Software
Houzz Logo Print
kam76

Trying to sell my dining set

12 years ago

It is a nice set but I have had for about 10 years it is not really going to fit well in my new home and I am kinda over the whole perfectly match set thing. It has a table with 4 regular chairs, two captain's chairs and a china cabinet for $600. It is solid wood with a cherry finish. I paid $1200 for it new. A person came to look at it and offered me $300 for the table and the 4 regular chairs. I am trying to decide if I should accept this offer and try to find a new table and chairs that will kind of go with those pieces but not be so matchy matchy or if I should hold out to sell the whole set and start over from scratch. What would you guys do? I don't have a ton of time because we need to be out of this house on Monday and I would prefer not to put it in storage if I don't have to.

Comments (21)

  • 12 years ago

    Taket the money and run. You don't have a lot of time to hope another buyer comes along. And you have to look at this also as someone moving it for you rather than your having to hire someone to do it. If you had more time, I'd say hold out. You can always ask the buyer if you can have until Saturday to try and sell the set but that you'll sell it to him/her if not. See what they say. They're getting a good deal and should understand why you'd want to try to sell the whole set.

  • 12 years ago

    ditto - I'd take the offer.

  • 12 years ago

    I'd counter first... Who makes their first offer the best. I'd counter 400 just on principal , see what happens.

    But unfortunately 25pct of retail is pretty normal

  • 12 years ago

    NO one is going to pay you $1200 for 10 year old furniture.
    Sell.
    Storing it just costs you money....

  • 12 years ago

    Sell! I tried to sell my set with 8 matching chairs and a sideboard and didn't get a single "hit". I gave it to one of the contractors guys - just wanted it gone!

  • 12 years ago

    Ouch. That would be a hard sell.

    I would be haunted forever by elderly female ghosts in long, high-necked Lanz of Salzburg nightgowns, chastising me for not keeping the furniture in the family. It's not worth the endless stretch of sleepless nights!

  • 12 years ago

    LOL kswl, it's not a family heirloom that's been generations in the family!
    I agree, sell, then relist the china cabinet alone on CL. I've seen several here listed as whole sets, then pricing broken down for just chairs, just table, just hutch. So it's done.

  • 12 years ago

    I don't know about that, mlweaving.....I had one relative who believed that her purchase of an item---- no matter how recent, ugly or I expensive--- conferred holy properties on it. You probably think I am kidding ðÂÂÂ

  • 12 years ago

    kswl: You are FUNNY! I'm one of those elderly ladies who runs around the house in Lanz of Salzburg nightgowns!

  • 12 years ago

    Oh my, my Mom used to give us Lanz of Salzburg nightgowns for Christmas, for excitement that could be surpassed only by a six-pack of socks.

    Thanks for the giggle KSWL.

  • 12 years ago

    Do you think you can use the china hutch in a different room in your new home? For things like little collectibles, framed photos, decorative bowls, similar things you have around the home? Or in an office, maybe?

    (The captain's chairs, well, I'd probably call Salvation Army -- get a little charity tax deduction -- if you decide to sell the table and other chairs to the person who called -- which you probably should so you don't feel burdened by it.)

    It sounds like a pretty and sturdy set, but as you've said, you don't want matchy/matchy anymore. It's given you a good return on your investment.

  • 12 years ago

    indeed kswl, I remember the nightgowns I owned at one
    distant point of my life, I had not thought of them for ages.

  • 12 years ago

    My mother-in-law believed that everything she owned was a valuable antique, simply because it was old. Sorry, if it was a cheap piece of crap when you bought it 50 years ago, now it's an old cheap piece of crap.

  • 12 years ago

    Does the buyer have room for the china cabinet? Throw it in for another $100?
    You save the cost of moving & storing it.
    Edit: typo

    This post was edited by romy718 on Tue, Feb 11, 14 at 18:43

  • 12 years ago

    I'd take the money and run. No current buyer really cares what you paid for it 10 years ago. To help you part with it and put things in perspective, if your current set originally cost $1200 and you've had it for 10 years then your per year cost was only $120 or about 33 cents per day. Anything you can get out of it is just a discount on your new purchase.

    But I know where you're coming from. I have a 30+ year old dining set that I'm struggling to part with. But my issue is finding something else that is the size I need in a style that fits and a quality I like. Guess I should just list it and once it's gone I'll be forced to be less picky.

  • 12 years ago

    So many of us with the ghost of Lanz in our lives ð Mtnrd, my mother still gives my husband and sons six packs of socks at Christmas....even though she has been repeatedly told they have not worn white crew socks in years. The cultural influence of whitebread clothing...lol!

  • 12 years ago

    I had a DR table and chairs and an unmatched hutch that would not fit in my new place. I liked the hutch but was tired of the table and chairs. I sold the chairs on craigslist, I use the table in the new basement as a great project surface and the hutch became a "bookcase" in a living room nook.

  • 12 years ago

    You can still buy a Lanz nightgown at the Vermont Country Store. Can you imagine having a hot flash while wearing that voluminous, high necked flannel? Yikes.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Vermont Country Store

  • 12 years ago

    They still have them at Macy's! I love how they put pretty young models in themâ¦as if. They are over at Victoria's Secret getting their Valentine's thongâ¦but then I suppose you could wear that under for an interesting dichotomy and to blow Salzburg hubby's mind.

  • 12 years ago

    I grew up in Buffalo, and I loved wearing flannel nightgowns like that.

    Good luck with trying to sell the set. Since you are on a tight timeline, take the money (or maybe counter) and let it go.

  • 12 years ago

    take the money and run..i have been trying to sell a calvin klein sofa for about 6 mos..lots of replies to CL ad but no takers..sometimes the buyer just wont take on the burden of moving the item.