Software
Houzz Logo Print
loganlady

Heat pump vs propane heat in higher elevations?

18 years ago

We have a manufactured house that currently has propane heat. We are looking into replacing it with a heat pump. The area we will be living at is 4700 elevation and does get very cold in the winter. Will the elevation have any effect on using the system? Our house is 1650 sq. feet.

Thanks!

Comments (4)

  • 18 years ago

    With furnaces (nat. gas at least), when elevation is higher than around 2000 ft., the input of the furnace (in BTU's) is derated. I have not heard anything about heat pumps being affected by elevation. I would ask your contractor to be sure, though. Hopefully someone can confirm what I've said here.

  • 18 years ago

    I'd consider a dual fuel system with both propane and heat pump. As ryan said, talk to your contractor about it. Unless you have great electric rates, the propane will supplement the heat pump when temps fall below efficient levels of electricity. You will get more btu for equal volume with propane over natural gas....but propane tends to fluctuate worse than oil prices in the winter. With current trends, I'd be fearful of a propane only system at that elevation. If your electric rates are a little high, stay away from heat strip backup.

  • 18 years ago

    Define very cold. It sounds like you may not be a candidate for a heat pump, unless you can afford a ground source heat pump. I replaced a propane furnace with an air source (convnentional) heat pump when propane hit $3.00/per gallon. But I am in Tennessee, and our electric rates are dirt cheap compared to most places.

    Check into ground source heat pumps, which is the more accurate name. Most people call them geothermal heat pumps. They extract heat from the ground and aren't bothered of affected by outside air temperatures.

    Beware, they aren't cheap, but with escalating energy prices, they are worth considering.

  • 18 years ago

    Thanks for your thoughts!! Low temperatures in Chino Valley, Az. run around 21 degrees in winter. We are having an AC/heating tech come out to check our place out next week. Propane costs out there are extremely high...hence the reason we are considering going the way we have it at our house we own now...with a heat pump. Not sure how much electricity is there. Anything to save some bucks in the wintertime, ya know? Does anyone have any other ideas for heating our place up?