Software
Houzz Logo Print
lisab_2007

Countertop material for old house

19 years ago

We are at the point with a kitchen remodelling where we need to pick out countertop material. Our home was built in 1928 and to the best of our research is something between french normandy and english cotswald. Very steep roof line with a slate roof, copper gutters, stucco- like exterior ( but not really, it's much more substantial and a pewtery color) with stone accents. Inside there are lovely mouldings that are either walnut or cherry, the stain being very warm without being too dark. There is also some woodwork that has been painted white. There are peggeg wide planked floors in most of the house and a thinner herringboned pattern wood floor in the dining room. The front railing has spindles that are iron with a stained railing. The current kitchen put in in the 80's is white with a terra cotta floor...too cute and country for the home that really has a more european flair. So anyway, we are going with stained cabinetry and an 18" limestone looking tile floor. In the butler's pantry, the stain is a deeper brown on cherry to match the original Chrysler&Koppin refrigerator, the countertops will be limestone. In the kitchen the island will be this same deep stain and the perimeter cabinetry will be a medium stained cherry with a black glaze and fly-specks. We are having difficulty choosing a countertop material. Island and perimeter the same? Perimeter different? The granites all seem too 'modern' for this warm, worn house. Any suggestions? This may seem like a 'kitchen forum' question, but I thought there might be more folks on this site who are sensitive to taking the style and age of the home into consideration when restoring. Am I being overly thoughtful about a kitchen work surface? By the way, we our 3 kids and their many friends are in the kitchen a lot, and I cook a lot, too. Thanks for input. Lisa

Comments (3)

  • 19 years ago

    Materials that would be appropriate to the period would be tiles (look up cottages for tile style), wood (joined planks rather than butcher-block) soapstone, marble, slate, copper, zinc. Which would depend also on your choice of cabinet style.

    Any material which has or will aquire a patina will probably look appropriate. I personally like the look of different counter materials. You than have the option of better fitting the material to its purpose.

  • 19 years ago

    Soapstone and butcherblock in combination come to mind. BB is made in many different woods to coordinate or contrast with the cabinets and floors. Soapstone's color variation is more limited, but I think you'd want to stay within the gray/black range (greenish and blue-ish soapstones are encountered)
    Casey

  • 19 years ago

    Soapstone would be nice and I think also a good choice for your lifestyle. We recently renovated our 1920s house and almost went with a beautiful granite called Nordic Black Antique. It looked a lot like soapstone -- black with some white veining, with a satin finish rather than a glossy polish. But we ended up with Bianco Romano granite -- looks quite a bit like marble but w/o the porosity worries.

    I think mixing countertop materials is a nice touch, and in your house might look like the kitchen had sort of grown organically over time. The top of our island is walnut planks, finished with Waterlox -- we have a sink on it and have had no worries at all with the water. I would suggest distressing it a bit before you seal it, though. Those first couple of scratches made us wince for days but now we don't baby it too much.

    There is a thread over in the Kitchens forum called "Farmhouse kitchen fans" that you may find interesting.