Software
Houzz Logo Print
icefox_gw

Heat pump Defrost Board and Sensor replacement

14 years ago

Our 9 year old Carrier 38ykc036 Heat pump has periodical tune-ups. The Defrost Board and Defrost Sensor were just replaced by our ARS company.

We found our unit frozen with up to 2'' frost while it was about 12 degrees outside (a sudden temperature drop in the night). The unit was heating, however we noticed a weird noise coming out of the unit before we discovered it was frozen up. We had a ''super furnace tune up'' done by Dial One 3 weeks prior this freezing problem. The maintenance guy didn�t even go outside to check the unit.

My worries are that the maintenance service could cause this board/sensor breakage. We had no problems with the heat pump before, it was cooling fine and heating fine. We do use it only about 3-4 months in the summer and about 1-2 months in the winter while we have an outdoor wood furnace. So this unit gets used max 6 months in an year.

It cost us $600 to get it fixed, not a good thing in a time of X-mass and in a time one of us being unemployed.

We had similar experience 5 years ago while a winter tune-up was done. The indoor circuit board stopped working 4-5 weeks after this tune-up.

The Heat pump and regular tune-ups were done by one company, this winter�s Super Tune-up was done by another company due to a special pricing offer.

I am wondering if it is possible that these boards were damaged during tune-up testing and broke after such a short time. I am also wondering if a Heat pump unit is under 10 years parts and labor warranty or what is actually covered. This was never spelled out black on white to us.

Thank you in advance for comment and/or help.

Comments (5)

  • 14 years ago

    No warranty unless specially purchased at time of install. No it's not the service guys fault so no freebie on the circuit board. I find it odd that the tech did not go outside and inspect the unit and test the defroster mode. Anyways watch out for tune up specials usually just a con to get in the door and sales pitch you. Also a word of advice stop being a victim, Everyone will always try to get your money it's just a fact of life.

  • 14 years ago

    Some people may disagree with me, but I think alot of preventative maintenance is a waste of money.

    I believe if its not broke don't fix it.

    I would rather not have people tinkering and possibly breaking/sabotoging my equipment when it is working fine. Its another story if it is broken or not working correctly.

    Homeowners should replace air filters often. I would recommend only calling for service for a heatpump/ac if the output temperature rise/drop is low or making weird noises. Its easy to test this. Just invest in a digital thermometer from ebay/amazon and stick into the vent when its been running a while.

  • 14 years ago

    icefox,

    Probably not the service guys fault. Not a lot he could have done that would have messed up the control board. You are most likely just like the rest of us and have bad luck. Now since the service guy did not go outside, the board could have been bad when he was there..... how would he know if he didn't test it.?

  • 14 years ago

    Routine maintenance and inspection and cleaning important, fiddling with electrical components freon charges in depth stuff not important unless there is a problem.

  • 14 years ago

    For these low priced visits many of our large competitors are offering, they aren't there to maintain but to see what they can sell.

    But I don't know of a way a good or bad visit could cause a board or sensor to fail. Which one was it? Unlikely both were bad. They probably replaced both rather than diagnosing the culprit. Often we find the wire to the thermostat broken by rubbing on something. A wire nut and some tape fixes that. Overall the Carrier defrost boards are rather reliable.