    I.E.,oversizing the condenser tonnage resulting in excessive short cycle run-times will greatly degrade SEER Ratings.

    The unknown factor is, what EER & SEER is the system delivering under your variable conditions! - udarrell

    Here is a link that might be useful: The Contractor Responsibility to Customers

  • 18 years ago

    Hi Udarell-

    Thanks for both your posts-- and I've read the articles too!
    Your point about looking at the EERs is a good one.

    Given that the SEER (and other ratings) can be misleading by themselves in trying to draw specific conclusions, they should be useful for at least a comparative analysis of the same company's products. My point of view is that if a manufacturer publishes a figure in its literature for a given model, I believe it should also be shown for other tonnages of that specific model, not just the for the one that has the highest rating and "looks best" on paper.

    So 5-ton SEERs (I had to look some figures up on ARI Certificates) are lower than 3-ton ones for the same models. I think it's sneaky to mention only one-- and I don't see any good defense to why they exclude information. If I'm trying to compare SEERs or EERs for different models or different manufacturers, I cannot easily do so-- and I just want to have that info as one component in my decision-making process.

  • 18 years ago

    I absolutely agree with you, the contractor or sale person should present both the EER & the SEER ratings of all the tonnages that you are interested in.

    If they are going to sell the equipment they should present it accurately to the potential buyer.

    Neither EER nor SEER mean anything if everything else in the system is not right &/or if the install was not done properly. - udarrell

  • 18 years ago

    HVACsalesguy:

    You are to be commended for providing an ARI Certificate for the the systems that you sell. Not only is it professional because it backs up manufacturer's claims of efficiency and performance, but its good for sales and business. People like when they're shown proof instead of thinking that they're listening to a sales pitch.

    Best to you.

  • 18 years ago

    Hi Udarell,
    What is your opinion on heat recovery units on A/C-heat pumps in hot areas (like cent fl where I live)? I've used them for over 20 yrs now on 3 different houses, latest a new 1900 sq ft with 3.5 ton 13 SEER system. In every case I've had about a 2 amp reduction in compressor amperage. I've not been able to get a reliable means of gaging plenum/coil temp change as this seems to vary continuously as a system runs. However I'm sure lowering the compressor draw saves money in addition to the fact my hot water heater element doesn't come on much at all during the summer.
    Gary