Software
Houzz Logo Print
kerrygw

Wood Mode vs. Crown Point?

17 years ago

Has anyone compared (cost & quality) Wood Mode cabinets vs. Crown Point? We are in our early planning stages and I would just love to hear some other viewpoints. I am planning an arts & crafts inspired kitchen with stained cabinets and inset doors and both companies offer styles that we like. Any thoughts/experiences? Thanks!

Comments (25)

  • 17 years ago

    I looked into both - and got estimates from both - I personally think the quality of the Crown Point is superior - I think for my layout the cost was comparable

    We ended up w/Kennebec cabinetry which we are very pleased with.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Kennebec cabinetry

  • 17 years ago

    I don't know about the price differential but wanted to mention that initially, I was going to go with Wood Mode and am now happy with Brookhaven, the less expensive line from Wood Mode. If there were specific units only made by Wood Mode that I'd needed, my contractor would have had those cabinet boxes made and then gotten the correct doors/panels from Brookhaven to work with it.

    Jayne

  • 17 years ago

    I got estimates from both and Crown Point was cheaper. I was leery of not having anyone in town, though, to help me. I ended up going with a local company mainly b/c I could work with someone here. I think both lines are very pretty. Wood-Mode was much pricier than the Brookhaven line.

  • 17 years ago

    We are also considering the Brookhaven line, though in the door style I want I prefer the Wood Mode version (of course, what a surprise). We have a local company that does Wood Mode and Brookhaven and I've been happy with our initial discussions with them, but I must admit my head is turned with the loveliness of the Crown Point pictures I've seen. I do worry about the "non-local" aspect of it, especially with the measuring, even though we are relatively handy. Kennebec is absolutely lovely from what I've seen and I've been keeping that in mind as well. Thanks - I'd love to hear other experiences as well!

  • 17 years ago

    We (dh, dd, and I) love our Crown Point cabinets. We've had them for more than 4 years.

    My initial reaction was that "of course" I needed a pro to measure for the cabinets. But then when I thought about it I realized there was no need. We were redoing all the windows and removing a chimney and leveling floors and putting up new sheetrock after our cabinet order so there were going to be lots of fractions-of-inch changes in the kitchen. We found the crucial part was having the carpenters do an accurate job in following the kitchen plans and making everything work with the measurements of the cabinets ordered---the best placement of the windows, placement of electrical outlets so that they were centered properly, etc.

    I drew up detailed measurements of the floor and each wall using graph paper, ruler and pencil. I enjoyed the process because it helped ideas gel and helped inspire new ones. Our CP designer asked lots of questions in order to get an accurate picture of our space. She built in places where the cabinets could be scribed to exact measurements when the fit was crucial. Our carpenters did a great job making them fit our walls and wavey floors exactly. Everytime I got a new drawing from the kd I went back into our kitchen and remeasured and made pencil marks where cabinets would end. I'm sure I went way overboard but we had been burned by wrong measurements made by an architect when we started our whole house renovation. We fired him and dh and I had to remeasure and rework all the plans.

    I enjoyed the "long distance" relationship with our CP designer. I felt that communicating via email worked well for me since it gave an accurate record of all correspondence and decisions made. My designer was very quick to get back to me with input, ideas and/or answers to questions. It was one of the most satisying relationships I've had with a business ever.

  • 17 years ago

    Same here. The long distance relationship with our CP KD was fantastic. And it was really long distance, we were overseas at the time. Then continued after we returned home and began work in earnest. I never worried about them being so far away, there was no need to meet in person. Love our CP cabinets!

  • 17 years ago

    Got quotes from both WoodMode and Crown Point. Wood Mode was more expensive. We went with Crown Point and expect delivery early next month. They have been a dream to work with so far! We too are doing it long distance. I think even if they had ended up being more expensive than Wood Mode we would have still gone with CP.

  • 17 years ago

    I got quotes from CP and WoodMode as well. Woodmode was $8K higher. We went with CP and I could not be happier. My designer was close enough to come down and measure alongside my contractors. My contractors are good enough they'd have been able to do it on their own, but it was nice peace of mind to have the CP guy come down (probably about 2.5 hours of driving each way for him).

    My inlaws have Woodmode. They are nice cabinets (not inset, which I had my heart set on)... nothing at all wrong with them, not even a tiny flaw, but I would still go with CP given the choice to do it over again.

  • 17 years ago

    I just have to post that I'm so surprised because I thought Crown Point was one of the most expensive lines around. So nice to hear of all these great experiences.

  • 17 years ago

    I'm loving all the information - please keep it coming if there is more out there! Does CP charge for their design service? Were you able to look at a CP kitchen locally before you made your choice? Thanks!

  • 17 years ago

    I started thinking about our kitchen redo way back in the early 1990's. We were doing some work on dh's shop then so we were frequent visitors at local lumber yards (back before the mega stores were around) to look at windows and doors. I couldn't help checking out the kitchen displays. There was one kitchen in particular that I was drawn to but we just weren't ready to start a massive project. We finally started thinking seriously about redoing our kitchen in 2004 and I found out about CP from a family member. We were close enough (1 1/2 hours away) that we were able to go visit CP to see the product first hand. We were hooked immediately. After I ordered cabinets I came across an old 1990's file labeled "kitchens." It contained just one pamphlet in it---the one for the kitchen I loved at the lumber yard. It was Crown Point! They must have sold through local retailers back then. I'm 90% certain it was the same company---unless I read the name on the pamphlet wrong. I wish I wasn't having an unusual decluttering fit and kept it.

    CP does not charge for its design services.

  • 17 years ago

    I have to admit, the cabinet companies not charging for their services at all surprises me to some degree - I understand why they don't but it still seems unusual when there seem to be charges for everything these days!! Zelmar - it just means you were meant to have that kitchen! How funny!

  • 17 years ago

    zelmar, your memory seems right on. I'm almost certain I read somewhere that Crown Point used to sell through lumber yards.

    I salute you brave souls who took the leap of faith to work with a company that wasn't local to you. I'm not aware of any other cabinet companies that are able to do business this way as successfully as Crown Point does.

    I'm only about 2 hours away from Crown Point, so my KD was able to come here to measure and has been down two other time to meet with my contractor and bring samples. I think she told me she will go as far away as Connecticut to meet with a client. Or maybe it was New York? Not sure, sorry.

    Even as close as I am, at first I was nervous about not having a kitchen designer minutes away to "hold my hand" through the renovation process. However, once I started talking on the phone with the designer (a very lovely woman named Carole Stevens), most of my anxieties vanished. Unlike the 2 local KDs I had consulted with, she seemed to grasp so quickly my vision for my new space. Working with her over the phone and through email has been surprisingly easy. She responds so quickly to all my various concerns and questions. In general, Crown Point's customer service and exacting attention to detail is something I have very seldom seen.

    I have no idea how big of a company they are, but working with them I feel like I'm working with a small, family-run business. One of the owners called me to thank me for my business after I signed my contract. When I asked my designer what would happen if when my cabinets arrived there was something that was the wrong size or damaged. After reading some of the horror stories on this forum, I was very worried about possibly long delays. She told me that in her long career she could only remember that happening twice, and she had simply gone out to the workshop floor and had a replacement made to be shipped out within the week.

    Concerning pricing, I got estimates from 2 different kitchen showrooms -- one for Cabico cabinets, the other for Plain & Fancy -- and two small cabinet shops. Crown Point's quote came in less than Plain & Fancy, almost exactly the same as one of the small shops and a little higher than the other small shop. Cabico's quote was significantly less than Crown Point's but the quality, although very nice, wasn't as high, and I didn't mesh well with the KD. I was able to get a nice discount because I ordered my cabinets in December when their business is slower.

    Sorry to be so long-winded. I don't even have my cabinets yet! But I wanted to share my experience of what a pleasant experience working with Crown Point has been.

    Best of luck with your project!

    Erika

  • 17 years ago

    I'm another Crownpoint fan. I worked with the same designer as Erika and I could not have been happier. The cabinet planning phase was one of the highlights of our project. I found my Crownpoint designer to be extremely responsive and to truly listen and understand what I wanted. She didn't try to upsell me into expensive add-ons that I didn't want, but at the same time she figured out how to do everything that I did want. I had no problem with the long-distance aspect.

    Our cabinets have been in for 9 months now. The quality is beautiful and we are 100% happy with them.

    I have to admit, I did not price shop. I've been an Old House Journal reader for years and have drooled over the Crownpoint ads every month. When I received their estimate it worked in our budget, so we didn't shop around any further.

  • 17 years ago

    I don't think you can go wrong with either. That said I did 2 kitchens in 5 yrs and saw a lot of cabs, KD's and most impressed with CP's, quality, finish, choices, the KD's, and the way they treat the customer. If it were within my budget I would deal with them in a second. Evey good comment above about CP above is true.

  • 17 years ago

    I guess I'm one of those "two" people that CrownPoint has had a problem with the order. They made a huge mistake on our corner cabinet, and one of our trash pull outs was wrong. I can't even remember the details. Why? Because they were so terrific about taking care of it. They gave us a choice, they would either replace the entire corner cabinet (which was huge because it was a really custom, odd-sized piece that included not only the corner, but the cabinet for the farm sink), or they could send my husband (a weekend carpenter and furniture maker) everything he needed to just fix the cabinet himself. We opted for the latter, but they were ready to replace $2K cabinet with no questions asked.

    They did have to send a new trash pull out. Took less than two weeks.

    Great company.

    Ivette

  • 17 years ago

    Our Wood-Mode cabinets will be installed next week so I'll get back to you when I have a better idea of my opinion since seeing them in the showroom. From what everyone is saying about Crown Point, I'm kind of wishing I had looked at those, but hopefully we'll be very happy with Wood-Mode. I have to say though that I think Wood Mode is a bit expensive in retrospect, and maybe we also should have considered their other line Brook Haven, which people have had good things to say about, but there was less room for customization.

  • 17 years ago

    I have to say, so far I'm impressed with Crown Point's customer service - I got an email today from the president saying thanks for contacting them and stating specific things about my kitchen (that I mentioned in my original email) that he thought they could work well with. And obviously of course saying that a designer would contact me today. May be a bit of a form letter, but it didn't feel that way and regardless it was a nice touch.

    It's terrific to hear all of the good experiences with both Wood Mode/Brookhaven and Crown Point, since I'm sure either one will be fantastic. I really appreciate everyone's input!

  • 17 years ago

    If/when we get our deposit situation with an inferior company straightened out, we plan to go with Crown Point. They are having an amazing promotion right now. They were actually 6K less than another place I got a bid from and 2K less than a large custom line a lot of KD's around here carry. I was really surprised by just how reasonable it ended up being. When we initially had things priced out by them in Sept, it was way out of reach.. thanks to the promotions, it actually is very, very reasonable.

  • 17 years ago

    what is the promo. crown point is having as they ere out of reach for us before?

  • 17 years ago

    They had some slots at 15% off.. some at 20% off... for winter orders. Prior to that it was around 7% off. I'm not sure what they have available, now, but they are looking to keep their workers busy, so they've opted to give some pretty deep discounts. So far, the process has been very smooth.

  • 15 years ago

    Crown Point THE BEST!

    I had a horrible experience having cabinets custom made by a local highly respected cabinet maker. They were AWFUL! They were measured wrong and to save money he spray painted them himself. I wept for days. We DID get our money back and the cabinet maker went out of business as he should have!

    We called Crown Point, they were CHEAPER! The measurements were flawless and they worked with me the get the right onyx finish.

    Their service was superb- their attention to detail drove me nuts at time- but oh! what a spectacular job!

    They will work with you if you want a more contemporary look as I did or more traditional styles.

    I would use them again in a heartbeat!

    I think their prices are reasonable and their cabinets are top notch. My installer said that they were better made than the Poggenpals he installed.

    If they are a bit more money than the others you are considering- spend the extra. I cannot recommend them highly enough!

  • 15 years ago

    I have priced Crown Point and Woodmode/Brookhaven (among others). Crown Point was a bit cheaper than Brookhaven and much better quality. 1" solid wood doors, wood boxes, hand painted finish for the same price as the spray finish. I was told by the Woodmode supplier that Woodmode would be 30% more in the layout I wanted.

    That being said, the local Mass cabinetmakers (small shops) have been much better priced than Crown Point, but a little lesser quality (eg, maple plywood boxes). On the other hand (not relevant to OP), if one prefers a spray finish, the local custom folks offer more paint colors (usu BM or SW) than Crown Point or Brookhaven. Because the other cabmakers are closer to me, I can stop in to their workshops and see my cabinets in various stages of building. A great boon, no doubt!

    Still, unsure what I'm going to do...But hope this helps you :)

  • 15 years ago

    I have used both Crown Point and Wood-Mode for projects and they both make good solid cabinets. Crown Point is a smaller company than Woodmode. I have now found a small company in Chicago that has earned my business, "Best Cabinets".

    Best Cabinets is a small custom manufacturer of custom cabinets and custom furniture. They own their own Sawmill and Kilns and have very good quality. They Bookmatch and sequece match their lumber for better quality than many of the larger companies. Also, the construction of their cabinets is supurb. There standard drawer boxes are Solid Maple Dovetailed and they install a Walnut Face to their drawer box which looks awesome. They build Inset, Framed and Frameless Cabinets. All 3/4" Maple Plywood Construction for their cases. They will custom match any paint or stain color for "no extra charge". They will "measure" and or "install" anywhere in the USA. They hand deliver all their cabinets in a blanket wrapped truck anywhere in the US. I like their hinges better than "Crown Points" and the Quality of the cabinets seems better than Wood-Mode. They are also great at servicing clients both locally and out of state.

    They have award winning designers and one of their kitchens was just selected for the front cover of a National Magazine, "Signature Kitchens & Baths".(Winter 2011)

    Here is a link that might be useful: custom kitchens