Software
Houzz Logo Print
trconnie

Paint, Primer, Depression and Despair

18 years ago

I have been painting the interior of my house, one room at a time, for a couple of years now. As the walls have been sadly neglected, I've used the same process in each room which is:

Thorough cleaning with a mild detergent and bleach.

Rinse.

Thorough cleaning with TSP.

Rinse.

Spackle and sand.

Rinse.

Prime with latex Kilz.

Paint.

No problems. None at all. Until the guestroom .

In the guest room, I cleaned and spackled as mentioned above. The walls were completely dry when I primed them. The primer was beautiful. I considered leaving it.

A week later, I applied Valspar interior paint in a luscious Tibetan Red.

Every roller mark shows. The edges of each roller mark turned black.

When I tried to apply a second coat thinking optimistically that This Would Help (TM), things got worse. I did what any sane person would do, shut the door and ignored the mess for 6 mos.

Today, I went in there with the 5 gallon bucket of Kilz. The roller keeps pulling the Kilz off the walls. I talked to people at Lowe's. I talked to customer service at Valspar. I whined to my mother. I drank a beer.

Valspar says Piffle! All you need is another two or three coats of Tibetan Red. I argued. Then they said all I need is to sand. Then they said the whole problem was Kilz. When I pointed out that I hadn't had this problem in any room except this one, the conversation degraded quickly.

I will do whatever I have to do short of ripping out drywall to fix this problem, but I'd like to know for sure. Since I have two coats of the most hideous paint job you've ever seen in a dark red, I have to prime before I can repaint. I can't get the primer to stick. Fine. I'll sand. But I still have to prime. Is Kilz really the problem? Will John and Marsha get back together? Can we solve global warming? Can I salvage these walls? How?

Connie, desperate

Comments (19)

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I can emphasize. I have been going through the same process for the past 6 months prepping house to sell. I've painted untold yards and numbers of dark stained trim and doors white, requiring two coats of bonding primer and two coats of finish enamel. I've still got one more door and two rooms of trim to finish, so I can see the finish line.

    I've had good luck with alkyd blocking primer (SW), but after a while I couldn't take the smell, so switched to SW top of the line latex bonding primer. The alkyd covered better, but the odor and clean up were bad.

    There must be something on the walls under the primer that's preventing the primer from creating a good bond with the surface. I'll let the experts chime in on this one, but reads like you need an adhesion boosting (bonding) primer.

    To heck with John and Marsha...I lie awake nights wondering if Luke and Laura will hook up again-LOL.

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Thanks Randita.

    I'm completely demoralized, but I'll get over it.

    I just got done sanding all the walls.

    The really crappy part of this is that although I'm a perfectionist, I never expected anything even close to perfect. My home is a converted barn and my ex and I did the drywall. And it shows. But I've never ever never had paint do this before. And I never imagined a scenario where saying %&^%$&^%$ it and slapping a coat of primer on it wouldn't fix it.

    Since I have no idea what you're talking about with alkyd blocking primers and latex bonding primers, I can tell this is going to be a long, ugly process.

    I often wonder if Nick and Nora aged gracefully together or if all that drinking and sleuthing busted the marriage.

    Connie, not a Thin Man

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Who the heck are John and Marsha?

    Is this Kilz 2 the latex version or the original oil based Kilz?

    I don't really know why your primer won't stick, but you really don't need to prime the wall just because it is red. It could be that the first coat of Tibetan Red just looked bad because it is a color that covers poorly and if it is one of those reds that take 6-8 coats to obtain complete color coverage then the first coat usually looks pretty bad. That's normal. What most of us do now is either use Aura or use a grey primer because the red will cover the grey in fewer coats than it will cover a white. Along the same lines, using a white primer over red is not going to cover very well either...it could be that you need to just roll and move on and try not to roll back into what has already started to set up so that you are not pulling the primer off again.

    Alkyd is just another word for oil based. There is really no reason to use an oil based (alkyd) primer inside on walls unless there are stains that need to be killed. Kilz 2 is really a stain killing primer too but it is a latex version and really it doesn't kill too many stains. The best thing to use would be a general purpose type of latex primer designed to be used on drywall.

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Hi TRConnie!
    (Your posts are true "humor works of art!")

    A few detail-oriented questions:
    1) Exactly what kind of paint....color/sheen/age, etc., was on that wall?
    2) Was there any wallpaper ever removed?
    3) What sheen is the "new" Tibetan Red??
    4) Exactly what roller-cover did'ja use (brand/style/nap-height)?

    TSP needs to be rinsed VERY well...2 or 3 times!! ANY residue from it will screw up the best primer in the world.
    >>> MIGHT you not have rinsed quite as well in this room??

    Your "round 2" of primer is MOST LIKELY getting pulled-off because you're probably rolling back into it after a minutes time.
    >>> It takes HOURS for a primer to start gripping well.

    Your "streaked" Red is such a common issue with this color!!
    * Correct...a medium-Gray primer should've been used under this.
    * Let Gray primer dry 3 hours.
    * My 2 fave roller-sleeves are the Purdy White-Dove, or the Wooster Pro-DooZ. Use a 3/8" nap.
    * FOR THE INITIAL LOADING:
    Let the sleeve get fully loaded....meaning: Load roller as normal. Let sit for 2 minutes...Load again, let sit another 2 min.
    * The weave of this class of rollers is dense. It takes awhile for paint to soak all the way in. If you don't "let them soak", you're just applying paint from the outside of the roller. Result...uneven coverage, and not nearly enough paint on the wall.
    * You should be able to walk around the house with a properly loaded cover and not have a drip (this only applies to top-notch paints though!).
    * On an 8' high wall...Load/Unload your roller 4 times in a column ~2.5' wide.
    * After filling-in bottom "square", bring roller to the top, and do a LIGHT ceiling-to-floor "sweep" of this column.
    * This evens-out thin spots, ridges, and roller-turns that you can't see because it's all wet!
    * Repeat around the room....Build a column, and "sweep it"!
    * SIX hours later, do 2nd FULL coat of Red the same way.

    I have some good "Gray primer" recipes, depending on what brands you have.
    We dropped the Kilz primers we had.
    We're using some Zinsser series, ACE deep tint primer, and a group of C2 primers.
    (Of Gray primer alone...one recent year...we sold nearly 500 gallons of the ACE Deep-tint for JUST this kind of use!)

    Faron

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    While I don't have any good advice, I have to add that my friend just painted her dining room a dark red (maybe your same color, not sure) and it took 8 coats. She was ready to run away from home, as it was not even the color she wanted, but her husband talked her into it. Good luck!

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    You people are great! I love it!

    I used a satin finish Valspar Waveryly Tibetan Red. I used 3/8 inch run of the mill rollers that were new. I'm aware of the properties of TSP. The house is old (a restored barn) and most of the drywall is a nightmare because we live hard and we play hard, but also because we lived here while we were converting one room at a time. The barn is, mostly, done and now it's time to go back to paint and decorate these rooms. The old paint is more than 10 years old - your basic contractor 5 gallon tubs of stark white. This is why I cleaned the walls so thoroughly. I've been painting one room at a time using the same process in each room. This is the only one that's given me a problem.

    It's possible I didn't get the TSP rinsed, but let me explain again. (Is it possible to post pictures?). I did all the cleaning and prep and put on two coats of KILZ2 latex. Those two coats went on great and looked beautiful. Stunning! Martha Stewart would have profiled me had she only known.

    I put on the first coat of the red about a week later. I should have stopped. But everyone told me red was difficult so I figured it would get better.

    The first coat was difficult to roll on. Every roller mark was a slightly different color of red. When it began drying, the edges of each roller mark started turning black. I've never seen anything like it. While this was my first foray with red, I've painted with dark colors before. This was not the simple uneveness you get with darks. I now have a room that looks like somebody did a very bad faux painting job layering black and different shades of red. I showed the picture to the guy at the Lowe's paint department and he went screaming into the plubming aisle. Something, truly, was wrong with the red paint. When I tried to put on the second coat, the first sweep of the roller went on fine, but when you pulled it back, it either pulled the 2nd coat back off OR turned ALL of the second coat black. If you've ever Venetian plastered, you know that sensation where the second coat does something chemically to the first one to completely change the sheen and color? Well it was like that, only it's paint! I'm pretty sure that additional coats of this are not going to fix the problem. First of all, I couldn't even get primer to go on and second - well there is no second.

    So, here's my plan (I think). I'm done sanding. The color is so mottled and so many different colors that I am going to prime. And then I'm going to paint. The room does need to be red which means I've got to go find another red that looks like this red but doesn't behave like this one. I've still got 3 gallons of KILZ2 left. In the interest of financial solvency, I'd need a really good reason to be convinced to buy a gray primer. This room has already cost me hundreds and I'm ready to burn the place down and move to the Mayan Riviera.

    I spent yesterday with a mouse sander sanding all the walls. It's a big room. I'm cranky.

    Connie Ihatepainting

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Hi Connie,

    Oh, I feel your pain! [I'm stalled in the middle of a difficult kitchen painting job.]

    I had a red dining room once. Loved it! Keep trying!

    All I can offer is a "good reason" to buy gray primer. Well, maybe it isn't a good reason. But I'm sticking with it! It's called:

    MakingAReallyHardJobALittleBitEasierAndWhoCaresAboutAnExtraHundredBucksInTheGrandSchemeOfThings.

    I started out with a gallon of alkyd Zinsser Cover/Stain for my kitchen cabinets. 30ish bucks. I used a teeny bit. It was hard for me to work with.

    I went and bought a gallon of alkyd Fresh Start (Ben Moore). Another 30+ bucks. It was easier to work with. I've only used a teeny bit, but I'm just fed up with alkyd primer (the clean up is too difficult).

    So now I've invested 60 bucks in these 2 premium primers. They are both almost FULL. (Disposal of them is difficult). But I want a latex primer for the rest of this job.

    SO I'M THROWING AWAY THE 60 BUCKS! Bwa Ha Ha Ha!!!

    This feels reckless and wasteful to me. And I don't care anymore!!

    How many TripleWhiteChocolateHoldTheWhipMochas will 60 bucks buy me? That will be my sacrifice.

    Painting is too darn hard to suffer with the wrong primer. Don't do it! Go gray!!!

    Btw: TheHusband doesn't know that I'm throwing away 60 bucks worth of almost new primer. And I'm not telling. Because he would find that unacceptable. Tough. I'm painting, not him.

    :-)

    francy

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    OK, Francy. Since you're easy with the idea of tossing money away, why don't you just ship that primer to me. If I dump the residue from the grill in there, it'll be gray.

    Normally, I would take this gray primer thing and run with it. I don't know why I'm being so obstinate. Honestly. The only thing I can surmise is that the I-Hate-Painting mantra has been a fact of life for the past two years because I have Color Issues (TM).

    I painted my kitchen twice - I hated the first color. I painted my dressing room THREE times. I still hate the color. With those two experiences under my belt, I shopped the bedroom color - oh yes I did. I stood in parking lots in full sun and looked at paint chips. Then I took about a 100 of each chips, lined them up on my bedroom floor and considered the color in the morning, the afternoon, the evening. I selected one. I wanted a not-quite-white that would look good with a mocha kind of color.

    I've got yellow. I hate yellow. In some light, my bedroom looks like a page from Curious George Paints the Man in the Yellow Hat's Bedroom. Nonetheless, I will die with that yellow paint on the walls. That room is 20 x 16 with 16ft ceilings. As God is my witness, I will never repaint that room.

    With the Tibetan Red fiasco, I love the color. I know what it looks like over white primer. If I use gray primer and the color changes, I will be forced to abandon my life and take up a new one as travelling xylophone blues musician. Since I can't sing, don't own a xylophone, and have too much respect for the blues, that would be a tragedy.

    Connie-who-is-happy-to-report-that-repriming-is-going-well-and-expects-to-put-red-paint-with-no-problem-at-all-on-the-walls-next-weekend-after-she-lightly-sands-the-primer-per-Valspar-phone-guy

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    You still have options. To make a grey primer you just add black to white so you could take the primer into a paint store and have them add black and shake it. You could also do this yourself but it's hard to mix manually. Another thing you can do is forget the primer and just use Benjamin Moore Aura. Sure, it's 50 bucks a gallon but by the time you apply a grey primer and 2-5 coats of red over that believe me the Aura option is way cheaper and faster. Plus, at the end you will have a very durable finish. They should be able to custom match your red in Aura. I have actually painted with a cranberry type red directly over white with Aura and it covered in one coat. Your Valspar story sounds very strange to me so I would stay away from the paint at this point entirely.

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Hey paintguy!

    Someone suggested that the problem with the Valspar was that one of the cans might have been a glossy enamel - an error made by accident when the store mixed the color. When I mixed the two cans together, chaos reigned. Does that make any sense? I used Valspar in the kitchen in a dark brown - it's beautiful, it seems to be holding up well, and it was one of the easiest paints to apply that I've ever used.

    The Aura sounds very tantalizing.

    I did reprime with the primer I had here. After I sanded the disastrous red, the new coats of primer went on just like they're supposed to.

    I'm so sick of the whole mess that it's quite likely that room will end up a boring beige.

    I know why painters charge so much. I'm so tired I can't move.

    Connie

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Hey, bayareafrancy,

    I bet you aren't really going to throw the primer in the hazardous waste collection, but just in case you were, please consider donating it to Habitat. If they don't want to use it for their own projects, they will sell it at their recycling store. And you can recoup a little bit of the cost as a tax deduction.

    Connie, I had the same thing happen when I painted my bedroom--agonized over paint chips, had them taped up on the wall, looked at them in all lights--but when the soft gold- tan that I thought was perfect went up on the wall, it had a green undertone that shone like a neon sign! Took it back to the paint store, they played with the color a bit, I played with it some more, and ended up with something that looks rather like swedish yellow pea soup! But, somehow, it is a soothing color that looks okay with my curtains, quilts and art (actually is oddly a good backdrop for the art). Since I have 4 other rooms and a hall to paint, it's staying!

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Hey raee: what a great idea! I never thought of that. My plan was to either see if haz waste would take it, or take it to the paint store to see if they could use it (or resell it in the "used can" pile). Thanks for the idea!

    It's not that I'm easy with throwing the cash away, but since I begged and begged for TheHusband to hire painters for my job (and he wouldn't), I figure I'm saving so much money doing this myself, I have wiggle room to get the primer I want.

    Connie: you should see my rooms! I have painted the dining room twice now. It has big paint sample splotches all over it. So does the living room (which I've painted once, and have to redo). I can't choose correctly from cards, so I waste yet more money on little cans and splotch them all over the place too see them in different light.

    I never had this problem with paint 10 years ago. I'd pick a color from a card while still at the store. And everything was fine. Even my red dining room was easy!

    Must be age...

    :-)

    francy

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Yes that could be some explanation. It could be that the 2 cans were tinted differently too. I didn't know two cans were involved.

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Yes. I had two cans. I was encouraged, due to the finickiness of red, to mix the two together before I began painting. Which I did in a brand new bucket.

    Connie

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I have the exact same Tibetan red and SAME streaking problem (I've painted many rooms in my life and I can't believe this is happening! I sanded and prepped the walls as usual etc.). Wanted your advise...I've done 3 coats... still streaky. Was Valspar helpful at all when you called? Should I just got get a a different red that's close to the color and paint over my horrible walls? I'm renting. There is NO way I'm sanding it all off. My landlord likes the red so I'm trying to make it work.

    Completely frustrated!!

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Connie--your original post cracked me up; I love the way you write. You could also be writing about my son and his fiance's first foray into the painting world--also with red paint.

    As adults, I steered them toward the Home Depot paint department and withheld all my maternal advice-giving instincts. Let them learn how things work by themselves.

    They had an experience very similar to yours, especially with the roller taking the previous coat of paint from the walls. When they explained this to me I couldn't imagine what they had done. I've never heard of this happening and was sure they had done something insane or were grossly exagerating the problem in an effort to get Mom to come and paint for them.

    Long story short(er): Home Depot mixed the red in APPLIANCE paint. Fiance told the man she wanted it to look like patent leather and they came home with paint for appliances.

    MANY hours of sanding, cursing, repriming, cursing, painting, margaritas and cursing later--they had one red room. They never painted another room as long as they lived in that first house.

    There's our family's sad red paint story. I feel you.

    Dianne

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Blame the paint. About six months ago I helped a friend use the EXACT same brand & color. Valspar Tibetan Red. It was HORRIBLE. It was supposed to be for accents and the three insulated metal doors. It would not roll on, paint on smoothly, ran and dripped terribly, took forever to dry and bunched and globbed in places when we tried to apply a second coat. Sanding and a different paint was the only option open to my friend. As a matter of fact he bought top of the line Valspar from Lowes for the three colors and wasn't thrilled with the other two color's performance either. I am getting ready to paint my kitchen this month and I am seriously thinking of avoiding the whole Valspar line.

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I used Kilz brand (it's not primer, nor does it have primer in it) paint from Walmart in Vesuvian Garnet. It's a medium red in a more warm tone, but not a brick. In my kitchen, I did it in a satin finish. Two years later, when I wanted the same red in the entry, I found that they have an eggshell finish and used that. It covers beautifully. Kilz promises one coat coverage in this paint, but man, it's red. So I had to do two, not over primer, but over a butter yellow in kitchen, a sage in entry. The coverage is great. The paint is under $20 a gallon. The Vesuvian Garnet is a good red, but it's not intense. And I used the proper nap roller cover for my knockdown finish walls. Here's one view from soon after my kitchen got it's red on in 2004, (before we did new floor, granite, etc.)

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Waaaaaaa!!!!! This is over a year and a half old and I want to know the end of the story. Trconnie--please????? Did you get your Tibetan Red room without streaks? I do hope you pop in.