Software
Houzz Logo Print
prestonbeary

Built-Ins Paint Finish Question

17 years ago

My new built-ins in dining room need to be painted. They are surrounding a bay window.

All the windows in my house are painted Ultra Pure White by Behr and I'm wondering if I should paint the bay window trim as well as built-ins that same color to stay consistent with the rest of the house?

The UPW is a semi-gloss finish.

Is this an appropriate paint and finsh for the built-in's or do you recommend something els

I will discuss with the painter but wanted to get others thoughts.

I will post a pic when I find out how?

TIA

Comments (11)

  • PRO
    17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    All the windows in my house are painted Ultra Pure White by Behr and I'm wondering if I should paint the bay window trim as well as built-ins that same color to stay consistent with the rest of the house?

    I'd likely choose consistency. Trim and built-ins are no place to get cute with color without a really, really good reason in my opinion. I mean, can if ya want to, but why.

    If there's a good answer to why, then do it. More often than not, there isn't a good answer to why? and there are other ways to get clever with color in a space -- ways that aren't quite so permanent. Trim and built-ins can be repainted, sure. But those are famous last words.

    I did work on a house where the trim was painted different *colors* and not consistent room to room. It was not a easy thing to pull off. It looks really cool, it looks effortless but I can tell ya, it was anything but effortless. It was worth the work, but...

    Choose wisely and know what you're getting yourself into. The sound of "Ultra Pure White" has a fetching echo of ease to it IMO.

  • PRO
    17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    My take on kitchen cabinet finishes is that kitchen cabinets are an entity on their own. Cabs are a big feature for a kitchen; they are really the most substantial *furniture piece* in that room of the house. That being said, I think kitch cabs deserve to be or can be a separate stand-out finish, treated so that they are indeed a feature. They do not need to match any other trim or door finish in the house.

    I just moved and I have semi gloss on all trim, doors, and built-ins. Happens to be oil which doesn't thrill me, but it is what it is. The semi-gloss aspect, however, I find quite lovely. Kinda amazed at how it can slide from a formal look to a casual one.

    And then we still have the point of consistency. If semi is on the trim, doors, etc., the the built-ins would look out of place in another sheen, IMO.

    Go with semi.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    A "2nd" on a S/G finish...

    Typically, the higher the sheen, the smoother/harder the paints' "binder"-resin is.

    Don't put ANYTHING on the horizontal-areas for a MONTH.
    This allows a fuller cure & hardening-off of the film.
    >>> Sure, it's "dry" in a day...but CURED...Nooooooo!

    Faron

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Okay, 4 days into the painting of the built-ins and there is trouble in paradise! I thought using a pro would save us so much time and trouble - wrong!

    I was all set to use Semi-Gloss as we discussed above but the painter said he'd prefer Satin since that's what he uses on all his built-in jobs and semi would be too "shiny" for such a large piece.

    We took his word and purchased Kilz 2 for primer and Behr UPW Satin for paint as he requested. He stated he wanted the Kilz 2 primer and "whatever paint we wanted to use".

    He has been complaining since the first day he started, first it was "the carpenter should have primed this in his shop and that would have saved me so much time...blah blah blah". Then it was "this is taking much longer than I expected to prep, I forgot that after you prime new wood the grain raises and I've had to do a lot more sanding than I expected". Next it was, "I did not know the bay window (which is in the middle of the 2 built-ins and window seat) was going to be painted - I thought you were staining it yourself. Next, "this Satin is not drying like the Satin finish I'm used to using (supposedly BM brand) maybe we should do Semi-Gloss for the second coat on second thought".

    At this point we asked him if there was another brand of paint he'd like us to purchase for him instead of the Behr since he was having problems with it. He says he usually uses some certain type of paint for trim - cannot remember the name - he said it's a ceramic type finish. Why he didn't tell us this before he started the job is a mystery.

    Anyway, he declined our offer to get his preferred brand of paint and it was decided we'd get Semi-gloss. We left the house for an errand and when we returned home he was gone for the day with a note taped to the door saying "forget the semi-gloss; the satin is drying okay now". Okay - that was a surprise?

    Now today, he is telling my husband the Behr is not covering as expected and this job is taking way longer than he expected so it may need a 3rd coat of paint and he will need more $.

    We politely told him; if it needs a 3rd coat and you are going to charge us more than the agreed upon price, then just forget the 3rd coat. His eyes lit up and he said, "If you're okay with that." I said, "No, it's not what we want but we cannot afford to pay more than the agreed upon price and you (as the professional - using the term loosely) need to decide if you are going to put the 3rd coat on for the original price or just leave and not finish the project. He saw that I was not happy so I'm not sure what will happen. He will be back Friday as the second coat is not yet complete.

    I'm so disgusted at this point; I don't know what to think. I feel like he really does not have a clue. He came very highly recommended by our finish carpenter so I'm tempted to get the carpenter involved - not sure if it would do any good?

    I'm sorry for the LONG rant but I'm really frustrated and fed up with this guy. He acts like he's doing us a favor. I don't want things to turn ugly since he seems like the type that would blow his cork pretty fast. It' like a black cloud has been hanging over our house since he started and part of me just wants him GONE.

    Thanks for reading and if you have any advice, I'd love to hear it.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Fire this guy(not the word I want to use to describe him) now. I was a contractor for a many years, and it reminds me way too much of some of the horrible paint sub-contractors I had hired. Actually, one of those bad painters also came recommended from an excellent carpenter I had build a staircase for me. I have no idea why good painters are so hard to find. Stories like this make me soo glad I am out of that business!! :)

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    It's always a bad sign to me when a painter will use whatever product the customer wants. Why would I let a customer tell me to use Behr when I know there are much better products out there? The painter using the products he wants is better for everybody in the long run.

    Painting is hard to bid, even if you have 20 years experience doing it. Some whites take 2 coats and some take three. If I expect it to take two, I am not going to go crying to the customer for more money when it takes 3. If this is a problem, bid the job for 3 in the beginning to be safe. Really though, it's probably the Behr, so again if the painter is using the products he wants to use, he may not be in this mess. Hopefully over the holiday he will calm down and realize that keeping a customer happy is the most important thing to running a successful business.

    I know why good painters are hard to find. It's too easy to get into the business (everyone thinks they can paint) so everybody does. It hurts our reputation, but it also makes it very easy to stay busy if you are one of the good ones.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    paintguy....i agree with all of your points. and it is true about easy to "get into" the biz.....everyone thinks they can paint but it is more skilled than many think.

    also i should have stated that i have used some excellent painters too that i am very envious of their skills.

    it just sends chills down my back tho thinking of some of the crappy ones that i have been unfortunate enough to have met.(and even paid)

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Just an update to let everyone know the outcome. The painter did end up "finishing" the job for the agreed upon price.

    It was very tense in the house the last couple of days he was there.

    I say "finished" in quotes because I am not satisifed with the outcome but the unit is fully painted. The quality and coverage of the paint are not as I expected - no big surprise based upon my posts above!

    I'm just glad it's over and he's not in my house anymore.

    Lesson learned - will pick painter much more carefully in future!

  • PRO
    17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I guess I was speaking more to the *color* Ultra Pure White more so than "Behr Ultra Pure White". Can't believed I missed an opportunity to tell someone to stay away from Behr. lol! :D 'Cuz that's something I consistently do.

    He could have had UPW color matched in a better grade and brand. Surprised he caved to Behr so easily. All the pro painters I know pitch fits about it and will use it, but you'll pay 'em more for the worry and hassle.

    Sorry it ended so badly and sorry I wasn't more clear about my speaking to the color and sheen aspect of your original post. I feel bad for missing that. I can promise you whenever I get the opportunity to tell people to consider their use of Behr carefully, I do.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    From reading all your frustations with the painter,

    it sounds to me like it is MORE THE PAINTER and he really didn't want to do the job in the first place. Sounds like he was COMPLAINING about something and everything from the get go. Doesn't sound like it was the paint at all.