Software
Houzz Logo Print
hzdeleted_19693214

Members' Home Makeovers

18 years ago

Hi gang,

Just a note to let you know we've been keeping up with some of your makeovers -- and love them! Our producers have put together a slideshow that we've been featuring. I think you'll recognize a few names and pictures. ;)

Keep up the great work!

Tamara

GW Community Manager

Here is a link that might be useful: Members' Home Makeovers

Comments (76)

  • 18 years ago

    I wouldn't worry about Garden Web making money selling our photographs. Garden Web (more accurately iVillage) makes almost all their revenue (which is substantial) selling US to advertisers and market researchers. That is the reason they exist.

    iVillage wants to create the biggest audience they can, because audience size is what determines advertising revenue. They study the forums and see how they can use the content to attract more sponsors. When forum members offer amazing services like professional quality photoshopping and decorating advice--for FREE (because we're not allowed to "sell" anything here)--Garden Web goes nuts, of course! So they put our work together in a slide show, which of course flatters many but pisses off others, then they use this is as a marketing tool to get more participants, which in turns gets more advertisers and sponsors.

    Aside from the revenue they earn from selling ads, they also have contracts with market researchers. Market researchers study us the way entimologists study bugs. Every move we make. Every site we visit. How often we visit sites. Etc. Etc.

    And don't forget who owns iVillage--NBC. So iVillage gets free prime time ad space on NBC. And who owns NBC? General Electric--one of the biggest media conglomerates in the world.

    Internet marketing and advertising is a relatively new and wide open frontier. While sites like this are great for those of us with special interests and looking to connect with others, don't forget why they exist. They are not truly "free". It's particularly a problem when it comes to kids sites (neopets, webkins, all the sites advertised on kids commercials, cereal boxes, macaroni & cheese packaging, etc), where kids are routinely studied and exploited by advertisers. I know this because I study and do parent/professional education on the topic.

    I really enjoy the Garden Web sites. But I do find it scarey knowing what I do about internet marketing in general and the types of information researchers can gather from us when we participate. iVillage essentially acknowledges that we're up for sale when we visit here. Check out their privacy policy.

    Here is a link that might be useful: privacy policy

  • 18 years ago

    Well said tracieb and wonbyherwits! I really don't understand what the big deal is?

    tina

  • 18 years ago

    tracieb and wonbyherwits.....you spoke for me too.
    It made me a little uncomfortable that GW would be
    grilled as if on trial. We all know the score where
    the internet is concerned. We all have choices.

    This is a perfect time to thank you GW for making
    a place (and free to me!) where I can get the best
    free decorating advise anywhere and visit with such
    great people.

    I salute you .

  • 18 years ago

    I agree with the posters that say "who cares?" It does cost money to keep this forum running.

    If this forum (and the kitchen forum) went away I would be totally bummed. (Then again I might have more money in my savings account since I get too many ideas here. hmmmmmmmm.)

  • 18 years ago

    teeda - Thanks for explaining the GW hierarchy.
    I am more concerned about privacy than proprietary rights, for example if someone gained information to use for nefarious purposes.
    Optimistically, more users will give us access to new talent and more ideas.

  • 18 years ago

    after taking all this info into consideration ... i agree with everyone who has basically decided that the *positive* side of all this far outweighs the *negative* ...

    i am SOOOO happy there is such a place as this forum for me to visit ... & i LOVE *listening* to all of the talented, brilliant, patient & kind decorating gurus who reside here!

    i love spending time here with my imaginary friends; thanks to garden web .... love, hugs & kisses to all from your imaginary friend, who is always lurking nearby!(grin) phyl

  • 18 years ago

    I feel the positive side of having this a free site for all of us to visit and share ideas and learn from one another more than outweighs any negative side to it. I thank GW for allowing us this site and to freely post and share. I thank they for allowing me to meet so many creative, talented and caring members and for helping me learn and make my home more beautiful and more comfortable to live in.

  • 18 years ago

    They included some virtuals! How fun to see one of my curb appeals in an 'ad' !

    I think it's also just easier to claim the right to use any material published -- what overhead and a pib to manage otherwise if they want to compile an album or something. (What are they really going to do with these things, anyway :)

    Although the idea of just being able to post your project/house for these purposes and then delete later for privacy purposes is desirable. Sounds like a hosting site would take care of that in terms of GW reprinting things -- but anyone can take a pic of your pic and do what they please with it.

    One of my design teachers said that once something is published it's fair game as far as using ideas. Not sure exactly what that means, he was brief. Maybe that a professional cannot copy an overall 'room' and make money off of another's design, unless they have published it for all.

  • 18 years ago

    If you don't want your photographs used, watermark them.

  • 18 years ago

    IMO, GW should contact the original owner of the photo. Would it kill them to send out 9 emails? This would at least give the OP the option of saying no.

    With this forum, the photos posted are usually on a site the poster paid for, being hot linked. To me, this is the same as someone posting a link or thumbnail to a picture.

    It's a different ball game IMO if the photo is uploaded on one of the galleries, in the 1st post using GW's bandwidth.

    Most people will be flattered to have their photos posted in something like that, some won't be. The only way to know is to contact the OP of the photos to find out. Common courtesy.

    I believe that once you post something on a public forum it is up for grabs.
    One of the things I do is train performance dogs. I had posted a photo of my dog jumping over a bicycle on an agility dog forum. Months later I found that photo on a website on where the bicycles are sold and then later found it again on the website of the bike manufacturer.

    I have no clue how they got the photo. There are millions of people on line surfing and people clip photos all the time.

    If you do not want a photo clipped there are ways to do that. I have visited websites where you get a message when you try to copy the photos saying "this is the property of ___________" I believe you would need to have your own website to do this but I am not certain.

    Further I have written people private emails from work. I am in the medical field. I have found entire conversations that I had with people up in public forums!

    Everything that you do on line, including email can potentially become public. I am acutely aware of this so I am careful of anything I say to anyone or anything I post on line. That is just the reality of the internet.

    .. FWIW I was tickled to see my dog jumping over the bike on the other websites. If they make money off of that ..good for them.

    There's a post at MaximumPC's computer forum in the "Dog Pound" about how one MPC member had his photos taken from his web shots page, his markings were cropped out, then a very large computer internet store site posted them on ads for TV's and monitors. This site possibly sold lots of products using this guys photo. He was pissed to say the least. No one had asked his permission. Had they, he would have either sold the photos or let them use them asking for them to give him credit.

    If it was my photo of the dog jumping over the bike on the bike manufacturers site, I would have contacted them asking for credit at least. Would it kill them to mention who actually took the picture, especially since this one time they did not have to pay someone?

  • 18 years ago

    They're only linking our discussions to show other GW'ers what's going on in other areas on their site.

    What I wouldn't like is having my room or home clipped and posted by someone else on RateMySpace or something.

  • 18 years ago

    The poster there is one of our members too.

    I guess I'm just not gettin' the problem. Felt like a gold star to me :) They're only creating a slideshow from what's on our threads anyway and letting other members see it in other areas of this website to invite other members over to HD. They're not putting them on another site or tv or anything. Hey, I never see anything around the thread list anyway :)

    Maybe the concerns people have is what else they might be used for?

    How does a watermark help?

    Hmmm, maybe I should be concerned, too. !!??!!??

  • 18 years ago

    Oh squirrelheaven, I am glad to see that you chimed in since some of your work was used. Like I said above, I don't have a problem with it. (Then again, I am sure that they won't be posting my home. lol.)

    I do think it would have been nice for them to send you an email to say "thanks! We will be using your work and you are one of the reasons we get so much traffic."

  • 18 years ago

    I guess if I felt funny about posting my home (and I would), I wouldn't post it on a public forum, or would post it quickly for advice then delete the images.

    What else can people do? We need to see pics to offer any advice.

    I guess if they were to do something else with our stuff that made them a bunch of money -- using our thoughts, conversations, and images -- it would be aggravating and we should be entitled to give permissions and get royalties or something ;) -- but do you really think something like that's going to happen ??

    The slideshow seems to be in context, in my mind anyway :)

    Man, do I have a body of work out there!!

  • 18 years ago

    Everyone "there" knows what happened to a Shutterfly link I posted last year - it showed up on HGTV's forum. Through me for a loop, since I would never directly link someone's photos or album like that. If I wanted to reference something, I would have linked the thread to lead them. For me, that's what I think is the right thing to do.

    Squirrel, my understanding of watermarks is, someone can save the picture then remove the "layer" that is the watermark without much trouble. They just have to know how to do it.

    For me, it's not whether or not GW or anyone would be making money from my pictures. It's that they were used without asking first. Rules or not. After my link was posted I stopped for awhile but came back because I enjoy GW, but I won't be posting photos anymore.

  • 18 years ago

    Grabbing photos whether they're personal or public, discussing one forum on another forum ... it's part & parcel of life on the internet. Sometimes we learn the hard way what is or isn't a good idea. I'm always amazed at those "let's get to know each other" threads and the personal info and photos of family, especially young children that's shared. I participated in one on another forum and a few months later was shocked to see my photo included in another member's slideshow. BTW Squirrel, I did the same thing ... removed it within a couple days, but that was too late. There are people who "collect" photos and personal info for many different reasons. Be careful what you share!

  • 18 years ago

    Golly gee oh my do I collect photos! Most of them aren't sourced either, watermarks would be nice at the bottom! Although they are just used for my own reference library and enjoyment, like books and magazines.

    Allison -- you've been posting photos recently. Did something else happen and you are going to stop???

    There is no way around privacy/ownership issues though, is there?

  • 18 years ago

    For me, it's not whether or not GW or anyone would be making money from my pictures. It's that they were used without asking first. Rules or not. After my link was posted I stopped for awhile but came back because I enjoy GW, but I won't be posting photos anymore.

    Allison, but the same thing can happen on the other forum too. Someone could link them elsewhere or save them to their hard drive.

  • 18 years ago

    Do they post a lot of pics over on bahrr?

  • 18 years ago

    Squirrel, nothing happened recently. I just don't want my photos being used for ads or whatever.

    If someone saves a photo of mine to their hard drive, that's one thing. If they post it somewhere else, that's another. Yes, I do realize it could.....may have already been done, I just would never do it with something that wasn't mine and don't really understand those who think it's no big deal. But the world is a great place where we can all have our own opinions. ;)

  • 18 years ago

    I just don't see how you can stake a claim on something that's out there for the world to see. It's like posting a recipe. Do I have any rights to claim it as mine once I do? No! It's nice if someone gives me credit, but I'm not going to lose sleep over it. And I'll admit to sharing food photos on other boards. I give credit to the photographer, but I don't see anything wrong with sharing. I just won't post anything that I feel is too private or that I don't care for the whole world to see. I've made many of my albums on Smugmug private or password protected for that very reason.

  • 18 years ago

    I'd surely want to be asked about anything that's mine but, in this case, it's a public forum where I know I'm setting something free out there. I would be upset if a member or other party used something, though. But, in this case, this is just their site.

  • 18 years ago

    Because the photo was taken by me and it's my house. I don't loose sleep over it. Like I said, everyone has their own opinion. Doesn't make them right or wrong. I'm not going to argue, not my style.

  • 18 years ago

    Oh, sorry, wasn't trying to argue. I'm a brain picker :) Too much coffee maybe :)

  • 18 years ago

    LOL Sorry, my post was to Natal, not you. I was slow to get posted. I apologize for the misunderstanding.

  • 18 years ago

    Allsion, I wasn't arguing either. Just sharing my view. I know you've said in the past your husband didn't want you posting exterior shots. Perfectly understandable. Maybe it's best to not share at all.

  • 18 years ago

    Oh, ok -- I do need to zip these lips today!

    Sigh, so frustrating, cause it's just so much fun to share out here. I can't imagine what the way is to post pics though without losing privacy etc.

    For those who object, I'd send off a note to GW/Tamara and let them know as it affects our conversations and their site. Maybe they would consider asking permissions. Wouldn't stop the rest of the world though!

  • 18 years ago

    I had stopped posting here last week, until someone sent me a note about what took place/was deleted on this thread. Anyway, I've always enjoyed decorating and it's fun to share. Maybe I need to get banned so I'll stop coming over. ;)

  • 18 years ago

    Hmmm, I only opened this yesterday, missed the whole thing then!

  • 18 years ago

    I'm a Craigslist kind of girl and I sort out spam. No thanks, I don't need or want cheap pills nor any part of my body enlarged no matter how many millions of emails about it I get; I'm just funny that way! My major joy with decorating is getting a million dollar look on a shoestring budget. So I doubt I'm very interesting and I'm certainly not profitable to the money-grabber types. This chicken dun already been plucked!

  • 18 years ago

    Rest assured Tamara is reading these posts ;-)

    The TOS are quite clear IMO. Everyone should read it prior to agreeing to becoming a member of this site.

    Members can have opinions till the cows come home, but it doesn't change the TOS. It's a free site. If you don't like the TOS, don't join.

    Wanting to keep your pix private is certainly understandable. That's why many folks here simply don't post pix. But this IS the internet, remember. Try Googling your username and see how many times threads you have posted to pop up. Text, or pix, it's out there for anyone to do with as they please. The copyright police can't handle it all. May not be something you/I like, but thems the facts.

  • 18 years ago

    Squirrel, it just happened today. A couple posts were deleted. Typical. Email me if you like.

  • 18 years ago

    No, I just stopped posting because I was spending too much time here. Needed a break kinda thing. Not the first time I've taken one.

    T2G, true. I sent you an email earlier today. Did you receive?

    Oceanna, I enjoy meeting GW members like you - so much enthusiasm. You also have started many good threads in the Gallery. That's one reason it was my pleasure to send you the hummingbird prints.

  • 18 years ago

    I see, some unhappy posts, which I did see.

  • 18 years ago

    no Allison, I sure didn't. :(

  • 18 years ago

    Allison, will respond by pm.

    sheesh, this all sounds like spy talk :)

  • 18 years ago

    LOL Try going somewhere else..I sent you an email there too.

  • 18 years ago

    I don't see the big deal. This is a public web site. GW doesn't have to ask your permission to use the photos because when you signed up as a member of this board you gave them permission by checking the "I agree to the terms" box. If you don't like it, don't post anything you don't want someone else to potentially use.

  • 18 years ago

    They've changed the rules since Spike sold to iVillage/NBC. Meaning, a lot of us were here before this was in the rule.

  • 18 years ago

    $600M was it? Hmmm, can't find it! Guess that was deleted. But, wow, I sure hope Spike got a huge bundle too. Wouldn't that make you sick.

  • 18 years ago

    I am a long time Compuserve forum member. Compuserve offered web space for their forum users to post and share pictures long before the internet as it exists today. I had no problem with Compuserve's terms of service stating that they could use pictures uploaded to their servers. I just limited what I uploaded to their forum space.

    If Gardenweb provided the web space to upload pictures, I would feel the same way I did with Compuserve and treat it the same way. But these days I am paying for my own web space to post my pictures. I spend a lot of money and time taking photos, editing them, preparing my web pages and posting them on my web site. I do not feel that when I link to my web space I am giving permission for GW to use my pictures any way they like. If GardenWeb wants to use my pictures they should provide the free space to upload them and I can make the decision which pictures I am willing to give them permission to use.

    But I see I am in the minority. So I will simply not post pictures or link to any pictures on Gardenweb in the future. In fact, I doubt I will spend much time on Gardenweb forums in the future since I might be tempted to post links that can be mis-used.

  • 18 years ago

    Timely article from The Washington Post. If you feel your photos are exclusively yours it's probably a good idea to refrain from internet posting period! That would include GW, BAHRR, a blog, or anywhere else.

    Here is a link that might be useful: People doing double takes as Web photos nabbed for commercial use

  • 18 years ago

    natal,
    As the article says: "Understanding cases such as the Changs' requires a crash course in copyright law:

    Photographers (even amateur ones) automatically own the rights to their own work (even online). That means others can't use a photo without permission.

    So GardenWeb is violating copyright law unless they request permission to use the photos linked in messages. The main message in that article is that like music sharing, use of amateur photographers' photos without permission is stealing no matter who does it.

    AS I said - if GW (or BAHRR) provided web space to upload pictures, they could write their agreement to state that by uploading, users give permission to GW (or BAHRR) to use the pictures. But I still maintain that if I am only linking to my pictures hosted on web space that I pay for, that does not constitute permission for GW or anyone else to steal my photos.

    Pictures posted on my Blogger blog are a different matter - they may have something in their agreement that gives them permission. But I only post limited photos there.

    I need to investigate - there is a way for me to post pictures on my web site but block linking to them from outside sources. It is sort of a redirect and I could post a picture that is offensive or states that the picture was stolen that any link to my photos directs the link to.

    I tried to search for pictures that I have posted in other GW forums so that I could rename them on my server and thereby block them. How convenient that the GW search engine is screwed up right now - I could not locate a single message with photos though I know I have posted links in messages in the Building a House Forum and the Flooring Forum.

  • 18 years ago

    Blocking them won't do the trick, though, since people can capture the image from the screen (Print Screen functions).

    Well, if photographers and musicians are protected, I think those of us who also share an image we have created with photoshop would fall under the same category, rather than it just sharing a picture of our house or garden designs and ideas. Then again, with the ps'ing, its intended use and purpose is different, as we are choosing to share or publish our artistic ideas and not creating a piece of art to be sold in another way. An ID told our class that once a design is published it's fair game. I guess the net and forums are a kind of publishing -- you're putting it out there with no way of controlling who sees or uses it.

    Whoa. Another reason not to post your kids.

  • 18 years ago

    Whoa. Another reason not to post your kids.

    AMEN!!!

  • 18 years ago

    If I provide a link to my pictures (so they do not appear in the post but a link must be clicked to see them on the picture program I am using), does this fact keep them private since I am paying for space on two sites now that I am using? If someone wanted to use one of my pictures or quote me, I would appreciate an email asking me if it was OK.

    I really feel that for good Karma and to make members happy, GW should ask permission before using photos and people's names on here since I am sure many would happily say yes and those that say no, there are many more pictures to use. We have so many talented members on this wonderful decorating list that I love so much. I have learned so much from all of you and feel blessed to have found this site in January 2006.

  • 18 years ago

    OH for Christs sake do we have to make a big deal out of everything? If the person who's photos were used wants it deleted from the slide show I am sure all they have to do is request it. Most of the photos we have all seen before whether we responded or not so there is no sence of privacy here anyway.

    I am just upset that my threads have been deleted and I am no longer able to reference the advice I was given on my works in progress. Luckily I had saved some of my photo renditions gracefully contributed by other members.

    Can't we all just.....

    Don't worry

    **AND**

    Be happy

    Now if one of you turns out to be a psycho who suggested some colors and decorating ideas for me, got mad because I showed up on a slide show without their suggestions used, tracks me down from my profile email address, finds out where I live, comes to my house in the middle of the night, ties me up, repaints my walls in their colors and redecorates my house in their choices, then takes pictures of their after work, submits them to GW .... I might get upset. *maybe*

    My point? I thought it was nice. Maybe someone out there is a little jealous?? hmmmmmmm?

  • 18 years ago

    MsJay, I'm pretty sure I saved your curb appeal thread, if you're wanting that one. Let me know and I'll email or put it out on an ftp site for you to pick up.

  • 18 years ago

    Msjay, what posts are you looking for?
    need photoshop help too

    I'm pretty sure you made one the other day also, it can't be that far into the pages.

  • 18 years ago

    Even Adobe, maker of Photoshop, has been caught trying to take photographers' rights to their own photos away. In the EULA for their new online Photo Express, Adobe says:
    Use of Your Content. Adobe does not claim ownership of Your Content. However, with respect to Your Content that you submit or make available for inclusion on publicly accessible areas of the Services, you grant Adobe a worldwide, royalty-free, nonexclusive, perpetual, irrevocable, and fully sublicensable license to use, distribute, derive revenue or other remuneration from, reproduce, modify, adapt, publish, translate, publicly perform and publicly display such Content (in whole or in part) and to incorporate such Content into other Materials or works in any format or medium now known or later developed.

    But unlike the owners of this site, when called on it by users and technical experts, Adobe has chosen to revisit this issue. See their response to Ars Technica at the link below.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Adobe joins list of companies not reading own EULAs