Software
Houzz Logo Print
melinrk_gw

Cookware question...

16 years ago

Hi,

Well, after an exhaustive search for an old thread (I know they're having problems with the search), I have given up and posted a new one.

I am looking to purchase 2 pieces of cookware. I have all the right pots, pans, skillets, woks, etc.

1. I need a large, heavy duty, NOT non-stick skillet, pan, whatever you want to call it, so that I can fry, brown, etc. All-Clad? Places to buy that won't cost me a fortune? Buy the expensive one because the cheap one is really cheap? Suggestions?

2. Large heavy duty dutch oven that does not weigh 400 pounds. I have looked at the Le Creuset. I'm even (mostly) comfortable with paying the price. But I can't lift them! The lids themselves are so heavy. I can't even imagine how much they weigh with meat and veggies and the lid. I'm not a weakling, but I do have a bad back. Plus, I sometimes drop things. Can you even imagine the mess that would make if it fell? Any suggestions?

Any help at all would be appreciated.

Thanks.

Yes, yes...the kitchen's just about done. I am waiting for the window treatments to come in. They have come in wrong twice now...third time's the charm? THEN I will take and post final pictures.

Comments (22)

  • 16 years ago

    For the skillet, I recommend good old cast iron as it is best for browning. If you prefer a color, you can go with enamel cast iron such as Le Creuset. Lodge has good quality all cast iron.

    I'll be watching the dutch oven recommendations because I have the same problem. I have been using the slow cooker because it is easier and safer.

  • 16 years ago

    Perfect timing! I too have been in the market for something similar, and I too have looked into cast iron but Le Creuset etc are just way too heavy for me.

    I once purchased a non-seasoned iron flat grill from an Asian Bazar. It's lightweight and it does a better job heating than cast Aluminum pan. I've heard too often that cast iron pans must be really thick to offer any cooking advantage; but my thin and lightweight grill is perfect. I'd take a look at the Asian grocery stores looking for it.

    Re All Clad, not sure if they make Cast Iron cookware -- but I may be wrong.

    If you happen to find a solution anyplace else then do let me know!

    TIA

  • 16 years ago

    For the skillet I would spend the money on the All Clad. Get the all stainless so it can go in the dishwasher. They are an investment, but they last. I don't have any advice on the dutch oven since I would recommend the Le Creuset, which is what I use everyday. I don't consider them very heavy, but I am stronger than most. All Clad makes a stainless dutch oven. But I think cast iron is best. All cast iron will be heavy, there is no way around it.

  • 16 years ago

    Another vote here for an All-Clad skillet. I invested in one this fall after borrowing a one-skillet cookbook from the library written by the folks at Cook's Illustrated. They recommended the All-Clad stainless for all the dishes, including a skillet pizza recipe that starts on the stovetop and gets finished in the oven which has become a family favorite here.

    I found mine on sale at TJ Maxx - paid under $70 for it.

    I use my non-stick hard anodized set for a lot of my everyday cooking needs, but now would hate to be w/out the All-Clad skillet for many dishes.

    Got to agree that, to me, nothing beats an enameled cast iron Dutch oven. Staub is a brand whose quality, IMO, rivals LC. I have a couple of their pieces and love them. Significantly less expensive than LC.

  • 16 years ago

    Melinrk - I'll link below the thread that you may have been thinking of that discusses cookware. In that thread, I provided links to places that sell discounted All-Clad and Le Creuset "seconds" or "irregulars" (about half-way down the thread). But when I say "seconds" or "irregulars", I have to emphasize the pots and pans I've bought from these places have been excellent and either I cannot find any flaw, or the flaw is so miniscule as to be unimportant.

    I love my Le Creuset dutch oven! (LC calls it a "french oven") As to weight, I do find it's heavy when it's filled with my spaghetti sauce, chili, pot roast or whatever, but I am not carrying the pot around when it's filled. I either bring plates to the pot sitting on the stove, and ladle out the dish, or if it's something like pot roast or roast chicken, I take the meat out of the pot and place it on a carving board. For washing, I soak the dutch oven in my sink (love my single bowl sink with plenty of room to soak things, but that's a whole other thread LOL), and after a little soaking, it washes out so easily, so the weight doesn't bother me.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Thread about Favorite Cookware

  • 16 years ago

    If you're looking for good prices on efficient cookware, try a restaurant supply house. No fancy names, just good pans.

    Re a dutch oven, to do what you want it to do it has to be heavy. It's the mass of the iron that does it. If you're limited by arthritis or another debilitating condition, my best advice is to get the smallest one you can and cook in smaller batches. If you can't lift the Le Creuset one you were looking at just because it's heavy, and not because you are dealing with physical challenges, I suggest you get it anyway, and keep it on the counter, at least for awhile. Move it for cleaning. Pick it up and carry it across the kitchen whenever you think of it. Wash it every day or two. Fill it with water and carry it as far as you can. Set it down. Rest. Then carry it back to the sink and use the water for washing something. You'll build up your muscles! And it's more fun playing in your new kitchen than going to the gym! (Love my Le Creuset! After years I just am used to how heavy they are and think it's normal.)

  • 16 years ago

    For the frying pan, you can try a Cuisinart Multi-Clad Stainless Steel pan. Reviews suggest this is a good rival for All Clad, and it is significantly less expensive. I bought one last month and so far, I love it. Builds up fond much better than the non-stick ones and it's easy to clean. I love that it goes in the oven too.

    I have to second the idea that in order to get one piece of cookware that serves all the functions a Dutch Oven does, you're looking at a heavy piece. An alternative you might consider is cooking in multiple but smaller batches. Or you might do your browning in your frying pan, deglazed it to get the fond, then do any slow cooking in a glazed ceramic dish in the oven. Results in more dishes, but each individual dish is not as heavy as a full dutch oven.

  • 16 years ago

    My chef-friend and I were discussing this very topic two nights ago. I cook everything in my 3-quart All-Clad saute pan (all stainless) unless I'm cooking eggs or searing meat (that's when I use my cast iron). He prefers to cook everything in his cast iron (when he's not working). I also prefer to cook with the A-C because I can throw the pans in the dishwasher.

    If weight is an issue for you, you may want to go with the All-Clad. An even more economical way is to go to your local restaurant supplier and pick out a pan from there (they are light, not very expensive, and made to take a beating).

  • 16 years ago

    Because all the Le Creuset's are very heavy, you might look at Emile Henry flame top ceramics. They do everything dutch ovens do--stovetop cooking, baking, freezing, etc--but they weigh 30% less than enameled cast iron. They are as pricey as Le Creuset. Sur La Table sells them.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Sur La Table

  • 16 years ago

    Thanks everyone.

    I knew I could count on my GW friends for some help.

    Cook'S Illustrated just rated the 12-inch All-Clad fry pan their best. I was thinking about getting the "french skillet" with the higher sides, but they didn't like that nearly as much. I will have to really go take a look at both and then decide. Since I'm only getting 1, I need to determine which one will do the most.

    anne arbor - thanks for that suggestion. I will look into that brand.

    Yes, I am sure that I would get used to the heft of the Le Creuset, but it is really heavy, and I have a bad back, so I really want to avoid that if possible.

    Anyone else with suggestions? And suggestions on where to buy would be great too - if anyone has encountered a sale, etc.

    Thanks.

  • 16 years ago

    This is my opinion....don't flame me GW'ers:

    Well, I'm the odd one out. I'm not going to recommend All Clad to you. Nope, I never had a problem with it, but I did have a lot of experience selling it. I personally think that there are better pans out there that do not cost as much money. You are paying for the name. I'm not saying that they aren't nice pans, but I feel that they are overpriced for what you are getting. They are pretty, if that is important.

    I was lucky enough to find my favorite pans, brand new, at a consignment store, for a steal. They are by Sitram. They have a very heavy copper lined bottom, which is where you want the weight. It really isn't important to have heavy sides in a fry pan. They clean up without any trouble at all. I did a little looking on the web, and you can find them at different places, including Amazon. If you look there, you will see excellent reviews.

    This is the stuff that the students at Le Cordon Bleu use.

    As far as the stockpot and the weight issue..I don't carry my full stock pot around the kitchen. Once it is on the stove, it stays there while I cook, and I usually scoop the finished product from it while on the stove. So, if you can lift the Le Crueset when empty, maybe this could work for you. (I also have a Sitram stock pot--it is fabulous too).

    Here is a link that might be useful: Chowhound discussion about Sitram

  • 16 years ago

    As an alternative to the Le Creuset pot, you may want to try the Lodge cast iron dutch oven. We just bought one, it's sturdy, works great, comes in a variety of pretty colors, and we got ours for $60 (with free shipping) from Amazon instead of paying $200+ for the Le Creuset.

    Our dutch oven is new, but we've had other Lodge cast iron pots and pans for an age, and we've been very happy with their quality and performance-- I've got no reason to believe their dutch oven will perform any worse, and thus far in our limited experience with it, it hasn't disappointed!

    Unfortunately, my suggestion doesn't help with the weight issue-- I agree with the previous posters that a dutch oven needs a mass of cast iron to hold temperature evenly and work properly.

  • 16 years ago

    I agree somewhat with Beekeeperswife. I think All-Clad makes great pans, but you are also paying a lot for the name, their marketing, the "cachet" of All-Clad. A lot of people like the Sitram that Beekeeperswife recommended (the Sitram "Catering" line). I personally am not a fan of most disc-bottomed fry pans because I find the discs don't reach all the way to the edge so that you can get burning around the outside bottom circumference. YMMV. The only disc-bottomed pan I know that doesn't do that is the Demeyere Apollo or Atlantis lines, but they are very expensive.

    One issue I have with All-Clad fry pans is the handles, which I find uncomfortable, as do others on the Gardenweb who have reported the same thing. An All-Clad 12" fry pan is pretty heavy too. If I were to say which is more uncomfortable to work with "hand-wise" between my LC dutch oven and an All-Clad 12" fry pan, I'd say the All-Clad. The LC has two handles that fit nicely in my hand. Of course they're for different purposes, but you should really go to a store and see if you are OK with the All-Clad handles. And has already been mentioned, most people are not carrying around a filled dutch oven, but are leaving it on the stovetop and serving from there.

    All-Clad has come out with a new line sold exclusively at Williams-Sonoma. It's called the d5, and reportedly has much improved handles. I don't know anything else about it, but it's worth checking out.

    I also recommend you look at Cuisinart pans that Meangoose mentioned. Another great bargain find is the Tramontina TriPly line sold at Walmart. Cooks Illustrated has rated the Tramontina TriPly very highly. I'll link it below and you can read the 40+ ratings on the page which rave about it.

    All-Clad d5 at Williams-Sonoma

    Tramontina TriPly 12" Saute Pan

  • 16 years ago

    All - Clad skillets (12") are half off at Sur la Table right now ($89) - go online! Their private label cookware is on sale too. I have both but I definitely prefer All-Clad. It cleans up so much better! I actually need another skillet -- maybe I'll get one myself :). Btw, I LOVE my Le Creuset. I'm petite so I agree it's heavy but I couldn't live without it. I have my LC close to my stove to cut down on lifting.(My mom has had her LC for 45 years and it still looks good and performs beautifully.) Good luck with your search!

    Here is a link that might be useful: Sur la Table All-Clad Sale

  • 16 years ago

    I bought a Caphalon Tri-clad set recently and LOVE it!! It's about half the price of All-clad with all of the quality. The set I bought did not come with a large fry pan though. I am going to get the Tramontina 12" from Walmart. It is Tri ply and is very high quality. Quite a bargain too. That brand got excellent on-line reviews.

  • 16 years ago

    I love to cook, and have finally reached a point in life where I've been able to afford high quality cookware. Out of all the various cookware I have used over the years, cast iron is my favorite. Le Cruset is excellent, and is wonderful for simmering a pot of spaghetti sauce all day, but Lodge cast iron is my favorite for all other cast iron cooking. I have several Le Cruset pans, and I still revert to using the old fashioned Lodge cast iron most of the time. It is also very inexpensive considering the quality.

    The enamel interior of Le Cruset will discolor from certain sauces after awhile, but I haven't found that it hurts anything. I have also found that I use only a few favorite pieces and will most likely downsize and give my children the pieces that I seldom use, but they would be thrilled to have.

    I like my black seasoned Lodge cast iron better. I feel it fries a better crust on food than the Le Cruset and makes for more flavorful "brown bits." If you like cornbread, the Lodge cast iron makes it awesome. The Lodge people told me to bring the ingredients (if you have time) close to room teperature. While mixing up the batter, put your lightly greased cast iron pan in the oven while it is pre-heating. Then remove your pan from the oven and put the batter into the hot pan. It will cook slightly faster. It comes out SO good.

    I've had the All-Clad all stainless collection, and while it is good cookware, it's not as good as the All-Clad copper clad collection that they offer. I have a couple of saucepans for those times I need a non-reactive pan, and a small fry pan. The copper core pans that they offer are superior to the all stainless for temperature control and even heating, but oh my, the price tag is high.

    Most likely, you will end up with key pieces of cookware that are of differing materials. Purchase what you really want, even if it can only be one pan or pot at a time. Cast iron is heavy in comparison to some other cookware, but many of the Lodge frying pans come with an assist handle on the end opposite the handle. Really helps with moving it.

    Good luck with your decision.

    Sandy

  • 16 years ago

    I can vouch for both Cuisinart Multi-clad saute pan and Emile Henry Flametop dutch oven.

  • 16 years ago

    So...I had a little time yesterday and popped into Home Goods. Sure enough, they had the All-Clad 12-inch stainless fry pan. And it was $80.00.

    I was ready to buy it until I held it in my hand...you're right, the handle IS uncomfortable. Those ridges are annoying. I think it would be better with an assist handle, but alas, it doesn't have one. Plus, I think the angled sides are not what I want for this very all-purpose pan.

    Hmmm...looking into your other suggestions.

  • 16 years ago

    I love my All-Clad fry pan. I got it at TJ Maxx or Marshalls and it was definitely less there.

    Cast Iron is great - I use them for different purposes though. I also have a Calphalon that I use quite a bit but I don't think the heat is as even. It has a glass lid though which can be useful.

    For the dutch oven - I have a magnalite that I've had for 25 years. It does the job and it's much lighter than the heavy cast iron one that I got from my Mom.
    I'm not sure if you can find them though - the company has changed hands and I don't know if they still make decent ones..

  • 16 years ago

    If anyone lives (or visits) near Kittery, Maine there is a Le Creuset outlet there. They sells firsts and seconds.

  • 16 years ago

    Melinrk - I know! aren't the AC Stainless handles so bad?? Anyway, in addition to my recs in my prior post, I suggest you look at the Sur La Table house brand Tri-Ply pans. I don't have any, so can't vouch how they cook, but the last time I was in the store, I picked up (just to see) their 12" fry pan and thought the handles were really great--no All-Clad-ish v-shape, no edges, and weighted very well with the pan. From their appearance, they seemed very well made, very professional looking. And the 12" skillet is on sale right now for $60 (usually $90). So that's one more for you to check, and maybe someone on this forum has a Sur La Table pan and can tell you how they are (or go to the Cooking Forum too and ask them).

    Here is a link that might be useful: Sur La Table Tri-Ply Skillets

  • 16 years ago

    Oops, just saw Marg42's post above where she mentions the Sur La Table brand and says she likes the AC better. Oh well, it still may be worth a trip to Sur La Table just to see in any case, and compare it to the Walmart Tramontina TriPly.