Software
Houzz Logo Print
desperado121

HVAC challenged in Florida

16 years ago

Hello and here is my situation. We bought a house in Nov 2009. Everything checked out ok, by us and the inspector. We turned on the ac, it blew cold air. We turned on the heat, it blew hot air. So we had no idea there was an issue with the system. I will try and explain the best I can the stats, and what info I am looking for here.

I live in Jacksonville FL. The house is a wood frame Ranch style home built in 1983. I have only 2 bedroom windows facing east, and none facing west. The house was originally 1600sqft. In the mid to late 90s, two additions were added to the home making the total heated square footage to 1992. I have a low attic, and good thick fiberglass bat insulation. There are 3 returns in the home, I donâÂÂt know the duct size, but the filter sizes are two 20âÂÂ, and one 12âÂÂ. We noticed last month that our AC was running constant during the day, and into the evening. I called a local AC company and they came out and checked my system. This is what I have now:

a 20 year old Frigidaire 2.5 AC and a propane heat system (air handler ??).

The AC tech checked the coils in the air handler, and informed me that they were leaking. He then checked the outside unit, and told me it was low on Freon, but was otherwise ok. He informed me that replacing the coils would cost approx $1800. He also stated that it would be foolish to do so, because the system was really old and undersized for the home. He suggested a Trane 4 ton HP. Total out the door $6,800

I donâÂÂt know the model #âÂÂs, BTUâÂÂs, etcâ¦

Like every good shopper, I called different companies, and got more quotes.

1. 4 ton Trane HP, w/15kw heat strip, new 50 whip to AH, and new Copper and drain + thermostat. Warranty = 10 /5/2. $6,400

2. 4 ton Amana HP, same as above but with lifetime compressor warranty. $6, 200

3. 4 ton Goodman HP, Same as Amana, $6,000.

I have one more independent AC contractor coming our today to give me an estimate. The other 4 were large HVAC companies here in Jax.

One note: One of the Techs told me that the 65amp breaker running to my outside unit was over kill. what size should it be ????

Any info or help from this forum would be greatly appreciated.

Comments (5)

  • 16 years ago

    the capacity of your old unit is not what it was when new, keep that in mind. If it barely kept up when new, 20 yrs later could be a struggle. A jump to 4 ton seems extreme. Did the tech do a heat load to come up w/ "it's really undersized for the house"?

    I would expect a 4 ton cond unit to have a breaker between 40-50. It will vary w/ equip and efficiency. The size will be listed in the installers guide and generally on the cond unit itself.

  • 16 years ago

    You need to have the ManualJ done on your house. Going from 2.5 to 4 tons is a big leap, and 4 tons for 2000sqft seems like overkill from this distance.

    2ndly, do you really want to get rid of the propane furnace? What are your electric rates and cost of propane? I mean, you could use the propane as your backup heat source in a 'dual fuel' arrangement. You would then not need the heating strips for auxilliary heat.

  • 16 years ago

    Thanks for the info. I will be calling a different HVAC company today that does ManualJ.

  • 16 years ago

    With propane, it's an either or situation, when the temp drops to the switchover point. With heat strips, they can be staged. Propane is expensive and a pain in the butt, in my opinion. Not only that, but a dual fuel installation costs more.

    A modern heat pump should be able to heat that house in virtually any weather that Jacksonville is likely to see. I vote thumbs down on propane for this one.

  • 16 years ago

    des,
    I believe you called yesterday. I was in an attic.
    Do to my schedule, if you can wait a couple days, I will be able to see your home and then give you some good information.

    A manual J is important if there is a concern about the sizing of your air conditioning and heating system.

    Propane is really not needed in our area, but that can also be looked at too.