Software
Houzz Logo Print
briannc_gw

Questions on 22year old A/C replacement

17 years ago

I live in NC and looking to replace an aging Carrier gas furnace & AC. The current unit has never given me trouble, but with the tax credits I think it's a good time to replace the system.

Our house is a Cape style about 1500sq.ft. and I would say pretty well insulated and such. We've thought of adding on a 200-300 sq. ft. room and I asked this to be included on the sized system. I've gotten three quotes. One was not worth consideration, and the other two were close and suggested similar Carrier equipment. Looking at other postings and info, I've pretty much decided on one contractor, but have a couple questions about what's proposed.

I also listed the following as dislike about the current system:

- temperature difference from upstairs to downstairs... would like this better consistency.

- it sometimes gets humid during the cooling season, but general not a big problem, so some extra dehumidification would be desired.

- it gets dry enough in Winter we need to run a 3 - 4 gallon/day humidifier almost continuously for a couple months

- when the current system is on, the airflow is noisy... would like it less noticeable

The system spec'd:

58MVB060 Infinity 96 gas furnace, variable speed, 2-stage

CNPHP4821 Coil

24APA530 Performance compressor

Programmable Edge Thermostat

My questions:

1. It's suggested this qualifies for the Tax credit... I've been to the AHRI site and I can't seem to sort it out. Is there an easy way to find out based on the models I've listed? With the credits and rebates, the systems comes out at about $5000 for equipment, installation (new lines, venting, condenser pad), haul-away.

2. It's suggested this system will give better temperature consistency upstairs and down, because with the variable speed air handler it will run longer and at lower speed and redistribute the air more. I can see how this would apply to heating because of the 2-stage furnace. But will I get this same benefit when cooling given the system is using a single-stage condenser. Or should I really be looking at a 2-stage condenser as well? That is, would a 2-stage condenser allow the fan to run longer at a lower speed to give better temperature consistency and quieter operation?

3. Will the system be able to dehumidify as the Carrier marketing material suggests when using a single stage condenser or would this work better as well with a 2 stage condenser. I should have asked for a price difference in moving up to the 2-stage condenser, but if a single stage will do, it's probably not worth asking.

4. I thought I'd hold off on a humidifier thinking the new system might improve the dry air in Winter, or is this just wishful thinking, and I should just consider getting a humidifier included now?

5. I asked if a air cleaner could be included as well, and he said this furnace comes with 4" filter, and the filters in my current air returns could be eliminated. I couldn't see anything on the carrier site that confirmed this.

I had also asked about a hybrid system, and he suggested this would add another $800+ to the cost. Given our Nat Gas is fairly cheap (roughly $1/therm, electric is .09/kwh) and we probably spend much more here on cooling than heating it didn't seem worth it. Does this sound reasonable?

Thanks for any help validating the suggested equipment.

Brian

Comments (11)

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    For temperature differences, it is true that the variable speed blower should help some, but the temp difference and the noise is very likely due the the ductwork being undersized. Did they say anything about that? That's step one to having a more efficient, better running system. Dehumidification would depend on whether the Edge thermidistat (which controls humidity) is going in. Better yet, the Infinity control is also a suitable thermostat (though more expensive) and has plenty of features for humidity control as well as diagnostics, etc. Ask your dealer about this. And that furnace I know either comes with or can be ordered with the 4" filter, so that sounds correct. On the humidifier question, it's probably not a bad idea if the house has as much outdoor (dry) air infiltration as you suggest. It can be controlled independently or (I believe) with some of Carrier's thermostats. Lastly, on the 2-stage condenser issue, that would require you stepping up to a 3 ton unit. If your ductwork is marginally sized for 2.5 tons, not a great idea, even though it would spend most time in low stage. I personally am not a huge proponent of 2-stage units though I do recognize the comfort advantages they can provide with longer runtimes. With the right controls and the correct size unit, a single stage condenser should do just fine.

    I would recommend getting another estimate if this is your only one for comparison unless you're completely comfortable with this company.

    Best of luck.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    brian

    Purchasing Carrier's top of line Infinity MVC furnace and pairing with an Edge Thermostat rather than the Infinity control is a mistake.

    because of NC moderate winters, you could consider the 80% Infinity furnace with a high eff qualifying heat pump. just a thought.

    good advice from Ryan.

    IMO

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Thanks, for the replies. I specifically asked about the existing duct work, and all three said it's fine. Actually the noise is probably due to our trying to compensate for the temperature differences between upstairs and down... we have to mostly close the downstairs vents to push enough air upstairs to get the temperature half-way decent. Perhaps with the VS unit running longer, we could open the downstairs vents more and eliminate that problem.

    It sounds like 2-stage is out simply because it would be too big for our house.

    Regarding thermostat, he indicated the programmable Edge should provide everything we need and from what I've read, it should include ability to control humidity. But you raise some good points. It sounds like I need to verify a thermidistat is being included... is this a separate sensor, or part of the thermostat itself and I just need to ensure I'm getting the right model (perhaps TP-PRH)?

    Regarding dryness from outside air infiltration... our house is pretty tight, but this could be coming from the windows... I'm also looking to replace them with more energy efficient vinyl replacements, so that may help that situation as well. I think I'll hold off on the humidifier until the HVAC and windows have been replaced, and then evaluate.

    Regarding tigerdune's comment about 80% furnace... if I recall the discussion regarding this proposal, the 96 was required to qualify for tax credit. If I were to opt for the hybrid, could this qualify based on the heat pump rating alone?

    Thanks, Brian

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Tigerdunes, I'm curious why you say the Edge thermostat is a mistake. By the way, the furnace proposed is the MVB versus MVC.

    I downloaded the user manuals for the two thermostats and it looks like the Edge does most of what the Infinity does, except for managing zones (which I don't/won't have) and remote access, which I won't use either.

    However, I don't see anything in the Edge manual about controlling fan speed, which is something I'm interested in.

    Is this one of the advantages of the Infinity control? Is there a big cost difference to move to the Infinity control?

    Bran

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    The MVB I believe is being phased out in favor of the MVC furnace; however, the extra heating stage of the 58MVC probably isn't worth the change in your moderate climate. Many times, especially in the 2.5 ton size, the heat pump's ratings when paired with the 80% furnace is adequate for the tax credit.

    Regarding the thermostat, I think the decision will be left up to you on. Both would work and control humidity (assuming you get the Edge TP-PRH), but as tiger suggested, the Infinity controller would be a nice control for this system. Here are a few reasons why: 1. control constant fan speed (you said that mattered to you), 2. intelligent humidity control (controlling blower speed--though I think the Edge can do this as well if configured properly), 3. diagnostics (even with the Performance series a/c), 4. system monitoring (static pressure, airflow, fault codes, etc.), and several other nice features. Upfront cost will likely be a determining factor of whether you want to upgrade to the Infinity control. I don't remember exactly, but I think the item cost alone for the Infinity control is around $300, give or take, depending on who is buying it.

    If you post your fuel/electric costs, tiger can probably make more suggestions on the dual fuel idea.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Both electric and Natural gas costs are pretty cheap where we live, at least for now (roughly $1/therm, electric is .09/kwh).

    Here's what I estimate we currently spend a year just on heating and cooling:
    $450-$500 Gas for heat
    $400 Electric for Cooling

    Of course both of these should drop with the more efficient system, and I'm also doing some other incremental improvements to the house like replacement of windows with more efficient Vinyl with low-E, glazed glass, etc.

    Thanks, Brian

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    As Tiger mentioned,
    You have infinity control boards in the system you are looking at.
    If you want the edge thermostat I would suggest looking into a carrier model that uses the basic control boards.
    There are some good systems that you can choose from and they will be a little less expensive in that case.

    What sets Bryant and Carrier apart is the systems that use the software written in Infinity/Evolution controller the system you are looking at uses the circuit boards that has Infinity/Evolution logic. So why bypass it for a standard operation by using an edge thermidistat?

    It's like getting a 4x4 truck then wanting to put tiny thin tires on it. Sure they will work but why purchase a 4x4 truck?

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    yep. just as classicdave stated.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    OK, I've upgraded to the Infinity controller.

    Any thoughts on whether the Hybrid system is worth it if I stay with the MVB furnace, given the cost information for my area.

    Thanks, Brian

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I'm still debating switching out the 24APA530 for a 25HPA30 to get a hybrid system. The extra cost would be $820, but I think it qualifies for another $100 off Carrier rebate. After looking around at costs using electric versus Natural gas, at our current rates I think it would currently be a wash, but I like the idea of being able to switch to mostly electric if gas prices escalate.

    But if the other occurs and electricity becomes more expensive, is it easy to control when the heat pump would be used versus the gas furnace? Is this done strictly through the "emergency heat", or is there a more general way tell the system I'd rather use gas than electric?

    Thanks again, Brian

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I found part of my answer in in some marketing text "Your dealer will select a balance point that tells your control when it's best to select electric heat and when it's time to switch to furnace operation. As utility rates in your area change, this balance point can be easily adjusted by your installing dealer."

    So, if I wanted to force my system to always use gas for heat, I assume it could be done by setting the balance point appropriately?

    Is it true changing this would always require a visit from my dealer?

    Thanks again, Brian