Software
Houzz Logo Print
janieful

Backsplash Advice

15 years ago

I wanted to solicit advice about installing a backsplash in our relatively dated kitchen. Our house is a 1920s bungalow with a 1990s kitchen. I know that is not that dated, but the cabinets are white laminate and somewhat bad quality. The counter is okay - a black speckled laminate in good condition. The cabinets are in okay condition, but it is definitely not a quality kitchen that a potential buyer would walk in and love. When we bought the house four years ago we were unimpressed with the kitchen. Now I see that it is functional and really not that bad. Also, since our home is worth more than we paid for it already, I don't want to spend the money to change the cabinets or the counter. We plan to sell in 3-5 years.

We very recently replaced the floor from an ugly peel and stick to a nice vinyl fiberfloor that looks like slate. Now the only thing left that I am willing to pay for is to install a backsplash. At first we wanted to install white subway tile, because we thought it would go with the style of the house. But then I changed my attitude to "go big or go home" and thought that we should install a flashy glass tile backsplash - one of those varied styles with greys blacks and whites. But now I am having second thoughts again. Should we go simple (and a little boring) or make a bolder (but still tasteful) statement?

My real goal in all this is to #1 enjoy it for a few years and #2 to have a picky first time home buyer like myself to walk into the kitchen and not think that they have to gut it immediately. Sure, a nice backsplash won't fool them into thinking the kitchen is new, but I just want them to find it pleasing enough to not be a hindrance to the sale. Our home is definitely a first time home buyer type of house - 2 bedroom, 1 bath, 1200 sq. ft.

We had a quote for someone to install it for around $300 (NOT including materials). Does this sound reasonable?

Any opinions on what type of backsplash would be appropriate would be much appreciated! Or anything else you think we could do to make it better. Forgive the clutter in the picture. Of course, when we go to sell, the counters will be clean of clutter.

Comments (14)

  • 15 years ago

    Would you be putting the tile above the existing laminate backsplash or removing it?

    My personal opinion would be to avoid the multicolored glass tiles -- I say that just because I don't care for them myself. Our kitchen is similar to yours, by the way, except for size and countertop color. I am not a real estate expert at all, but when I bought my 1st house, I don't think I gave the kitchen much of a look and I don't even now remember what the backsplash was (or if it had one). I am guessing that new buyers would be more swayed by the appliances, if anything.

    However, if you are doing it mostly for yourself, then by all means put up the glass mosaic if you love it!

  • 15 years ago

    I think the kitchen looks fine the way it is. I wouldn't invest in a backplash. IMHO a backsplash will not make or break this kitchen. I disagree with you in that the next buyer will probably want to redo this kitchen, espcially if you are adding 3-5 years from now.

  • 15 years ago

    Instead of doing all mosaic glass tile, what if you did just an accent row of the mosaics? Since you already have the laminate backsplash it might be kind of tough but you could definitely put the glass mosaics behind the range. I would do a solid color vs a multi colored mosaic.

    The subway tile would definitely go with the style of the house. If you went that route you could do a contrasting grout color (i.e. dark grey) to make it stand out more. I personally like the grout color the same as the tile but that's just me.

    There is also subway tile that has a crackle finish. A little more pizzaz than the plain subway.

    $300 for installation does not sound bad to me.

  • 15 years ago

    Honestly, unless not having a backsplash is something that's bugging you, I don't think you necessarily need to add one. Consider it money spent for your own enjoyment; it's not going to make or break the kitchen or the sale. It's very possible that a new buyer will gut the kitchen anyway; if you were unimpressed with it four years ago, just tack on a decade and imagine the next buyer! :)

    I'd really avoid putting too much money into it. The worst thing the previous owner of our house did was to replace the backsplash and counters in our kitchen (also a dated kitchen in a 2/1 bungalow) before selling. It looked lovely, but the cabinets were not in good shape, so it was basically wasted money to try to make the house look better to buyers. It didn't affect our offer, and in fact we would have preferred that she'd left the old counters on because they would have been less costly to replace. The kitchen, while prettied up, was clearly still old and the layout was still problematic. Like northcarolina, we also really didn't pay much attention to the details as first-time buyers, beyond whether it was a new or old kitchen (old), and whether it was functional enough that it wouldn't need to be immediately remodeled (yes).

    So basically---do it if you'll enjoy it yourself in the time you'll be there; don't do it for a theoretical buyer. If you do decide to do it, though, I like the idea of something bold/colorful with your walls and cabinets. HTH!

  • 15 years ago

    Thanks for the responses, everyone!

    @northcarolina
    I hadn't thought about removing the existing backsplash. I was worried that the removal of that would damage the drywall and necessitate extra money to repair the wall first. We removed an identical backsplash in the bathroom, and chunks of plaster came off with it, since it was glued to the wall.

    I'm glad everyone thinks that the kitchen doesn't scream gut job. Perhaps I've been watching too much HGTV in which first time home buyers react with horror to any cabinets that aren't custom and wood. I remember being pretty shallow and impressed with surface things like SS appliances and possibly a flashy backsplash. Honestly that was my reasoning. I would enjoy it, but it of course would not be essential. There are certainly other things we could do with $500 - tuck pointing, for instance! I recognize that doing a backsplash is pretty frivolous. We just have young children and I want to sell the house fast and worry in this bad market that it will sit for a while with this kitchen. Sadly, the house next to us, which is identical, sold for $15,000 less than ours WITH a new kitchen (albeit a really cheap remodel for a flip). I guess that has made me paranoid.

    The walls, however, are filthy at the moment. Maybe I'm just a messy cooker. But I guess instead of spending hundreds on a backsplash, we could just use high gloss paint behind there.

    I like the idea of a focal point mosaic in one color, just behind the stove. I had actually thought of that before, but not just the one color idea. This would be cheaper and still give me something fun and unique to install in an otherwise pretty standard kitchen.

    Thanks again!

  • 15 years ago

    Janieful, I LOVE the look of the aqua paint on your backsplash wall(at least it looks aqua in the photo) with the white cabinets and dark counter and the slate-look vinyl. I agree about not needing to put in tile to help sell the home, given the style of the kitchen and the circumstances. The aqua helps give it some charm and color, imho. (If you do decide to put in tile, think about keeping some color, maybe.) Perhaps you could take the $300 and get some great window treatments and some beautiful decorative accessories to help sell the home-- or at least the kitchen----like a gorgeous platter (or whatever)above the range, fun accessories above the cabinets (can't see what is up there), and some great light fixtures. Aqua is so "in" right now, as I'm sure you are well aware, so you can easily find lots of home decor items that would look great in your kitchen at every discount store. I love older homes, so I'd play up the quaint and charming aspect of your older home/older style kitchen.(My grandma's old house from the 40's had plain white (metal) cabinets- so maybe that is why I say that I think you could have fun with a retro kind of style with what you have!) Anyway, just my 2 Cents. (I say this as I am struggling to find just the right backsplash tile to go with my new granite countertop. And by the way, $300 for labor isn't bad. Most places I have asked, have stated a minimum of $500 for labor (but I am in a pricey D.C. suburban area-don't know what part of the country you are in. )Hope this helps.

  • 15 years ago

    Don't they say a homebuyer makes up their mind in 30 seconds or something like that? I actually envy you that kitchen! Mine is technically a bit bigger, but yours has so much charm - honestly, I think it's the color, like Fun2Learn said. I just can't get over that aqua popping out from the white, black and gray! It's classic & modern at the same time, which means the "feel" of the kitchen is a good one (for me, at least).

    Semi-gloss or high gloss paint would give you more scrubbability (check out Ace Hardware's Royal Finest with Scotchguard or another quality, scrubbable paint). If you really want a backsplash behind the stove, I think either those faux-tin tiles or glass mosaic tiles to tie in with your aqua would be pretty.

  • 15 years ago

    Actually the paint color isn't aqua - it's more of a light sage green. But looking at the photo it does look aqua. Now you all have me wanting to paint again! I agree that would be a great choice, especially considering the floor now has some blue in it. Too bad I just bought a semi-gloss in the exact same color I already had. When we first moved in we were spending a fortune (or so it felt at the time) on paint, so I went with a $2 mis-tint at Sherwin Williams. I love the color, but stupid me didn't check the finish. It was flat/matte paint - a terrible choice for a kitchen.

  • 15 years ago

    Hi again, Janieful. I just saw photos of this gorgeous kitchen redo on this forum and immediately thought of your kitchen (since we thought your paint was aqua!)This one uses aqua glass mosiacs on the backsplash-and it looks somewhat contemporary, but not totally. It has a similar color scheme as yours(or what yours appeared to have!). Maybe with your "contemporary" style cabinets, playing up the contemporary angle wouldn't be such a bad idea afterall, if you could get such beautiful tiles as these!
    (Maybe eclectic--"quaint and charming bungalow meets contemporary chic?" ) Either way--paint or tile--that soft grayish aqua would be awesome with your colors,imho. You could keep it in mind for the future. HTH

    Here is a link that might be useful: Piaa's kitchen

  • 15 years ago

    Janieful,
    I think your kitchen is adorable. Since you are already
    ahead of the game in your real estate investment I would
    think carefully what you want to spend on your space.
    If you want to do what Fun2Learn suggested and dress it
    up the way Piaa did, just make sure you are doing this for
    YOU. Think of a tile as a gift to yourself, not an
    investment. Artemis78 is on target.


    "...do it if you'll enjoy it yourself in the time you'll be there; don't do it for a theoretical buyer." wise words by Artemis 78

    $300 sounds reasonable in my neck of Boston area to redo
    tile. But you might discover this is a DIY project with a
    simple sage or aqua tile you can find at a lowes or HD.
    Another option would be to use a piece of glass (fire safe)
    to go directly on the wall over the paint. But in reality
    this is no different that a great high gloss paint that
    can be washed.

    Whatever you do or don't do is going to be cute in your
    kitchen.
    ~boxer

  • 15 years ago

    If you are going to put in a backsplash put one in that you like. It's sometimes very hard to determine what potential buyers want. I know HGTV screams that you have to have everything neutral in order to sell and that you have to take every ounce of charm and personality out of a home to appeal to the masses.

    Chances are, no matter what you do, the buyer is going to want to redo it. There is a house for sale in my subdivision. The current owners redid the kithcen in a black and white scheme. They painted the oak cabinets white and put in black granite. It's very dramatic. And it's one of those things that I think most people either love or hate...and I am guessing from the time that it's been on the market, that it is turning a lot of people off. It would be quite expensive to redo this kitchen.

    My point is to do something for your enjoyment since you will be there a while. Maybe not too trendy where buyers are totally turned off and automatically have to calculate how much they need to spend to change it. But it's a small enough space where you can definitely jazz it up without spending a lot.

  • 15 years ago

    Here's one of my favorite painted backsplashes.

    Here is a link that might be useful: painted striped backsplash

  • 15 years ago

    Here's another of my favorite painted backsplashes...by Girlcat...faux tile....

    Here is a link that might be useful: find Girlcat's faux tile painted backsplash

  • 15 years ago

    Home Depot has these vinyl panels that just like pressed tin. I would use them in a muted silver color. They look like the real thing. You can easily install them yourselves and it will jazz up your kitchen for a small investment. You can finish the ends with thin molding strips painted to match your walls. If you want to use tile, I would go with classic white subways. I wouldn't use anything multi-color as it's a small space and your floor already has a lot going on.