Software
Houzz Logo Print
blackchamois

Help! Countertops - Projection over cabinets

12 years ago

Hi folks!

I am doing a white shaker cabs (framed w/full overlay) and quartz (Caesarstone Raven) countertops. The counters will have a mitered edge with a 1.5" overhang.

My question is ... how far should the counters project past the cabinet boxes, as well as past the doors/drawer fronts?

There is some dispute between my cabinet maker and the countertop folks. Cabinet maker says I should have a 1" projection past the doors/drawer fronts, while the countertop folks are suggesting a "flush" appearance (not truly flush, but more like a 1/4" projection).

Does it depend on the look you're going for - traditional vs. contemporary?

Can you tell me what yours are?

Any suggestions or advice are appreciated!

Comments (13)

  • 12 years ago

    About 1.5" from the face frame, about .75" from the front of the drawer. Seems just right to me. I think it just personal choice.

  • 12 years ago

    My kitchen is very modern, and I wanted the counters flush with the fronts of the drawers and doors (for looks). The templater is here right now and he suggested using 1/8" for leeway, so that's what we'll do. I think it's just personal preference, depending on the style you're going for.

  • 12 years ago

    The reason for the overhang is to protect your cabinetry from drips. I would not go with a flush design. When I was looking they were specifying 25" counters (various places, kitchen and bath), leaving a fairly flush counter with 3/4" doors plus a 1/4" air gap on the kitchen cabinets. My old cabinets got ruined that way so I was on alert and knew that was not a good idea and poor design.

    I think an inch is good, not sure if the 1-1/2" they say is from the base or the door fronts. To me, the cabinet depth dimension used should include the doors/drawers, but that doesn't seem to be the way they look at it. I found 3/4" to look better with an overlay cabinet design so the top detail didn't get cut off. Not sure how critical that last 1/4" is.

    You also have to be careful what counter edge you choose so drips don't roll over and around, say, with a bullnose.

    This post was edited by snookums2 on Thu, Jan 2, 14 at 16:45

  • 12 years ago

    Mine projects 1/2" from the drawer front. I haven't had a dripping problem on my cabinets.

  • 12 years ago

    sjhockey - From what I've read sounds like the majority of contemporary kitchens have a more flush appearance like you are doing. Hope you'll post pics when your counters are in!

    snookums - I'm doing an eased edge.

    Thank you all! I think I would not be happy with 1" projection. I think I will go with either 1/4" or 1/2" from the drawer fronts. My kitchen won't be fully traditional nor fully contemporary, but maybe leans a little contemporary. (Is that transitional??? :))

    Thanks for the feedback!!

  • 12 years ago

    The reason I have an overhang is because once I didn't have an overhang and it was much harder to wipe the counters clean without getting food on the floor or in a drawer. It must be an age old habit, but I put my open hand or hold a paper towel under the counter edge and sweep crumbs over the edge into my hand/towel.. cant do it If the counter is really flush
    You seem to have to decided, but others who havent might actually go to the cabinent store and remind themselves how they wipe down their counters.

  • PRO
    12 years ago

    The amount of the overhang isn't nearly as important as its consistency.

    Most walls are wavy and out of square. Cabinets can't be just screwed to a cooked wall. Probably the biggest mistake I see is at stove openings. If the cabinets on each side aren't the same distance from the wall and the top overhang is the same, the reveal on each side when the stove is installed will always be off. Watch out at diswashers too, you don't want your dishwasher installed flush on each side yet crooked in the opening. This stuff usually doesn't become apparent until the appliances are installed. By then the cabinet and countertop installer's checks have cleared.

    I did a consult for a lady whose overhangs varied from 7/8" to 1 7/8". Yikes.

  • 12 years ago

    "If the cabinets on each side aren't the same distance from the wall and the top overhang is the same, the reveal on each side when the stove is installed will always be off. " As many times as they screwed the template up, I guess I can be glad that is the least of it.

    This happened with my install. One side projects beyond the range by about 1/2 inch. I asked about it and the installer gave the reason that the walls were uneven. But I thought that was why they did a template first!! Compared to the other template errors that were caught, I guess I can be glad that is the least of it.

    Most important is protecting the cabinetry from damage, imo. Unless you don't mind replacing them.

  • 12 years ago

    "If the cabinets on each side aren't the same distance from the wall and the top overhang is the same, the reveal on each side when the stove is installed will always be off."

    I just measured the distance from wall to edge of cab, and the cabs on either side of the range opening are exactly 24".

    Great reminders!

  • 12 years ago

    Another thing to consider is overall counter depth. You have no idea how much difference an inch will make. We lost an inch with our new counters and it took me years to stop shoving things into the back splash - I always felt like there should be just that bit more room.

  • 12 years ago

    idabean & daisychain - Thank you! Both great things for me to consider!

  • PRO
    12 years ago

    "If the cabinets on each side aren't the same distance from the wall and the top overhang is the same, the reveal on each side when the stove is installed will always be off. "

    "As many times as they screwed the template up, I guess I can be glad that is the least of it.
    This happened with my install. One side projects beyond the range by about 1/2 inch. I asked about it and the installer gave the reason that the walls were uneven. But I thought that was why they did a template first!! Compared to the other template errors that were caught, I guess I can be glad that is the least of it."

    The countertop templater is screwed by the cabinet guy. If he makes the countertop depth (wall to edge) the same on each side so the stove reveal is the same, the overhang will have to be off if the cabinets aren't the same distance to the wall. This may be quite noticeable when looking at the drawer/door fronts.

    If he makes the overhang the same so the doors and drawer fronts look right, the stove reveal is off.

  • 12 years ago

    Thing is, the counter on that side extends more over the cabinetry too. It seems the back could have been adjusted. I know they did shim out the cabinets. The last templater was very conscientious, so I'm not sure what the problem is. I wasn't there for the first except to hear he was very surly. Then found the measurements made no sense when I went to sign off. Next one had the sink wrong. Those had nothing to do with the other guy. Same happened to someone else I know, all the order details were wrong and the counter had to be pulled and redone. It's no wonder these things cost so much.