Software
Houzz Logo Print
leigh3

Timeless backsplash

14 years ago

We are looking at putting in granite or quartz countertops in our kitchen. . Our kitchen has natural cherry cabinets and our floor is sapele wood floor in cinnamon. It looks like a deep cherry. I call it black cherry. It turned out darker that I thought, but I love it. It looks very rich. We are still trying to decide on the perfect countertop and backlash. My question is what is considered a timeless backsplash material? I realize this is subjective, but if there was one backlash that is always in style what would it be. A few years ago we almost went with a tumbled stone, so glad we didn't. Subway tiles, glass? As for our countertops. We know we want granite or quartz, but not sure which way to go with color. Dark floors, and medium cabinets should the countertop be dark or light? We have a 6'x2' island that I would like to have a different color from the rest of the countertops. darker or light? It is all overwhelming. Any help will be appreciated.

Comments (16)

  • 14 years ago

    If you want something timeless and classic, black counters (absolute black granite, honed, or soapstone) with ivory subway tiles on the backsplash would be it. Butcher block for the island -- also classic and very practical. End grain would be very nice but more expensive than standard butcher block.

    But the right choice for your individual kitchen depends on so many particulars. You didn't mention how much natural light you have. This might influence your counter choice-- whether you want black or something lighter.

    When I was trying to decide, I took some black towels and set them on the counters to "mock-up" soapstone. Same with white towels. This really helped me make a decision.

  • 14 years ago

    I think subway tiles are timeless. Maybe in a herringbone/chevron pattern for interest? But then maybe it's not timeless...

  • 14 years ago

    I don't know that anything is exactly timeless.

    If you look at the 20th century and what was used as a backsplash material for the longest during that time, it appears that:

    1. the same material as the countertops
      2) 4x4 square ceramic tiles
      3) 4'' tall backsplash matching countertop with paint or wallpaper above

    were used for the greatest length of time. Subway tile is not timeless because it virtually disappeared from the 1920s to sometime in the 1990s.

    However, since subways have made a major return over the past decade, they are a classic Alternative --because they have had two major periods of use.

    I think that what will make a backsplash related to a particular time period is the design, and accent bands of glass tiles, framed areas behind the sink and range, insets of decorative tiles,--all these things are going to say "early 2000s".

    Ultimately, if you want to have something that looks "timeless" or at least classic, it also has to be a little boring or a little not in style. This is not necessarily a bad thing. But having something done well but clearly "of its period" is not a bad thing either. Not everything that is old fashioned or "dated" is automatically "ugly", not by a longshot.

  • 14 years ago

    Tarting up a kitchen is still a relatively new phenomenon. So anything that is particularly detailed or ornate is, to me, trendy.

    I opted for no backsplash (except stone behind my range, which the exposed back of my LR fpl chimney).

    I think Pal's fourth choice is the best. Square tiles were for so long the cheapest and most institutional choice, that i find it hard to warm up to them.

  • 14 years ago

    Our kitchen in 14'x26' We have a bank of windows at the 14' end. The windows face south. We also have a large keeping room off the kitchen. So we have plenty of natural light. I considered no backsplash except behind the stove and near the kitchen. Not sure the best way to do that and how it would do in resale. Appreciate all the help!

  • 14 years ago

    4x4 tiles set on the diagonal would be about as timeless as it gets. Or a 4" backsplash of the same material.

    Subways are far from "timeless" unless you live in a 1920's era house and are doing more of a "restoration" type kitchen than a modern interpretation of that vintage kitchen for the new millinia. Subways are just an old trend that is now a new trend. They just look fashion followingly wrong in so many home styles, like a MCM ranch. Much like a 45 year old woman with low cut jeans exposing her jeweled thong and tramp stamp. (Do what you loooove, it will all work out just fine. LOL)

  • 14 years ago

    4"x 4" (or 6"x 6") square ceramic tiles are timeless. They show up in every single generation of kitchen since tile was invented. :-)

  • 14 years ago

    I have cherry perimeter cabinets, a distressed creamy white island, med to dark walnut floors. My granite is Yellow River.
    I love, love, love, my backsplash. I am certain I spent more time agonizing over the backsplash than anything else. I finally decided on a handmade subway tile. I also had my heart set on a mural above the range. I have enclosed the link. I love it because it looks so elegant and cleans up so nicely.
    The first 3 photos are of the finished backsplash. If you keep going, you will come to pics of the ungrouted backsplash and pics of my cabinets and granite.
    Good Luck

    Here is a link that might be useful:

  • 14 years ago

    It might help to know what kind of style your house is? What do your other furnishings look like? Are you fussy or sleek, modern or traditional, colorful or neutral, fluffy or streamlined?

    In terms of color choices: I put yellow ceramic subway tile into my kitchen with cherry cabs and a darker wooden floor, for what it's worth, because this is a small house from 1921 and it seems appropriate to that era. Yellow is stunning with the cherry, as is green; I find white a little stark with it.

    Is there a color/texture direction you're currently veering in?

  • 14 years ago

    Leigh,

    Keep in mind, too, that adding or changing a backsplash is relatively easy, considering how much it can change the look.

    For resale, you can always put in what's hottest at the time.

  • 14 years ago

    I would also keep in mind that the use of separate finishes on the island is a current trend, so this will also be a key to when the kitchen was done. I don't want to discourage you from doing it, but just be aware that as a popular trend right now, it will have a fairly specific time period associated with it, in the future.

  • 14 years ago

    Another vote here for glass tile.

  • 14 years ago

    Perhaps it makes a huge difference where you live and how old the homes are. Subway tile didn't disappear from all of the old homes where I live. And yes, I do suppose the style of the house matters a lot - as much as the region where the home is. Maybe timeless is plain and "not timeless" is color or pattern. I think someone just posted a post about what is timeless...maybe I'll read it...

  • 14 years ago

    Tattooing: a timeless classic that has been around since pre-history. You can't possibly go wrong with choosing such a time honored means of self expression!

  • 14 years ago

    I don't mean that people took out subway tile. What I meant by disappeared that if you wanted to replace or repair subway tiles in an old house, virtually no one was manufacturing it any more. A lot of houses kept it because it was solidly installed, but it was "old fashioned" for decades.

  • 14 years ago

    Maybe this will help. Our home is similar to the Southernland Place design by Frank Betz. We live in the south. It is a traditional with a twist. We have many family antiques, with touches of the unexpected. In the kitchen above a 180 year old cabinet from my husband's family hangs a bright Costa Rican textile piece. I would describe our kitchen as contempory tuscany. White ware, crocks and iron chandeliers over the table and island. We are a comfortable-put-your-feet-up-on-the-coffee-table kind of people. Most of what we have has a story behind it. I do like the look of subway tiles, but wonder if that really works in a southern home. I really like the glass tile backsplash. My husband is concerned that it will be dated in 5 years. Most of the homes around here have the tumbled tiles backsplash. So would like to stay away from that. As for the counters considering black, but concerned it will make the kitchen too dark. My son had an idea of covering the counters with black wrapping paper and if we like it. May have to give it a try.

Sponsored
Haus Studio
Average rating: 4.8 out of 5 stars28 Reviews
Franklin County's Preferred Custom Cabinetry & Design Studio