Software
Houzz Logo Print
cschmelz_gw

3 ground source geotherm quotes! Argh

16 years ago

So I would like to replace my Lennox Completeheat with a ground source geothermal system. I currently have a single completeheat boiler/water heater with 2 air handlers. Home is 4800 sq ft-about 60% above ground single level and 40% basement mostly below grade/no walkout.

Climate is eastern Washington state-typical winter day is lows of mid 20s, highs in low 30s and summer hot days run 3 weeks or so of 100-105dF and very dry and then mid 90s for the rest of the heat of summer.

First quote:

Guy comes out, looks at system, looks at air handlers and A/C units. Doesn't measure anything so clearly doesn't so a manual J. He quotes for 2 5 ton geothermal water-air units and a 3 to water to water for domestic. He also quotes a few odd things like 2 solar water heater panels to dump heat into the ground loop,etc.

His bid is $64k

Second quote:

Very professional team of 2 arrive from Econar dealer. They work together to measure every window, room, etc and do a manual J with a winter design temp of 0dF. They quote a 4 ton and a 3 ton Econar Vara 2 (2 stage units) with desuperheater on largest unit, electric storage tank and 90% efficient gas water heater for about $28k. They want me to bid my own excavation so they don't have to mark it up so add $3k, plus I'd need a couple air cleaners (say Aprilaire 5000 at $500 a piece self acquired) so let's say bid at $32k

Third quote:

Very professional young man does same as #2, measures each room, windows, etc. Looks at units. His manual-J is done for winter design temperature of 5dF. He quotes single 4 ton unit and tying together the air returns and such. All inclusive with air cleaner and excavation he quotes $28,000.

So first guy was a crook, no way I'm going with complex system designed based on no real data (no Manual-J)

but I have 2 different guys who claim to have done good, solid manual-J calculations and are apart by 3 tons or the addition of 75% more capacity!

Manual-J for the single 4 ton guy was BTU heating 91,293, cooling 39,691 and CFM cooling was 1549. I don't have the other guys numbers

House is 4800sq ft.

Thoughts?!?

Comment (1)