Software
Houzz Logo Print
dorry2

Do you like Sherwin Williams paints?

13 years ago

I love Ben Moore paints and was disappointed to find the nearest BM store in the coastal town where we just built is one hour away. The decorators all recommend SW paint. Anyone have a sea glass room?

Do you like SW paints? I won't be painting, but am wondering if they hold up well, cleanability, two-coat coverage? I am not planning on using deep, dark colors in this house.

Thanks.

Comments (25)

  • 13 years ago

    I can not get BM paints locally, so can not compare. We have used SW paint, or Valspar, (Lowes), for all our home painting projects, and I do prefer SW paints. I find them easy to work with, durable, and great when you can get them on their frequent sales.

  • 13 years ago

    We have used SW paint for most of our home just because there is a store conveniently located about a mile away and I am a big fan. We had heard that Behr was good, so tried that in a couple of rooms and never again, I found that the colors inconsistent between cans and the coverage wasn't as good. I know that most here prefer BM, but I have always been so happy with SW that I don't feel the need to seek out a store that carries BM.

    Like mentioned above,SW will have sales relatively frequently if you keep your eyes open.

  • 13 years ago

    We've used both SW and BM paints. I like both equally (did not like Valspar or Behr). Right now the SW store is closest, so if I pick a BM color, I just go get SW paint and have them match the color - no problem at all.

  • 13 years ago

    I do like SW paints and recommend them.

  • 13 years ago

    I have used both, but the SW store is much more convenient and the frequent sales make it a great deal for me. I just purchased all the paint I needed for my bathroom reno at 40% off. I love the colors, they are perfect and covered like a dream.

  • 13 years ago

    We painted with SW Duration matte and it was suppose to be so good - very expensive. I don't know if it had to do anything with the primer SW or not, but I have not been happy with it. In Consumer Reports it didn't get very high ratings. Each year the ratings differ on what has been done to the various kinds of paint. SW I know rated much higher a few years ago. The Velspar used in one room was much thicker paint.

  • 13 years ago

    In the past year, I've painted with BM Regal and Aura in the matte finish and with SW Duration, also matte. I prefer painting with BM.

    I had my first ever paint failure with SW Duration. I had about 3 gallons of paint left in a 5 gal bucket. I mixed it as well as I could. After painting it bubbled and peeled in some spots. The paint was about 1 year old, which might have been the problem, but I have used "old" gallons in the past without problems.

  • 13 years ago

    Love their colors but am not a fan of the paint especially in bathrooms. we used what was recommended by their "pro" and it streaked horribly. Behr primer paint covers well and mixing colors is easier for them since they now mix by actual formula instead of just trying to match a tone to one of their established colors.

  • 13 years ago

    I prefer SW over BM.

  • 13 years ago

    YES!

  • 13 years ago

    I am not a fan. Don't use cashmere. I used it in a dining area and when I wiped off a small spot with water the paint came off. When I talked to them at the SW store, they said "well that paint isn't washable". Since when is paint not washable. With water.

    It had been on the wall for months. Really not worth the money.

  • 13 years ago

    I've used SW over the years with no issues and would use it in the future. I like the paint & I like their service. Our FR is painted in the old Martha Stewart color White Crane from when she marketed her line through SW years ago. SW could still mix the color for us when we repainted two years ago, even though Martha's line was long gone.

  • 13 years ago

    I've always used BM paints, but recently tried SW ProClassic on some cabinets, both because they are nearby and have beautiful grays. I had a terrible time with this paint! Switched in the middle of the project back to BM, and found it much easier to work with and more durable to date.

    Could just be my technique, and I know others swear by the stuff.

  • 13 years ago

    rovo, which BM paint and sheen did you use for your cabinets? Have they been finished for very long and wearing well?

    Which paint line in a brand is very important in comparing. Even BM has what its staff calls a "total cr#p" line. I heard many times that nothing compares to their Aura. I think it's the color lock feature that sets it apart (washing and fade).

  • 13 years ago

    snookums2: I used BM's satin impervo oil-based for the cabinets (once I switched from SW). I'm in California, and had read that it was no longer available, but not true! My BM guys that I've worked with for years swear that it's still the best, along with cabinet coat (couldn't use in my application because I neede a dark base) and a couple of high-end brands. I had concerns about the VOCs around my kiddos, but we decided to open every window and keep them at the grandparents' for a couple of days, so I felt ok about using it. As a side note, I used far less paint with the oil; actually the entire can, so maybe it balanced out from an environmental perspective?:)

    I agree that when comparing paint lines, you must do an "apples to apples " comparison. Still, I have successfully used BM's lowest grade "ultraspec" and have been thrilled every time. Totally my opinion, but I think BM covers better than SW and has better consistency. I have also used Aura in a few rooms, and for me it was streaky, dried waaaay too quickly to get even coverage, and was over priced. Frankly, I find it over-hyped, but again, just my opinion.

  • 13 years ago

    Thanks for the information on your cabinet paint. I don't want to use oil for a number of reasons but am considering the waterborne Impervo. Do you have paneled doors? Any cracking between cabinet parts (with the oil)?

    I am trying the Aura. It does dry waaaay too fast. I have been told that they all are that way now which came with the low VOC formulas. I'm happy with the coverage and find no streaking or anything. But boy do I really hate the fast dry. Even pros need time to work or fix an error!

    This post was edited by snookums2 on Mon, Feb 25, 13 at 16:15

  • 13 years ago

    Sorry, forgot to answer your other question: the SW painted cabinets have been done for about 4 months and are wearing poorly (scratches and chipping all around, even on rarely used cabs). The oil painted BM cabs have been up and running for about a month less, are used more frequently overall, and so far only one tiny ding where my dd ran her metal truck right into the door...

  • 13 years ago

    I love BM (original, oil) Satin Impervo for cabinetry and trim. We switched to the BM Waterborne Impervo the last time we repainted our cabinets and I hate it! We will probably re-do the entire kitchen with the oil Impervo when we can gird ourselves for the task. The oil Impervo levels out beautifully and has a rich finish; very durable and cleanable, too. Waterborne...don't get me started!

    I would definitely drive an hour to purchase Oil Impervo from BM if painting trim or cabinetry.

    I've been pleased with SW Cashmere, which we've used in two rooms. In general I prefer BM. I am drawn to to BM's colors and also appreciate the expertise of the employees at our BM store. BM also seems to offer more products. When I recently needed a quart of flat paint for a project, SW only had flat quarts in a paint-and-primer combo, which I didn't want. I do find SW's quality comparable to BM, though, provided you select the premium products.

    Sea Glass looks pretty. I've used SW Rainwashed, another pale aqua, in two rooms.

    This post was edited by lazydaisynot on Mon, Feb 25, 13 at 15:42

  • 13 years ago

    I have heard from my guys that the impervo waterborne is no good, but that Advance is a good choice if you want to avoid oil. I would have gone that route, but they had to special order it, and I really wanted to finish already, so I did oil.

    Yes, all the doors are paneled. I have one door that I caulked (some say do, some say don't, I had no idea and just did it as a matter of course) that separated a teeny bit, but I think it was from painting it on an unusually cold day. It's not obvious to anyone but me, so for now it stays!

    Sorry to hijack this thread!

  • 13 years ago

    Thank you!

    I can add that I have not been at all impressed with SW. Either the paint I used (forget which one, coverage did not compare with Aura) or the knowledge and experience of the staff. Color matching didn't exist. BM employees seem to have a better attitude, too, imo. Perhaps different company standards. My experience is limited, however.

  • 13 years ago

    I used SW in my master bath for walls and trim and enjoyed painting with it, liked the texture and itâÂÂs so far holding up well. Over the past 27 years or so and throughout my children growing up I have used both BM and Behr. I like them both and only switch to BM for color reasons. There is Zero difference on how either holds up in a family setting. I once used Velspar paint/primer and think it is the most pathetic paint on planet earth.

  • 13 years ago

    I have used both BM Aura and SW Duration and have to say that I actually prefer SW. At least for yellow, the SW was more scrubbable than the BM, which changed color. Last time I painted, I tried to color match one of the BM colors in a SW pain, which didn't work. So, I used BM.
    And,yes, Seaglass is very pretty.

  • 13 years ago

    I also like SW Cashmere. I was able to take scuff marks off it no problem without damaging the finish. This is in our LR and hallway.

    Now if you need whites, BM has probably 50 different variations.

    I am OK with Valspar and Behr, but they are runnier than SW or BM.

  • 13 years ago

    Jamie, I had the exact issue with BM. Came off the wall when I dabbed it with water. Ugh.

    We used to use BM exclusively but now use Behr and Valspar. My husband said he noticed no difference between BM Aura and Valspar. Except the $!

  • 8 days ago

    SW paint is garbage. Inferior grade. I have painted for 50 years owning many new homes. Recently we paid to have our house painted and they used Sherwin Williams best grade Emerald. I didn't want to use it but the painter talked me into it. The reason why painters love their paints is there is a Sherwin Williams paint store everywhere and they get great discounts on the paint. One year later it's fading and doesn't clean at all. Probably why Consumer reports ratings of Sherwin Paints are usually poor.

Sponsored
Haus Studio
Average rating: 4.8 out of 5 stars28 Reviews
Franklin County's Preferred Custom Cabinetry & Design Studio