Software
Houzz Logo Print
luvnola

1st slightly major problem...Any suggestions?

18 years ago

The long and short is I am replacing two windows and a door (from sliding glass to patio door). Keep in mind my DH and I (o.k. mostly me) have subbed the work and are acting as semi GC's. At any rate, their is a 2 inch difference in the width of the windows. The smaller was to go over the sink the other behind the bench seating. My DH got confused and had the installer put the larger window over the sink. At first this doesn't sound like a big deal EXCEPT I will have cabinets flanking both sides of the window. As it stands now the cabinets to the left will butt right next to the window and on the right there will be appoximately 5-6 inches b/w cabinet and window.

My options:

1) Have the intaller redo the windows and go a good bit over budget (we are on an EXTREMELY TIGHT BUDGET).

2) To the left of the problem window there will be a 30in wall cabinet for double ovens followed by a 21in upper. On the right there will be a 25inch corner cabinet with an 18 inch next to it. My cabinets are Ikea, so could I flip the 18in with the 21inch?

3)Even if I flipped the 18in with the 21in, my sink and faucet will be off center from the window about 2 inches. Can I live with this? My gut says that two inches will be the death of me!

Thanks for any help or suggestions you can offer!!

Comments (9)

  • 18 years ago

    Add a revashelf filler pullout to one side and even it up?

    Here is a link that might be useful: Filler pull out

  • 18 years ago

    I think your only real option to be satisfied with your kitchen is the redo of the windows. #2 sounds and will look awful. #3 is what I have had since we moved into this house 9 years ago. I noticed the sink and faucet being off center, but in 9 years, no one else did, not ever the KD until he come and measured for the cabinets. In the scheme of things, being over-budget for the windows may seem much cheaper then living with a glaring mistake for years( It will probably be glaring only to you).

  • 18 years ago

    I'll let the Ikea folks handle the cabinet swap question, but I expect that it's not a problem.

    As for the 2in, MANY people have their sinks and faucets not quite centered (ours wasn't before the reno, by about that much). Most people don't really notice it. Chances are only you and your DH will. Another "solution" to this, depending on how far along you are in your decisions/purchases, is to switch to a D-shaped sink with a faucet in the corner. That would de-emphasize the fact that they are slightly off-center.

  • 18 years ago

    Maybe get a slightly smaller sink so that it can be centered with the window? This likely means that the sink will be somewhat off center with the sink cabinet but I don't think that would be as disconcerting to the eye as being off center with the window.

    And, you might check to see what tolerances you have in the sink cabinet with the sink that you have. There might be enough room to fudge the sink over enough to center it with the window.

    Depending on how complete the window install is (moulding, exterior siding?), it might not be a huge deal to switch out the windows...esp. since you'll be putting the smaller window in a larger window opening. It's easy to fill in the excess space---as opposed to having to redo framing for a larger window in a smaller existing opening.

  • 18 years ago

    If your gut tells you this is going to bother you every time you look at it, then have it changed.

    My husband and I have done lots of remodeling work over the years (major DIY'ers) I'm very flexible, lots of things won't really matter, but once in a while it's something that I know one of us will never be happy with.

    I've learned to think long and hard before deciding to NOT fix a mistake. If I don't think I'll get use to it, then it's worth changing. Right now, the change to your window will be cheaper than at any time in the future.

    I know this from experience. I've "not fixed" a few mistakes over the years that have been a constant thorn in my side - and I've had others that after a few months, I don't notice any more. Usually it's more of a case of knowing I won't be happy, but not willing to do the work or spend the money to correct it now.

    From what you describe, I know that I could never be happy or "get use to it" and every time I looked at it I'd find myself feeling a twinge of anger at my husband for getting things mixed up. I don't want that kind of "reminders" around the home.

    Cathy

  • 18 years ago

    i don't think you will notice the faucet. i am not happy that our over the range microhood is not lined up exactly with the range. both appliances are white and the cabinets are stained. of all the people that have seen the kitchen re-do over the past year, not one has noticed it until it was pointed out. honestly, they didn't...so i decided that it would be unrealistic of me to care too...
    the only way that i would go over budget to fix this mistake in your case is if the mistake affected the feel of standing at the sink using that faucet, not just the look. if it affected the way that you can use the sink or look out the window, then change the window. otherwise no.
    i know what i am talking about here with the windows...good old DIY hubby put in two windows along the back wall of the kitchen, with much measuring. turns out they are one inch higher than the same window in the mudroom. what to do? i just couldn't make him take it all out after working an entire weekend...decision is to leave the kitchen windows uncovered and to put a lovely curtain over the mudroom window (that we don't really look out of anyway.) it bothered me a lot....for exactly 2 weeks...now i don't care. good luck whatever you do!! kren

  • 18 years ago

    I would notice something like that if I were touring for a purchase, especially if the cabinets are not lined up evenly on each side of the window. Our first set of cabinets went in with one side two inches off of the other side (framing a door). It looked terrible. I had them removed immediately.

    That tight budget could cost you more later in resale if your kitchen isn't quite right. I'd move the window to the original design, or purchase a new cabinet that fits the space evenly (balanced on both sides). Then adjust the sink holes if necessary or get a new sink....which (with cabinet and sink) is probably more than just fixing the window :)

    Then I'd shoot one of the GC's :) IT's easier to have just one...I'll let you choose which one should be shot heh heh

  • 18 years ago

    For the question about the IKEA cabinets, try posting it on ikeafans.com. It's a site not run by IKEA but full of helpful people (amateurs and professionals) with lots of experience designing, installing, and modifying IKEA kitchens.

    Here is a link that might be useful: IKEAfans

  • 18 years ago

    THANKS to all for your GREAT suggestions and helpfulness. I have been on the IKEAFANS website frantically asking about the switching of the upper cabinets. In the meantime, my installing called with a resolution. He miraculously has the SAME window as the incorrect one at his shop ONLY it's 2 inches narrower (the size I needed). He will change out the window with his and he gets my slightly larger window for an even swap and no labor cost. So in the long run, everything will run as planned with the exception of a lightly smaller window behind the bench seats. That I think I can live with and I won't have to shoot anyone or bite my tongue around my DH who has truly been trying to help with this project (usually not his nature, just let's me do it).

    Thanks again to you all!! You are a God send!!