Software
Houzz Logo Print
dilettante_gw

BM Paint - Can store get the color wrong?

13 years ago

I usually buy my BM paint from a small local hardware store that is an official Benjamin Moore vendor. It seems to me that several of the colors, especially ones that I bought in pint-sized custom mixed samples (not the tiny premixed samples) are WAY off, not just from the printed paint chips but from the dozens of photos I've looked at online.

I know that paint chips and computer monitors aren't very accurate, that paints look different under different lighting conditions, and that there are zillions of variables that affect color in photographs, etc. Still, the colors are so far off that they couldn't possibly be right. (I've checked the labels, and the color number and color name are what I asked for, so they didn't mix a different color.) The colors are in the right family, not completely random. But if these samples are correct, what's the point in even looking at paint chips?

I always assumed that stores use a computer to mix their colors and the process was totally foolproof, but now I'm wondering if that's really true. Is it possible that the store computer is out of calibration or that the person who mixed the paint made an error? I've never complained to the store because I trusted the system, and they have a no-returns policy on paint anyway (understandable, of course, unless the store got it wrong).

If anything, the colors seem too deep, as though too much colorant had been added. Is it possible for this to happen if the colorants are added by computer?

Comments (12)

  • 13 years ago

    Whether it can be clerk error, or computer error, mistints do happen. It should match the paint chip exactly really. It could be that they shot an amount of colorant for a gallon into a quart can or something like that.

  • 13 years ago

    The small tintable samples aren't really paint. It's a substance that holds colorant like paint, but sometimes isn't a true representation.
    C2 has ACTUAL paint/tintbases in their pints (Eggshell sheen only).

    Most computerized tinters do have to be calibrated yearly. Some colorants are harder on pumps than others. For our COROBS, it takes about half a day, using an electronic scale out to the 3rd decimal position, in a repetition cycle. Sometimes a pump or two has to be replaced.

    Faron

  • PRO
    13 years ago

    Not to get off topic but

    Eggshell sheen only).

    Why is that?

  • 13 years ago

    Eggshell used because-

    * 'Cuz it's the most popular sheen by far.
    * Equally important is the inventory-cost of stocking all tintbases of each sheen. NO store owner would do that.
    * At least it's real paint!

    It would be kinda like a painter stocking-up on all kinds of faux-finishing tools, etc., just-in-case one customer MIGHT want that kind of job....
    Foolish use of capital for a small business!

    Faron

  • 13 years ago

    Thanks, everyone. At least I'm not crazy.

    Paintguy, I think you may be wrong about using the wrong quantity of colorant. Next time, I'll speak up if the sample doesn't match the chip.

    Faron, I had no idea that the BM sample pints weren't real paint. That's upsetting. I could understand that they'd use their cheapest line of paint for samples, but it should still be paint.

    Whose responsibility is it to calibrate the machines? Does the dealer have to pay to have this done? Do the manufacturers require their dealers to do this on a particular schedule? (It seems that they should.)

    C2 isn't an option for me. Their closest store is over an hour's drive each way. There are other BM dealers within range, though, as well as Sherwin-Williams and others. I would hate to stop buying paint from my local store because the people there are so nice, and I imagine that the store is just barely surviving, with so many big-box stores nearby. I'd hate to see it close.

  • PRO
    13 years ago

    Thanks Faron, I did not know.

  • 13 years ago

    Recently I had an unfaded sample of aluminum siding scanned for paint matching. The mixed paint was WAAAYY off. Finally the clerk told me he had a book of colors (Glidden). Thousands of choices, far more than the cards in the rack. I found a pretty good match and can live with it. The siding has 35 years of weather exposure and the unfaded sample does not now match the siding that is weathered. So I guessed at the change in the color and got close.

  • 13 years ago

    PG-
    No prob! I hope I didn't come across as snooty....I just wish this site had some avatars/emoticons to convey "casual talk"!

    Dilettante-
    * As PG noted, yes, sometimes the wrong "size" can accidentally be selected before shooting the color.
    * It's usually operator error; clicking on wrong/but similar color name, accidentally in wrong formula/brand-line, grabbing wrong tintbase, etc.
    * Scanners out of calibration......
    * Tinters: Usually a dealer buys a maintenance package. Depending on the tinter, sometimes maintenance companies contract-out to a small firm with calibration scales, etc.
    * "Usually", yearly is an average on transmission/pump-based tinters.
    * Bottom-line, it's a stores' job to do this. And, no, it's not cheap....!

    Faron

  • 13 years ago

    Thanks for the tip, Tuesday. Next time I'll make sure that they test the color before I leave.

  • 4 years ago

    I agree that thr paint does’nt match the pain card that I have pick for the 3rd time!! ive bought and waisted 4 gallon of paint! ☹️

  • 4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    Usually more helpful to start a new topic than hop on one from 9 years ago, but anyways...

    If your paint, when painted with two coats on a piece of posterboard (or similar) and left to dry completely, does not match a new paint chip, it is mixed wrong, and you shouldtake the cans of paint back to the store to have them replaced. Most stores will take back paint that was wrong due to their error ... they'll likely resell the can of mis-mixed paint at a discount (most paint stores have a rack for things like this).